Exclusiva
The Headlines From Around Latin America and the Hispanic World

David Puente is the anchor for ABC News' "Exclusiva." He regularly reports on immigration and politics in Latin America and the Hispanic community in the U.S.
RECENT POSTS
EXCLUSIVA VIDEO
« Previous | Main | Next »
ARE WE A SYSTEM OF "POWER APARTHEID"?
May 18, 2007 9:36 AM
Will Congress pass it? Will America buy it? The immigration battle in our country has just begun that's for sure. But another battle getting less attention is the battle to make America's most powerful institutions more diverse. In many ways the immigration deal and the record breaking Census Bureau figures also released yesterday that say that America has become more diverse, with minorities topping 100 million for the first time in 2006, go hand in hand.
So as Congress struggles with immigration reform, the population of the United States is growing increasingly darker. Our lawmakers and society at large need to start struggling with better social integration so that our politicians, judges and journalists, all power centers in this country, reflect the diversity of the population. This is currently not the case. America is more diverse, sure, but Integrated?
Yesterday Sen. Arlen Spector, R-Pa., predicted that immigration will become more relevant in American politics than even the issue of social security. Although the immigration reform bill, which would grant legal status to millions of people who are currently in the U.S. illegally, was a bipartisan announcement and has the chance to be historic, a re-energized and extremely heated national debate will take place before any immigration reform has a chance to become law. And in fact it may die and never become law.
There is a long road ahead, and the question now is: Where will the debate lead? With the White House blessing the deal, the unprecedented bipartisanship in this Congress was a singular moment of political harmony. Can this spirit of bipartisanship strengthen across the nation, or will the immigration debate deepen America's cultural divide and hurt diversity efforts in schools, businesses and social organizations?
In fact, there is already strong dissent to the bi-partisan deal in Congress and on Main street. Two senators engaged in the talks from the beginning, Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, and Sen. Robert Menendez, D-N.J., skipped the unveiling of the deal. Both have strong reservations about the compromise. Even Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., refrained from endorsing the bill, which tops 300 pages. Critics call this bill "amnesty" and compare it to the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 passed under Ronald Reagan, which was ineffective in curbing illegal immigration. On the other side, immigration-rights supporters and even the Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi say the Senate bill must be improved on the issues of family and guest workers. They also say "anti-immigrationists" fear "the Browning of America."
The Congressional process begins with debate in the full Senate on Monday, in the end the deal may go by the waste side and not become law. But the battle to make our institutions reflect our newer, more diverse America is a battle that won't go away as easily - a "power apartheid," where Hispanics, Blacks and Asians are not in key political, business and social positions cannot be best for our country. The Census Department estimates that four states and the District of Columbia already have a majority population composed of African, Asian or Hispanic heritage. California leads this diversity trend, home to 21 percent of the nation's minority population. The long term consequences of the growing number of minorities is a test the of the strength of America's commitment to equality of treatment.
A strain is already showing up when we look at who holds positions of power; in businesses, elected office and media across the country. How will the dominant culture in America integrate the new diverse population, in positions of power? I think mainstream America will adapt to the cultures of other ethnicities, not only because of the country's commitment to equality but also because it will prove better for business and society at large.
Undoubtedly, this wave of immigration will change America, perhaps in ways that no immigrant group has before in history. Will these changes help our country? Is this diversity good for America? Do we have a choice? Post your view at the Exclusiva blog.
May 18, 2007 | Permalink | User Comments (34)
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c4df253ef00d83543fa7d53ef
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference ARE WE A SYSTEM OF "POWER APARTHEID"?:
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.
Here in California, many Hispanics are indeed in "key political, business and social positions", such as mayor of L.A. (a former campus radical who explicitly supports illegal immigration and who's a former leader of a racial separatist group), former Lt. Gov (a former member of that same racial separatist group), several state reps. (including former members of that same racial separatist group).
Unfortunately, here in CA it's difficult to find a Mexican-American elected official who isn't to some degree an ethnic nationalistic supporter of illegal immigration. About the only distinction is to what degree they act like they're actually working for Mexico. That doesn't exactly portend well for Puente's vision of "Integration".
Exhibit One
Watch the speaker of the CA Assembly snap to attention and salute Mexico's national anthem after failing to do so for America's national anthem:
Posted by: TLB | May 20, 2007 12:50:49 PM
"Power Apartheid".. Now that's a new one. "Browning"?? Now that is plain Racism added to blatant racism by the media - This article is just as racist as any other of those that are written to promote the criminal illegal aliens who are making obnoxious demands of the American people. I would like to see ABC post one article that reveals the illegal aliens as they truly are... All Illegal aliens are criminals, many if not most are Felons that have stolen identities or forged Social Security numbers in order to further defraud the American people. The illegal aliens are not here to become Americans, the illegal aliens do not adopt the culture and language of the United States, the illegal aliens do not abide by our laws, and We The People (by 90%) do not approve of their demand for amnesty and "benefits" for their illegal behavior. It sounds like the writer of this latest hit piece against The American Citizen is a promoter of anarchy and illegal criminal behavior - it might be worth taking a good look at those who promote and harbor illegal aliens. We (the American people - Red Yellow Black & White - AND Brown) have just about had enough of this insanity.
Posted by: Bill | May 20, 2007 2:37:53 PM
Dear Mercedes,
Most Americans have empathy for those who want to come here for a better life. In fact most of us are immigrants ourselves or are children or grandchildren of immigrants. The problem we face today is that we need to have a safe, orderly, legal process, none of which we have right now.
I blame our politicians for putting us in this mess more than I do the people who have come here illegally. For decades they have refused to enforce our borders and current immigration law, and have lacked the leadership to make positive changes. And now Congress and the President seem to want to wipe the slate clean and say, "sorry, we screwed up but you are just going to have to suck it up for our past mistakes. And by the way we're not going to make any promises that we're going to do any better in the future."
We are a country built on immigrants. We want immigrants here. We just want the process to be fair, and safe while resprecting the current citizens of America.
Posted by: John | May 20, 2007 3:20:48 PM
I have been in this country since President Reagan was re-elected. I entered legally and acquired a PhD from a big University in this country with publication in top science journals. My children are citizens by birth, and despite everything my wife and I did to acquire legal status and make to good use all this education, there is nothing to show for. We entered legally and had been registered, fingerprinted, paying taxes, even paying vehicule insurance and whatever license or fees required including going to traffic school and paying fines and have absolutely no access to any benefits whatsoever. We are struggling with medical bills, and have to make it with meager wages. We are tired of running away, but we are trying to do what is best for our children. We still count ourselves as blessed and would not hesitate to give up what we have for miserable conditions from where we came from. We hope and pray that the American legislators will find it in their wisdom to make this a reality and end this cycle. God Bless.
Posted by: Nacer B. | May 20, 2007 3:55:18 PM
Correct:
Not: "We still count ourselves as blessed and would not hesitate to give up what we have for miserable conditions from where we came from"
Read: "We still count ourselves as blessed and would not hesitate to do it all over again for going back to the miserable conditions from where we came from"
I know you got the point, but want it to be clear.
Posted by: Nacer B. | May 20, 2007 4:14:55 PM
It is pretty sad to read the comments of many people that you can tell by their names that they are also inmigrants, their ancesters came to the United States to get a better life, whether it was because of the Holocaust or because the poor living conditions of their contries, lets face it,the United States is a Diverse country and yes I agree that the people needs to learn the English language, but many of them had already learn it and it is impresionant when you see that they speak both languages when many of us still do not know how to speak our English language.
I bet it took a while for antecendants to learn the English language as well and some of them haven't learn it yet.
Posted by: Yolanda | May 20, 2007 6:16:30 PM
Mercedes,
If all of you demonstrated and activated in your own country the way the illegals do in the US, you could take over your own government for a better way of life in your own country.
The US will run out of resources. You've just admitted you are only here for the money, which is precisley why most illegals come.
Our country to you is only a money tree. That's why you don't respect us, our country, our way of life, or want to assimilate.
It's a bit more than that to us.
Change your own government or come here legally. You (illegals, no matter where they come from) are not the only people who want to come here. Your illegal actions are not fair to law abiding immigrant entrants.
Overall, American people respect our rule of law and order and we are generous and compassionate.
We do not appreciate thieves. The whole world, it seems, wants or needs something from America and we've been a constant source to help them.
I don't care what kind of sob story you have there are American citizens who need work, food, education, medical attention, etc that illegals are getting that our own countrymen need and can not access.
The audacity of a people who would steal into our country illegally, find every loophole they can for every provision they can rob, and then demand more special treatment?
new amnesty bill?
The Dream Act- illegals can pay instate tuition, but Americans cannot.
Go home.
Posted by: Ciel | May 20, 2007 8:50:12 PM
American whites are predominantly xenophobic, and generally detest people from developing countries becoming US citizens. It's ironic that between the 15th & 18th centuries, white people from Europe (where the ancestors of most of America's white people came from) descended on every region of the world and colonized the local people, forcibly taking over their lands, and turning them into their own. They did this in Africa, Australia, New Zealand, the United States, etc. What's infuriating about these white colonizers is that once they established a foothold at the expense of the native people, they erected barriers to restrict other people from coming in.
By the way, if we were to demand the identities of every one who has spoken against the Immigration Bill on this blog we would discover that they are mostly white people. Would you say that is an accident or a coincidence? NO! White people are manifestly racist and xenophobic.
Posted by: Kutias | May 23, 2007 12:39:56 AM
By the way, not every illegal immigrant came from Mexico. In fact not every one even came in illegally. There are a few cases of people whose applications for visa extensions were bungled by the US Immigration. When the mistakes were discovered and were brought to Immigration's attention, Immigration only admitted to them, didn't even say "sorry" and just acted as if these foreigners were mere statistics on their graph chart. For instance, a guy I know had been given a 3-year visa extension by Immigration. 1 & a half years into that extension, Immigration discovered that they had issued the extension in error, and wrote back to cancel it. This immediately put he and his family in automatic illegal status, since they couldn't just get up the next day without elaborate preparation and return to their country. Now, these are some of the people who are counted among America's so-called 12 million illegals. My advice to you is to desist from over-generalizations of how the illegals came into the country. Please do not dump all of them in one basket, because their situations are not the same.
Posted by: Paloma | May 23, 2007 12:53:56 AM
Post a comment