Nightline's Daily Line is our blog, where you’ll be the first to find out what stories we're working on each day. Plus, our anchors, correspondents and staff share the latest behind-the-scenes information from the newsroom and the field.
RECENT POSTS
- 'Nightline' Exclusive: Firsthand Account of Fort Hood Shooting
- Closing Arguments: Obama and Election Day Implications
- Closing Arguments: Best Halloween Costume Ever?
- Closing Arguments: Regulate Extreme Self-Help?
- Closing Arguments: Congress Tackles NFL Head Injuries
- Closing Arguments: Computers in the Cockpit
- Closing Arguments: Scientology's Tax-Exempt Status
- Closing Arguments: Obama Slashing Exec Pay
- Closing Arguments: Does the 'Smart Choice' Label Mislead?
- Closing Arguments: Most Annoying Phrases? Whatever
MONTHLY ARCHIVES
« Previous | Main | Next »
Closing Arguments: Politics of Fear
July 14, 2008 9:47 PM
At the heart of tonight's Closing Argument--a cartoon. But it's one many are not finding funny. The latest issue of "New Yorker" magazine has this drawing as its cover. Entitled " So what do you think about all this? Is it satire or smear?
Politics of Fear" it has Barack Obama and his wife Michelle doing a fist tap in the Oval Office. He's in Muslim clothing and she's armed and in camouflage. Above the mantle piece is a portrait of Osama Bin Laden. In the fireplace is a burning American flag. The magazine's editor says they were trying to satirize the rumors about Senator Obama and his wife. Others do not see it that way. The campaign of Senator Obama called the cover "tasteless and offensive." His GOP counterpart, Senator John McCain, publicly agreed calling the drawing "inappropriate."
July 14, 2008 | Permalink | Share | User Comments (247)
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.
The last time I checked, we still had freedom of speech and freedom of expression in this country. If the Obama robots don't like it, they can find another country to hoodwink...America needs to wake up now! Obama is a fraud. No matter how much of a feel-good or novel choice he may be, he is the WRONG person at the WRONG time!
Posted by: Cy Brown | Jul 14, 2008 10:04:13 PM
Well, it is inappropriate. The picture above the mantle should have been Ahmadinejad, not Osama. Silly New Yorker.
Posted by: SadStateOfAffairs | Jul 14, 2008 10:09:32 PM
BHO just can't shake the terrorist connection. And, for good reason. The roots just run too deep!
Posted by: Aston | Jul 14, 2008 10:17:32 PM
This goes to the Rove tactic of blowing smoke. Tell outlandish stories as way of brainwashing people. It doesn't matter that they make no sense. The message is inside the story: example "birth certificate" means "not one of us", as does "Hussein Obama". "Wh*tey Tape" means "untrustworthy", as does "under the bus ".
Repeated like a mantra, the messages soak in - how else can you explain the chorus of "THAT'S HIM!!!" in response to the New Yorker cover?
Enough smoke and people believe in the fire. In military parlance, it's called 'preparing the battlefield'. When the Swift Boats arrive, they swallow every drop.
Posted by: Snarxon | Jul 14, 2008 10:39:19 PM
BTW - my last (10:39) post is quoting myself on the current 'Image' thread. I copied and pasted because I think it's relevant here.
Posted by: Snarxon | Jul 14, 2008 10:41:49 PM
Snarxon
Boy do you ramble! What are you drinking tonight?
Posted by: Aston | Jul 14, 2008 10:45:18 PM
The cartoon doesn't work as satire because it isn't over the top enough to be obviously satirical and feeds into the ugly lies that have been spread about this candidate. It is also too much to expect or hope that the kind of person who is likely to buy into the smears and also has limited critical thinking skills would get the "joke."
Posted by: mary | Jul 14, 2008 10:51:15 PM
your asses at abc know it not spam its your way of censorship, maybe i need to contact the aclu
Posted by: steve | Jul 14, 2008 10:51:57 PM
yes we do have freedom of speech but that cover was wrong there were other ways to use satire the fact is a lot of people still think obama is muslim AND HES NOT thanks to fox news karl rove oh and lets not forget drug addict limbaugh we can thank them but you know what true obama supporters know who he is and the cover of new yorker is definatley not him
Posted by: angie | Jul 14, 2008 10:58:59 PM
On the one hand, I see the satirical work in the cover. This, of course is my "idealistic" hand, that believes that people see this for what it is. Satire. As in NOT TRUE.
On my other hand, my "rational" hand, I believe that is extremely offensive and only perpetuates the notion that is founded in many low info voters. My point is actually validated in some of the comments found on this board and others.
Posted by: Chris | Jul 14, 2008 11:00:05 PM
OH Dear, is Obama whining and complaining that the New Yorker cover is grossly misrepresenting him? Hmmmm.... considering how he misrepresents other people, he really shouldn't be complaining. He misrepresented Bill Clinton, one of the best recent presidents, someone who advanced the cause of minorities tremendously......Obama made Bill to be a racist. So, how does it feel, Obama, to be misrepresented? You can dish it, but you can't take it, can you? Sorry, I have no sympathy for Obama. He tosses the race card when someone stands in his way, but he whines if he is made to look negative. This is called....divine justice. Deal with it, BHO.
Posted by: Doublestandard | Jul 14, 2008 11:10:29 PM
DOUBLE STANDARD
for your information he is not whining he has made no comment about it his camp has the media has as well as his supporters do you not watch tv and as far as obama making bill clinton a racisit i belive bill made himself look that way remember the sc and jesse jackson statement come to think of it i wouldnt put a past bill or hill being behind this cover of new yorker
Posted by: angie | Jul 14, 2008 11:17:57 PM
BHO should stay out of the kitchen if he cant take the heat. Who does he think he is? POTUS? Lol.
Posted by: brigitte | Jul 14, 2008 11:35:36 PM
Aston: You're a paid stooge. Admit it.
Posted by: Snarxon | Jul 14, 2008 11:37:10 PM
Aston: A smoke-blower, you are. Traitor.
Posted by: Snarxon | Jul 14, 2008 11:45:56 PM
angie -- kindly tell me how comparing Obama to Jesse Jackson, who proclaims himself to be a good friend of Obama's, as racist???? THAT, my dear, is the race card, calling something racist, when there is none. Bill has done so much for all minorities, he is the least racist person around. And Obama and his campaign IS whining about this cover. Deal with it, you can't take the heat, get out of politics. It is very witty satire, and that cover will be a collector's item.
Posted by: doublestandard | Jul 14, 2008 11:59:30 PM
Now now now ... Barak Hussein Obama should run for the presidency of Iran, not the USA. The picture depicts him and Ms Hussein Obama in the Iranian oval office. You see, over here we pray to God and the Bible, not allah and the ignorant koran. By the way ... all of this must be president Bush's fault, as usual. In GOD we trust.
Posted by: phuckalqaeda | Jul 15, 2008 12:04:00 AM
DOUBLE STANDARD
once again obama is not whining the campaign is even mccain said how distasteful it was as far as bill clinton is concerned the statement he made when obama won the sc primary about jesse jackson winning there was racisit but it was ok when hillary was whining sexism right it was wrong didnt see any of her supporters telling her if she couldnt iake the heat get out of the kitchen you hillary supporters are such hipocrites
Posted by: angie | Jul 15, 2008 12:05:45 AM
As I lifelong Republican, I find this cover not even close to freedom of speech...Just offensive!
Posted by: Butch B | Jul 15, 2008 12:09:27 AM
A picture is worth a 1,000 words and, unfortunately, the words inside the New Yorker will not be what people remember.
Posted by: lucidamerican | Jul 15, 2008 12:11:48 AM
Post a comment
