RECENT POSTS
- White House Study Looks at Job Creation in Illinois if Gitmo Prisoners Transferred There
- President Obama: Asia Trip Helped Usher in a New Era of American Engagement
- Secretary Sebelius Celebrates the Tenth Anniversary of National Adoption Day
- Organizing for America Targets Sarah Palin
- Obama Administration Starts to Publicly Raise Issue of Detained US Citizen Xue Feng
- President Obama Gives Interview (of Sorts) to Dissident Cuban Blogger
- "You Guys Make a Pretty Good Photo Op," President Obama Jokes to Troops at Osan Air Base
- Did the Chinese Government Crack Down on an Obama Interview?
- Our Trip to the DMZ
- President Obama Greets U.S. Troops in South Korea, Wraps Up Week in Asia
MONTHLY ARCHIVES
« Previous | Main | Next »
Anti-Catholic Bigotry?
July 31, 2007 6:13 PM
We've already seen allegations of anti-Mormon bigotry in this campaign ... now come charges of anti-Catholic bias.
This fight is between the presidential campaign of Sen. Sam Brownback, R-Kansas, who converted to Catholicism, and the campaign of former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee.
According to the Catholic League, a letter "is being circulated among evangelicals in Iowa asking them not to split the Christian vote between former Arkansas Governor Mike Huckabee and Kansas Senator Sam Brownback; they are urged to vote for Huckabee, an evangelical, over Brownback, a Roman Catholic."
The letter was written by Pastor Tim Rude of Walnut Creek Community Church in Windsor Heights, Iowa. A Huckabee volunteer.
He writes that "Huckabee is an evangelical. He has not learned how to speak to evangelicals; i.e. Bush 41 & 43. He is one of us. I know Senator Brownback converted to Roman Catholicism in 2002. Frankly, as a recovering Catholic myself, that is all I need to know about his discernment when compared to the Governor's. I don't if this fact is widely known among evangelicals who are supporting Brownback."
Says the Brownback campaign: "Governor Huckabee should apologize and denounce this prejudiced whisper campaign," says Brownback's Iowa communications director John Rankin. "Political campaigns should focus on the issues that Americans care about, not make bigoted slurs aimed at a person's faith and character.
We are waiting for a response from the Huckabee campaign.
But in the meantime, I spoke just now to what seemed a very frantic and upset Pastor Rude -- a Huckabee campaign volunteer -- who said this was an email meant for two friends, not wide dissemination. (I called him for a comment before posting.) He sent me an apology letter, which reads in part:
"I was careless in the first place with my words. And obviously, if I knew this private e-mail would somehow not remain private, I would have taken great care not to convey anything that would be offensive to anyone.
"As you know, I support Governor Huckabee first and Senator Brownback as a close second. I have a number of friends working for the Senator and he would make an outstanding president. The reason I wrote this, in the first place, is that this was a major factor in choosing Governor Huckabee over Senator Brownback. I frankly agree theologically more with a Southern Baptist. Perhaps, Mormons are rallying around Mitt Romney and Catholics around Senator Brownback. I don't know.
"In no way do I think a Catholic would not make a great president, in fact, if Governor Huckabee drops out of the race I will support Senator Brownback. But I do apologize for my statements because it could be taken as anti-Catholic which isn't the case at all.
"Again, please accept my apology and I ask for your forgiveness."
This seems, once again, of a case where a candidate is being held responsible for what his supporters are saying -- which is a tough standard for anyone. Especially in the age of the internet, when careless and offensive thoughts can, in mere minutes, make their way onto the website of ABC News.
But what do you think?
-- jt
UPDATE: The Radio Iowa blog provides Huckabee's response -- LINK.
July 31, 2007 in Religion | Permalink | Share | User Comments (22)
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.
Let call global warming, nature worship.
The founders dug up dust of 4ooo years of history.Now look at the richest party of the USA. The fathers use to be GOP, but the kids of the richest oil family are Democrates, Bill Gates the names go on and on. The party of billionares who own most the world stock are Democrates. If the Democrates win big in 2008 there push for global warming issues, will end up taxing the little guy. They use the Government to put more money in there pocket. We will become fewer in number. Our vioce will go under ground.
Posted by: jerry | Dec 16, 2007 1:11:38 PM
I personally have no problem with the pastor's initial remarks. It is his flight to mediocrity that I find more offensive. With first hand experience of the bigotry and prejudice that is propagated from within the catholic church in Kansas(married into a catholic family but I am a steadfast protestant and suffered through years of ridicule and abuse for not converting), so I don't see the problem with the pastor calling it as he sees it. I myself agree emphatically. Our beliefs are a primary facet in defining who we are so why not take those into consideration when selecting a candidate for whom to vote.
Posted by: Leonard | Oct 13, 2007 12:50:41 AM
I have a opinion that most anti-ism wheather it is Mormon, Jewish and Catholic is more economic than any particlar religious dogma.
Protestant reformers are now protesting their faiths because they see a threat to their money, tithes comng in to fill the pockets. In someways the only way it is to make money publishing books and tracts as well as movies such as the Godmakers.
Look at all the money being make from UFO's, 9-11, or Kennedy assassination conspircies and you understand the economics of hatred!
Posted by: OnceUponATime | Aug 4, 2007 1:57:58 PM
Brownback's Catholicism is very low-key. I believe he also attends a protestant church with his family. What is so sad about the minister's comments is when he states, "if I knew this private e-mail would somehow not remain private, I would have taken great care not to convey anything that would be offensive to anyone." I do not remember a Gospel verse relaying the idea that intolerance is acceptable as long as it is only a personally held belief.
Posted by: Joshua | Aug 2, 2007 10:13:22 AM
How did this email get to the news anyway? Did the recipients forward it? It does seem a little shady that a private email found it's way to the Brownback people. Of course, it's not the first time something like this has happened.
Posted by: Agatha | Aug 2, 2007 5:15:25 AM
This pastor doesn't speak for all evangelicals in his Anti-catholic bias. I can say, however, that he is a member of an association of churches that has made the list of several cult watch groups. Here is a link about Tim
Rude's association of churches.
Posted by: agatha | Aug 1, 2007 10:37:56 PM
As a Momron whose Parents are Catholics I find the bigotry unforgiveable. It is amazing that we are discussing what place a religion has on it's cadidiates to this day. You would think we learn from John Kennedy?
Mormons are one worst persecuted religions in the United States. It is sad that hatred is coming out of the woodwork!
Posted by: OnceUponATime | Aug 1, 2007 7:32:27 PM
Just a thought, shouldn't Pastor Rude's congregation and church now be investigated by the IRS for violating their tax-exempt status? He is clearly recommending a specific candidate and that's a violation of the law that gives church their tax-exempt status.
Posted by: Ellen | Aug 1, 2007 4:04:15 PM
When will Christian's be enlightened enough to get along with each other?
Posted by: White Mountain | Aug 1, 2007 3:27:59 PM
No Rudy - No Way. Mike and Sen. Sam are super candidates.
Posted by: trueblueconservative | Aug 1, 2007 2:56:56 PM
A battle between two 2nd rate losers. Who cares?
Posted by: I♡Rudy | Aug 1, 2007 2:54:53 PM
Deos it all really matter? I mean, I like Huckabee (and to a lesser extent Brownback, save for his immigration stance) but let's face it, neither one of them is going to last to the end. It's going to be the big 3 and then maybe Ron Paul who, the more I look at, the more I'm starting to like. But he too isn't going to win and for that matter no GOPer will/can win the election unless things radically improve in Iraq which we hope they do. I don't want to hedge my bets on America's loss.
Posted by: Den | Aug 1, 2007 12:06:32 PM
Deos it all really matter? I mena, I like Huckabee (and to a lesser extent Broback, save for his immigration stance) but let's face it, neither on eof them is going to last to the end. It's goign to be the big 3 and then maybe Ron Paul who, the more I look at, the more I'm starting to like. But he too, isn't goign tot win and for that matter no GOPer will win the election unless things radically improve in Iraq whioch we hope they do. I don't want to hedge my bets on America's loss.
Posted by: Den | Aug 1, 2007 12:00:28 PM
One candidate chooses to adhere to the same irrational/anti-rational view of the world you yourself choose to adhere to. Why wouldn't you prefer that person? Why is that any more controversial than choosing a person based on his or her view of the death penalty?
Posted by: DKNY | Aug 1, 2007 11:19:53 AM
I guess he won't be voting for Giuliani: a pro-choice Catholic. Most people mention the clergy-pedophile scandal and use that to slur all Catholics. At least this guy apologized. Maybe he has a conscience.
Posted by: Sean O'Brien | Aug 1, 2007 9:30:25 AM
There's an unwritten rule which Pastor Rude (I'll forgo the all-too-obvious pun here!) has obviously forgotten: never write an e-mail which you wouldn't want read by the public, because it just might be read by the public. Other than that, though, neither Gov. Huckabee nor Sen. Brownback are responsible for what their supporters do, even when it comes to garnering attention for second- and third-tier candidates who haven't a hope of winning the Republican nomination.
Posted by: chuck | Aug 1, 2007 8:45:25 AM
Huckabee DID denounce the comments from Rude. Huckabee is so much more than just a social conservative. He created healthcare for underprivileged children, he improved the cobblestone interstate highways that Clinton was somehow never able to fix, he improved Arkansas' education system which was ranked at the bottom under Clinton, he cut taxes and still left a huge surplus in Arkansas when he left, and he was a Republican governor elected twice in a state where 86% of elected officials are Democrats, proving he really can get things done working with people from both parties. There is so much more to this man's record and fabulous ideas on tax reform, health care, education, immigration, national security. He is a better communicator than Brownback, and I believe more efficient, and very importantly, one who can beat Hillary in 2008.
Posted by: Liz | Aug 1, 2007 8:10:49 AM
The funniest thing about this situation...
Brownback has spent this entire campaign making closet bigoted remarks, and now he demands apologies?
Oh well, I guess I should give him credit... at least he apologized when his staffers were bigoted. John McCain didn't even bother.
Yeah... Ron Paul... big... big Joke.
Posted by: Brad | Aug 1, 2007 12:45:26 AM
I am someone from Iowa who is sick of all of the phone calls and flyers from lying sell-outs on both sides of our political parties. Neither side cares about real average people whose beliefs are somewhere in the middle.Like wanting to reduce taxes without putting the elderly into the streets. Where did common sense go in this country? By the way Jesus wasn't a Republican or a Democrat and I am sick of his name being used for polical and financial gain.
Posted by: Luella lynn | Aug 1, 2007 12:31:45 AM
Two bottomrungers fighting for 9th place, wow what a campaign.
Posted by: Hakim | Jul 31, 2007 10:55:12 PM
Post a comment


