Political Punch
Power, pop, and probings from ABC News Senior White House Correspondent Jake Tapper

« Previous | Main | Next »

Iowa City Councilman Calls Mormonism a Cult

December 13, 2007 11:55 AM

The Mormon faith of presidential candidate Mitt Romney continues to receive scrutiny and criticism in ways that would likely not be so vocally aimed at any faith other than, perhaps, Islam.

In Marion, Iowa, City Councilman Craig Adamson -- a registered Republicans who considers himself a supporter of Mike Huckabee -- sent out an email asserting that if "you think religion, especially Christianity, is being marginalized by ACLU and other organizations" then "you would be piling on" if you vote for Mitt Romney because "Mormonism is a cult. In case I didn't type it clearly enough … Mormonism is a cult."

As first reported on the Iowa Caucus Cooler blog, Adamson wrote that "based on my knowledge of Mormonism, I would not trust him as my president as he might be fooled into believing most anything. How could he possibly be trusted to negotiate with Islamic radicals? He might believe Muslim and Mormons are the same, just like he tries to pass off Mormons as Christians."

Adamson sent the email to a friend who had invited him to a Romney event, hitting "reply all."

In an interview, Adamson - who considers himself a Christian who believes that "Jesus Christ died to save me from my sins both now and in my future" -- confesses to bad e-mail etiquette and suggests his objections to Romney are not just faith-based.

"Whether or not you believe what Mormonism has to say, Romney has flip-flopped on important issues such as whether or not he's pro life," Adamson says.

But he goes on to say that Romney's faith bothers him. "If you've delved into the Mormon faith at all there's a lot to swallow," he says. "Mormonism tries to assimilate itself as mainstream Christianity."

The 35-year-old married father of two, who runs a financial consulting business and has been in city council for two years, says none of this means "that Mormons are bad people. It just means I am never going to agree that they are Christians."

Adamson intends to attend the Republican caucuses in Iowa on January 3. While he's strongly leaning towards Huckbee, a former Baptist preacher, he considers Huckabee weak on illegal immigration and likes the views of Rep. Tom Tancredo, R-Colo., on that issue. The only matter he seems sure of is that he's "going to campaign against Mitt Romney. He's a very educated man -- there's a lot of very educated people that are Mormon. Orrin Hatch is a Mormon; he's been in the Senate for like 100 years. But if you're going to be in positions of responsibly it does trouble me."

"Mormonism is a cult," he says again. "I'm not going to back down on this."

Says Romney campaign spokesman Kevin Madden, “Governor Romney continues to believe that this campaign should not be about questioning a candidate’s faith. While it is fair to criticize a candidate’s record or policy positions, we would strongly disagree with anyone who would choose to make disparaging remarks about a candidate’s personal faith."

And he notes that Romney said in his speech at the George Bush Presidential Library just last week, "I am an American running for President. I do not define my candidacy by my religion. A person should not be elected because of his faith nor should he be rejected because of his faith."

In other anti-Mormon news, a Baltimore Sun columnist actually weighs in on whether or not Romney wears the garments preferred by some members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. (60 Minutes' Mike Wallace took a look at this LDS practice HERE.) A Sun reporter used a bathroom at one of the Romneys' many mansions and took a peek.

This is one of the reasons why people hate the media.

And on Bloomberg TV, Huckabee is asked what he meant when he asked a New York Times Magazine reporter, "Don't Mormons believe that Jesus and the devil are brothers?" 

"Where were you going with this comment and is it reasonable for people to question how an ordained minister would ask this kind of question?" asked Peter Cook.

"No, because I don't know that much about the Mormon faith," Huckabee responded. "I haven't studied Mormonism.  I have enough trouble keeping up with Baptist theology.  I'm a Baptist.  The reporter actually knew more about the Mormon faith than I did.  It was a question that was asked, 10 words, in the context of about a three- to four-hour conversation that we had over a period of several days.  Somehow, 10 words got lifted out of an 8,100-word article and it’s unfortunate.  I’m not, you know, talking about somebody else’s faith.  It’s not my job to discuss it."

Would any religious belief, if practiced by a minority population, withstand such scrutiny?

-- jpt

December 13, 2007 | Permalink | Share | User Comments (38)

User Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

"In 1846, this same mentality drove the Mormons out of their homes, just across the river in Nauvoo Il., about this time of year, in the dead of winter."
--- this is because they were practicing polygamy. Somthing that Christians of the time found absolutely destestible to have in their community. Mormons seem to conveniently leave this fact out when they are talking about their church's persecution.

Posted by: S | Dec 13, 2007 6:28:38 PM

Again, calling the LDS church a cult is not an effort to be accurate (since the defintion of cult is pretty darn ambiguous) it is merely an insult and anyone who does so should be embarrassed. It's like me calling your wife a wench. True, any woman fits the definition of wench but it would obviously be insulting to call anyone a wench.

So just be aware that if you call my faith a cult, I'll just assume that you are rude. It certainly doesn't indicate that you have anything intelligent to say since few if any can even explain why the LDS faith would fits the definition of cult except in the way that ALL faiths do.

Posted by: ep1433 | Dec 13, 2007 5:57:42 PM

Christ put is best when he said, "by their fruits ye shall know them". If the LDS Church is a bad tree...how is it producing good fruit? You will be hard pressed to find a more decent, law abiding, honest, and charitable group then the Mormons.

At the roaring pace the Mormon Church is growing among every nation, kindred, tongue, and people you will soon realize that your bigoted voice is rapidly dwindling. America's bigots have always become the minority.


" How long can rolling water remain impure? What power shall stay the heavens? As well might man stretch forth his puny arm to stop the Missouri river in its decreed course, or to turn it up stream, as to hinder the Almighty from pouring down knowledge from heaven, upon the heads of the Latter-day Saints."

-Joseph Smith

Posted by: BMOC2007 | Dec 13, 2007 5:48:19 PM

If your a Mormon you should not be a presidential candidate because next thing you know it will be illegal for a black person to merry a white person ore else he'll be executed or throughn in the clank for 50 years. Or church being banned it's just not right.

Posted by: zacary baker | Dec 13, 2007 5:42:51 PM

Adamson is "going to campaign against Mitt Romney. He's a very educated man -- there's a lot of very educated people that are Mormon. Orrin Hatch is a Mormon; he's been in the Senate for like 100 years. But if you're going to be in positions of responsibly it does trouble me."

Is the counsilman troubled by all educated people, or all Mormons, or only troubled by Mormons that are educated?
I wonder how Mr. Adamson feels about educated Atheist women in positions of responsibility.

I wonder if remaining uneducated is the glue that Mr. Adamson uses to keep his faith in tact.

Posted by: proed | Dec 13, 2007 4:50:21 PM

The Councilman and anti Mormons are scared of losing the Primary to a much stronger candidate in Mitt Romnney.They are chicken out already and go on the anti Mormon tactic which is all they've got to offer.What a lot of failure in these type of people with less undestanding of the real issues matters to most Republicans.How can this man become a Councilman if he doesn't speak and act like it,he sounds unintelligent and immature next to being a handycap.

Posted by: kmjjp | Dec 13, 2007 4:43:24 PM

The people on this blog probably have never read the Book of Mormon, the Doctrine and Convenants, or the Pearl of Great Price. Those are all Mormon texts that Mormon's consider first before the Bible. The Bible talks about being aware against false doctrine and against other texts that are not from God. Mormonism is not Christian because they do not believe in the Jesus of the Bible. It is a Jesus invented by Joseph Smith and nothing else.

Posted by: A.S. | Dec 13, 2007 2:48:06 PM

Hmmm...
"I would personally consider anyone that believes god spoke to their churches founder through a magic hat as one that calls someones judgement into question. eh?"

That is quite the mischaracterization. That would be like referring to Giuliani, a Catholic, saying:

"I would personally consider anyone that believes that the wafer and wine in the mass actually becomes flesh and blood of a Jew who lived 2000 years ago is one that calls their judgement into question," or how about Hillary Clinton the Methodist:

"I would personally bring into question the mentality of someone who believes that the earth was created in just six 24-hour periods."

Moral: Don't try to mischaracterize the beliefs of another-you may misunderstand yourself what they actually believe.

Posted by: Fairness | Dec 13, 2007 2:30:46 PM

Mormonism IS a cult. Get over it.

"In an interview, Adamson - who considers himself a Christian who believes that "Jesus Christ died to save me from my sins both now and in my future"

Could you be a little more condesending with your tone please? I don't think everyone got it. He "considers himself a Christian"?

Posted by: Scott | Dec 13, 2007 2:18:49 PM

"It just means I am never going to agree that they are Christians." -
Craig Adamson

If the councilman is trying to state that The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is not a "Protestant Christian" church, then he is absolutely right, and he just stated it poorly.

If he is trying to say that Mormons do not worship, honor, and believe in Jesus Christ, he is absolutely wrong.

The problem lies in the sentance where he states: "based on my knowledge of Mormonism..." Most Americans know little to nothing about the 4th largest church in the U.S., and usually receive their information from inaccurate or at least mis-informed sources.

Believe what you want, but LDS Church members are Christians in every sense of the word --just not protestant or catholic Christians.

Posted by: DavidJ | Dec 13, 2007 2:14:05 PM

You know, a lot of Trinity-Christian priests and pastors were afraid that endorsing Mitt Romney might help the Mormon church. What's funny, in my opinion, is just how much their efforts to persecute Romney for his faith might actually help the Mormons. For example, the idea of sacred underclothes that represent a promise made to God is not really very strange. It is only strange for as long as it is totally unfamiliar. The more they make a big deal about Mitt's holy undies, the less strange they'll seem. Also, there aren't really too many truly weird things about Mormonisms beginnings. Joseph Smith had visions and used material aids (seer stones, golden plates, papyri, etc.) to obtain new scripture. He and his followers married multiple women (in Joseph's case, some of the women were already married to other men civilly [and those husbands sanctioned the marriage]). Brigham Young said some racist stuff. Well, in all honesty, the only major practioners of multipe-wifery today are the Muslims. There are MANY muslims with more than one wife living in America. No one talks about that. And, for whatever reason, people are less shocked because they expect that from Muslims. The more the press bring up weirdness from Mormonsims early days, the less shocking it will be. It will soon be logged in as "those quirky 19th century Mormons did that" and the press will try in vain to find really good modern stuff.

Posted by: Deseretian | Dec 13, 2007 1:59:13 PM

Mormons ARE a cult.

There, I said it.

Posted by: Oscar | Dec 13, 2007 1:32:20 PM

How many times must we Mormans turn the other check when we are called names, lied about and spit upon.

One of the strongest non Christian beliefs we adher to is the Saviour's, Jesus Christ, teachings of turn the other cheek and forgive all men seventy times seventy. This is why you will never find the Morman Church attacking any church or individual.

Posted by: Estreet | Dec 13, 2007 1:31:25 PM

Don't you just love the open minded Iowan's.

In 1846, this same mentality drove the Mormons out of their homes, just across the river in Nauvoo Il., about this time of year, in the dead of winter.

Men, Women and Children were driven from their property and homes, which were then stolen from them as they were pushed across a frozen river into the Iowa wilderness, to perish. Hundreds never made it to the valleys of the Rockies.

The anti's thought the Mormons were
"dun in fer good, this time"

Well, guess what bigots?
"They're Baack".

Not only have the Mormons re-purchased properties which were stolen from them
160 years ago, they have restored the city of Nauvoo, even re-built their Temple, which was desecrated by "Good Christian Folk".

Nauvoo is now a larger tourist attraction than anything the state of Iowa has to offer.

Carry on with your attitudes, pass them on to your children, but just remember, that the Mormons know their history and your game is neither intelligent nor original.

You would have been there with painted faces at Carthidge.

Have a good day and have a piece of pie.

ajarizona

Posted by: cjarizona | Dec 13, 2007 1:19:48 PM

I would personally consider anyone that believes god spoke to their churches founder through a magic hat as one that calls someones judgement into question. eh?

Posted by: Hmm | Dec 13, 2007 1:12:39 PM

phillygirl64 is correct. The term cult is so broadly defined that all faiths would equally apply. But what I find more disconcerting is that, because there is no specific definitional reason to call the LDS faith a cult, one can only assume that is is being done as a pejorative effort. basically it is an effort to insult, not to be correct (since the term is so ambiguous). When others call my faith a cult, I am tempted to call their wife a wench. Th term wench is often defined as a woman so I wouldn't be innaccurate to call a woman a wench would I? But let's be honest, it would be equally insulting and equally unfair.

Posted by: ep1433 | Dec 13, 2007 12:55:49 PM

in the beginning, Christ and his followers were considered a cult, too

Posted by: phillygirl64 | Dec 13, 2007 12:27:28 PM

Courtesy of Meriam Webster:
CULT
1: formal religious veneration : worship
2: a system of religious beliefs and ritual; also : its body of adherents
3: a religion regarded as unorthodox or spurious; also : its body of adherents

By definition, it would appear that all religions are a cult of some nature. We should all just let people believe as they wish. The only time that it should matter in a presidential candidate is if it affects his competency--and I believe that Romney's experience clearly demonstrates that he is more than competent.

Posted by: Frank | Dec 13, 2007 12:26:51 PM

Post a comment





 

POLITICAL VIDEOS