Political Punch
Power, pop, and probings from ABC News Senior White House Correspondent Jake Tapper

« Previous | Main | Next »

Let's Go to the Videotape

January 29, 2008 10:22 AM

With at least tacit encouragement of the Clinton campaign, enough left-wing bloggers and emailers have accused ABC News of somehow doctoring the transcript of former President Bill Clinton's comments in which he compared Barack Obama to Jesse Jackson that we're going to post the entire 11 minute video.

I recognize that some people are so hopelessly partisan this will not satisfy them. They will change the subject, or even perhaps insanely accuse us of doctoring the video, CGI-style.

They don't want to believe that Bill Clinton did this the way the media portrayed it. And desire can be a powerful emotion.

That said, facts are stubborn things.

Fact: on the morning of the South Carolina primary, when it was clear to her campaign that Sen. Hillary Clinton was on her way to a massive defeat, Bill Clinton, unprompted, compared Obama's win to Jackson's.

Fact: he had not been asked by anyone about Jackson when he did so. 

Fact: despite claims from the Clinton campaign, he had not been asked whether an African-American could win the state when he did so.

Fact: Bill Clinton didn't compare Obama's (then pending, but obvious to the Clinton campaign) state win to those of John Edwards in 2004, Al Gore in 2000, or even his own win in 1992. He reached back to 1984 and 1988 when Jesse Jackson won.

Fact: our transcript bears this out.

Fact: the video bears this out.

But hey, don't take our word for it. Watch for yourself HERE.

- jpt

January 29, 2008 | Permalink | Share | User Comments (17)

User Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

What is happening to this country? Don't get pulled into a race debate. Look at the real issues that matter, the war and the economy (and the future), get past the spin, and pick a leader for America's sake.

Posted by: nep | Jan 30, 2008 3:22:06 AM

Jake....good article...I think you got almost all the possible Clinton spin covered....except for the big one of course.

It wasn't even Bill Clinton on the tape....it was an outer-space alien dressed up as Clinton. Once Obama wins....the aliens will attack the USA just as Hillary said they would in New Hampshire! Remember what happened to Gordy Brown!

Posted by: AW | Jan 30, 2008 2:06:54 AM

I don't buy it. I compared Obama's South Carolina win to Jesse Jackson's before I heard of Bill Clinton doing it. I'm a black male. Am I racist? This is just one more example of Obama's supporters playing the race card, and it's getting old. Obama and Jackson both won South Carolina with 55% of the vote on the strength of black voters while still running behind nationally. I'm sorry, but it's a natural comparison to make.

As a black male, it's disheartening that you continue to claim Hillary's campaign played racial politics against Obama. The reverse is more accurate.

Obama's South Carolina campaign chair, Jesse Jackson Jr., crassly declared that Hillary never shed tears about Katrina victims in response to her famous "welling-up" incident in New Hampshire. Isn't that playing the race card? Where is the outrage from Obama supporters?

Soon after, Obama's staffers released a memo implying that Hillary's campaign was "racially insensitive." For proof, the memo referenced Hillary's MLK-LBJ gaffe and Bill's "fairly tale" speech. Hillary's comparison was clunky and ill-advised but hardly racist. The fairy tale Bill referred to was Obama's Iraq war vacillation, not to race. Yet rather
than criticize this dirty trick, pundits bought into the lie that the Clintons are bigots.

It's disappointing that reporters are too politically correct to confront Obama about his campaign's abuse of racial politics.

The sad part is neither Obama or Jesse Jackson are making this particular South Carolina incident a race thing. It's Obama's supporters who refuse to let the racial dog lie. And it's going to backfire against their candidate if they keep it up.

Posted by: DJK | Jan 29, 2008 5:18:54 PM

Now, it is obvious that Clintons have become cult leaders, just like Rev. Moon couple of the Unification Church, so their follwers would blindly believe whatever they say and reject whatever others say. It's getting really scary.

Posted by: Mia | Jan 29, 2008 4:52:03 PM

It's not the facts that are in dispute, but your interpretation of the facts. I really didn't think that the mere mention of Jesse Jackson was a "smear." Jesse doesn't think so, in fact, he's voting for Hillary. I think it's pretty clear that Bill had seen the polls, and knew that Hillary was losing badly. So, when he was asked the stupid, baiting paparazzi question, "How does it feel, ganging up on Obama?" he rejected the premise, and brought up a historical example of another black man, with a "Rainbow Coalition," who didn't do so well after South Carolina. Now, I don't think Obama will disappear on February 5, but he was just being philosophical in the face of an impending whupping. The objections to the relentless "battle of the clips" in our presidential elections stands. They never mean what they say. Dean's "scream" was a bad mike, which the nets decided not to mix with audience sounds. It made him look crazy. They were helped in that interpretation by the Kerry and Dick Gephardt running ads, seconded by the DC establishment, that echoed what Limbaugh and Rove had been saying about Dean for weeks. Dean's a "radical" who's angry. Instead, we got the insufferably boring Kerry, who now supports Obama.
Very similar to the ganging-up on Hillary. The press wanted her out by New Hampshire, and they were appalled when she won. The press immediately stopped sliming her as a woman and took off on her "racist" husband. Just happens that meshes with Obama's need to get some more black votes in South Carolina. Hmm.
So now, it may be "obvious" to many in the press that this remark was a slap, but that's just because you guys in the cocoon just talk to each other. I believe it was also "apparent" to you guys that Bush was a nice guy and Gore was crazy and would do anything to get elected, even defeat Bush in the debates, and Saddam had WMD.
By the way, how does it feel when Bob Herbert uses one of your craziest commenters to "prove" the slimy tactics of Clinton?

Posted by: Jim H | Jan 29, 2008 3:49:43 PM

Congratulations on your show of backbone, Mr. Tapper. A more tremulous reporter would have simply passed along the Clinton-camp spin.

Posted by: Creamy Goodness | Jan 29, 2008 3:44:20 PM

nice rant. What do you do for an encore - start a flame war?

Posted by: cordelia525 | Jan 29, 2008 2:11:18 PM

This video is highly exculpatory for President Clinton - indeed, it's an "aha" moment - and ABCNews should apologize.

He'd just come off a lengthy discussion of civil rights, black voters, and leaders like Andrew Young and John Lewis. Then he mentions Jesse Jackson in the context of race-baiting.

Clearly, it didn't "come out of nowhere" as ABCNews and Jake Tapper have claimed.

You owe President Clinton an apology.

Posted by: Tom W. | Jan 29, 2008 12:28:05 PM

What upsets me, as a black woman, is that the mere mention of Jessie Jackson's name has now become the race card. And, I would further say that if there were no Jessie Jackson after the death of Martin Luther King, their probably would have NOT have been a Senator Barack Obama. Instead of Barack running from Jessie Jackson he could have, especially in South Carolina were Jessie did, in fact, when 2 Caucasus because of the black vote, acknowledged that he was walking in the footsteps previously set by Jessie Jackson and many other civil rights leaders. That would, in deed, show true courage on the part of Obama. What I also noticed during Obama's victory speech was the audience that was used as a backdrop for his speech -- they wereabout 95% white. How could that be with an 80% black turnout in support of Obama. It was done intentionally so as not to frighten the white community with his overwhelming black support. Let's be real -- Bill Clinton can not make Obama a black candidate, nor can a landscape of adoring young white people, make America color-blind. I am very proud of Barack and if he should get the nomination, I will support him. However, I am not ashamed of Jessie Jackson -- he is not perfect, but he has paved the way for many African Americans, and what is truly hurtful is how the predominantly white media has reduced him to a race card.

Posted by: Diane | Jan 29, 2008 11:42:25 AM

maddymappo and all the other Libs - Dont you watch your own liberal news shows?
WMDs were there and Hussein was planning on building them up again once we left!! DUH!! So I expect an Apology to our President for the false allegations from you libs!!

daron - Open your eye all and all dirty tricks, lies, misconduct come from the libs!! ALL Proven!

Posted by: spock | Jan 29, 2008 11:23:47 AM

Facts are facts, and the fact here is that the Husband-Who-Will-Not-Shut-Up is becoming more of a liability to his wife's campaign than an asset. Although in this campaign, he is certainly trying to make an asset of himself, without the last syllable.

Posted by: chuck | Jan 29, 2008 10:59:48 AM

Jake,

Thank you for getting the truth out. I heard a well-known pundit repeat this morning that the statement was taken out of context. It clearly wasn't.

Posted by: Susan | Jan 29, 2008 10:54:07 AM

Kevin, you are insane. The dirtiest of tricks is always from the right side. Dems aren't perfect and all aren't white as the pure snow, but anyone who doesn't acknowledge that the right is more known for their dirty tricks is just completely in denial.

Posted by: daron | Jan 29, 2008 10:53:18 AM

The Clintons are smearing Obama because when it came to the most important life and death vote of her entire Senatorial "experience" , Hillary voted to give Bush the authority to preempt war in Iraq. Now after nearly 4,000 American lives have been lost, hundreds of thousands of Iraqis are dead and 2 trillion dollars spent, she says no one can know the future. But it was not a wrong decision based on predicting the future, it was a wrong decision based on her inability to clearly view the present. She did not understand the “urgency of now”. There was never any evidence of WMD or an Iraq/Al Qaeda connection. She made her decision because she was all wrapped up in the feelings and fears of the public and the political correctness of materializing an enemy to fight for the moment.

Posted by: maddymappo | Jan 29, 2008 10:53:14 AM

Barack Obama is to 2008 as jesse Jackson was to 1988. It is the truth.

Posted by: geevill | Jan 29, 2008 10:40:24 AM

Thank you so much for consistently calling out these lies and distortions, doing so in a frank, unambiguous manner, and backing up your statements with full transcripts and (now) video. So refreshing to see folks in the media take a stand and unspin the candidate's statements.

Posted by: Kevin | Jan 29, 2008 10:39:26 AM

If you want to get rid of these dirty tricks then vote out the Democrats!!

Look what they did to Lieberman!!

Posted by: spock | Jan 29, 2008 10:30:39 AM

Post a comment





 

POLITICAL VIDEOS