Political Punch
Power, pop, and probings from ABC News Senior White House Correspondent Jake Tapper
RECENT POSTS
- Obama Pushes Back Amid Criticism Over G-8 Progress on Iran
- While the President's Away, Health Care will Stray?
- 'My Cousin In Kenya Can't Get a Job Without Paying a Bribe': Obama Tells African Leaders to Get Their Houses in Order
- 'Camp Obama' for Malia and Sasha
- When In Rome...? Actually, not so much
- President Obama Shakes Hands with Qadaffi
- More Qs for O's WH - 7/9/2009
- President Obama Urges Major Economies Forum Nations to Act on Climate Change
- Today's Qs for O's WH - 7/9/2009
- Whom Should the White House Invite to Its 2010 Nuclear Non-proliferation Summit?
MONTHLY ARCHIVES
« Previous | Main | Next »
Did McCain Flip-Flop On Torture?
February 15, 2008 9:49 AM
This week, Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., voted against an intelligence bill that stated:
"No individual in the custody or under the effective control of an element of the intelligence community or instrumentality thereof, regardless of nationality or physical location, shall be subject to any treatment or technique of interrogation not authorized by the United States Army Field Manual on Human Intelligence Collector Operations."
Andrew Sullivan, who has written admiringly of McCain's anti-torture position in the past, describes himself as "heartbroken."
"I simply cannot see any explanation for this except politics - that McCain feels the need to appease the Republican far right at this point in time,...McCain has indeed been a leader in preventing the military from torturing terror suspects, and in banning waterboarding. But by leaving this lacuna in the law, he gives this president the space he wants. As president himself, of course, McCain would surely instruct the CIA to uphold the American way of interrogation, and not to adopt techniques once used by the Gestapo and prosecuted by the US as war crimes. But we now know that there will be one difference between Obama and McCain in November. One will never tolerate torture; the other just did."
McCain insists that he remains opposed to torture and waterboarding, but that this bill would have applied military standards to the CIA, which he opposes. As McCain said on the Senate floor:
"It was not my intent to eliminate the CIA interrogation program, but rather to ensure that the techniques it employs are humane and do not include such extreme techniques as waterboarding. I said on the Senate floor during the debate over the Military Commissions Act, 'Let me state this flatly: it was never our purpose to prevent the CIA from detaining and interrogating terrorists. On the contrary, it is important to the war on terror that the CIA have the ability to do so. At the same time, the CIA’s interrogation program has to abide by the rules, including the standards of the Detainee Treatment Act.'"
McCain argued that when the Congress voted to apply the Army "Field Manual to the Department of Defense, it deliberately excluded the CIA. The Field Manual, a public document written for military use, is not always directly translatable to use by intelligence officers. In view of this, the legislation allowed the CIA to retain the capacity to employ alternative interrogation techniques. I’d emphasize that the DTA permits the CIA to use different techniques than the military employs, but that it is not intended to permit the CIA to use unduly coercive techniques
indeed, the same act prohibits the use of any cruel, inhumane, or degrading treatment."
"What we need is not to tie the CIA to the Army Field Manual, " McCain said, "but rather to have a good faith interpretation of the statutes that guide what is permissible in the CIA program."
Lots of supporters of the bill, of course, say that the CIA hasn't proven itself to be interpreting their statutes in "good faith" and thus need this law.
President Bush is going to veto it anyway, as White House spox Dana Perino said in a gaggle yesterday morning, because "it would repeal the entire enhanced interrogation program that this Congress passed on a bipartisan basis in October of 2006. It's the program that General Hayden has said has saved lives. This is not the President talking, this is the intelligence community...
"Do you trust the intelligence community more than you trust Democrats who are beholden to their left wing?"
What do you make of this all?
- jpt
February 15, 2008 | Permalink | Share | User Comments (27)
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.
McCain didn't flip flop. He "adjusted to the realities."
Trust the intelligence community? After the crap they let Bush pull to start this war, no one in their right mind would trust them.
Real professionals know that torture doesn't work. Thugs and drug dealers, they torture because they are nasty and have no morals. Which group does the IC identify with?
Posted by: Tommy Times | Feb 23, 2008 3:24:02 PM
If Governor Huckabee gets cheated out of this race, many people are either not going to vote, or we will vote Obama.
So since the Republican establishment thinks they are so smart, be prepared to lose the white house.
Our GOP leaders should have stepped in a long time ago and put a stop the the unethical campaign Romney was running. Especially when he robo called millions of people prior to Super Tuesday to tell un suspecting Americans that Huckabee had dropped out of the race.
Huckabee should be leading right now. Just because he is not, doesn''t mean he shouldn''t be.
I am sickened that we have an awesome leader who is getting short shafted.
Posted by: Dan Campbell | Feb 16, 2008 7:17:42 PM
Senator McCain will do whatever - say whatever he must to get elected. Changing his spots should be expected, for it is a well-known trait (never mind his cowardace of 2004, when he could have made history by joining the Kerry campaign as a running mate).
If one wants a continuation of the Bush-Cheney Regime's policies, absolute cast your ballot for Senator McCain.
On the other hand, if one really wants to purge the White House - and the U.S. - of the stench permeating for the past 7 years, one will seriously consider sending the Republican Party packing. Collaboratively, the Party and its collective arrogance has dragged our poor country into a murky mess.
I know - at age 58 - I will not see full recovery from the destruction of the past 7 years. With that said, the sooner we commence repair, the better off we'll all be.
Posted by: Mylon Stark | Feb 16, 2008 12:15:05 PM
John McCain is a political Ozzy Osbourne. The heavy metal God only sold his soul for Rock and Roll while the Arizona senator decided to cash in his integrity for political power.
Posted by: Jonathan Berr | Feb 15, 2008 10:28:05 PM
Shame on those of you that have no problem letting our civil liberties get eroded by this administration. You've done exactly what the terrorists wanted us do. So....we were a nation of principles until 9/11, and then a terrorist attack changes everything? Pathetic. The Pledge of Allegiance used to mean something. Remember "liberty and justice for all"?. How about "innocent until proven guilty"? Are those concepts gone forever? The definition of terrorism, according to the American Heritage Dictionary is: "The unlawful use or threatened use of force or violence by a person or an organized group against people or property with the intention of intimidating or coercing societies or governments, often for ideological or political reasons." Oh, and Bush says they hate us for our freedom. Maybe he's right, but our government has done EXACTLY what the terrorists wanted. They've bled us financially on our own stupidity and made us suspicious of each other. Every time we cut into our own rights and freedoms, THEY WON! We've done more damage to ourselves and our reputation than they could have ever achieved! Our strength lies in our laws, principles, and our resolve. We are (or were) the standard bearer for liberty worldwide, and dropping down to the level of an enemy is absolutely despicable. Freedom means something; we're turning the word into nothing more than an empty slogan. Our founding fathers would be horrified! Please, take a step back and look at what some of you are advocating.
Posted by: bartonizer | Feb 15, 2008 8:18:46 PM
John McCain can pander all he wants. He can flip flop all his personnel standards away to try and please the current republican base but he has no chance. Straight Talk my ...
Posted by: Flip Flop | Feb 15, 2008 7:01:30 PM
As far as I'm concerned, John McCain can no longer be trusted (assuming he ever could have been). He has sold his soul to the right-wing devil in return for the GOP nomination, and as a result, is rapidly losing the independent voters to Barack Obama. And as we all know, you can't win the presidency without the support of the majority of independent votes.
You can't have it both ways any longer, Mr. McCain.
Disturbingly, a vote for McCain *really is* a vote for a third term of GW Bush....
Posted by: Mark | Feb 15, 2008 4:35:31 PM
Spock Brother states:
"You libs would rather millions of Americans die before you put someones head under water. There is no lasting affect to water boarding"
You make this point. Maybe you got the one in a million ticking time bomb scenario going on. And any President in that scenario that does not have what it takes to protect the country ain't worth #@%&. I am not gonna disagree in this regard.
But on a larger scale let me ask you this: When did torture become A FAMILY VALUE?
ANSWER: it never did. Torture is not consistent with conservative values.
I really don't know why it so hard for some on this side to admit the obvious. Torture ain't good for anyone ..... not for you, not me or my kids, nor for our enemies.
GW1 issued a general order back in the day. This order said this: no torturing the enemy whether it be Red Coats or hired TERRORIST Hessian mercenaries.
I'll give McC some time here. Because I ain't perfect. Maybe there is a loophole that has him covered and I haven't seen it yet.
But the Torture issue is simple. I am not for it. I am not defending it.
Posted by: The Commander Guy | Feb 15, 2008 2:22:43 PM
"Did she realy say that? Here's your answer Dana. Who got us into this war...the 'intellingence community.'"
The intelligence community is doing a pretty good job, not much to complain about there. No attacks in more than six years, that's amazing. That's well spend tax dollars right there.
Posted by: DanielK | Feb 15, 2008 2:19:51 PM
What about Obama and Clinton ?
I have heard they didn't vote. Is it true ?
One flip flop, and two cowards ?
Posted by: Cecile | Feb 15, 2008 2:18:25 PM
"Do you trust the intelligence community more than you trust Democrats who are beholden to their left wing?"
Did she realy say that? Here's your answer Dana. Who got us into this war...the "intellingence community." I'll trust the left wing Democrats, thank you.
Posted by: leo | Feb 15, 2008 1:00:13 PM
pt - First of all it was Pres Bush 41 that supported McCain today!! Shows libs don't read.
If you go by what you libs say is torture, then why do you allow our children to be tortured everyday!! You playing rap music loud is torture ! Don't our kids play rap music louder!!
You libs would rather millions of Americans die before you put someones head under water. There is no lasting affect to water boarding.
Posted by: spock | Feb 15, 2008 12:17:44 PM
I have contacted Andrew about this subject and suggested to him that he talk directly with McCain for clarification. To suggest that somebody held as a POW would in any way condone torture is just downright stupid. McCain has walked the walk unlike all of us responding here including Andrew and others that make a living being controversial. It simply amazes me that those that are certain what torture is and in what circumstances are the very same people that support the right to abort the unborn without any regard to their destiny. Barack believes he is destined for greatness. How fortunate that his mom chose to let him live and become all that he can be and how lucky for us. How many Baracks, McCains have been killed in the name of convenience and how utterly hypocritical of those passing judgment on a man that was held against his will for over FIVE LONG YEARS. How many of you would have survived the first day with a broken body, let alone 3 years in solitary confinement? Shame on you. We should be embracing this sort of character instead of looking for reasons to doubt somebody that has already proven he is heads above most of us. I have no problem debating and disagreeing his often controversial positions that are often at odds with mine, but to doubt his honor regarding torture that so impacted his life is as low as it gets. If we now see somebody like McCain as not being sincere, then this country has seen the best of times. The generation flocking to see Barack give his inspirational speeches would never in a million years be able to tolerate the conditions that McCain endured. If this nation is to once again be a great nation, willing to sacrifice, we will need to embrace the famous words of JFK, "And so, my fellow Americans: ask not what your country can do for you - ask what you can do for your country." The men and women in the armed forces over generations have done their part to do for this country. They have proven to be a cut above the rest.
Posted by: Verycold | Feb 15, 2008 12:16:54 PM
>>Waterboarding, and other extreme interrogation techniques, must be personally approved by the Commander in Chief.
Exactly. This is how we know that Bush is a war criminal. Torture is a war crime. Bush ordered torture. Bush is a war criminal. McCain agrees, but he refuses to say so because he knows that 80% of his party supports war crimes.
As McCain himself said back in October:
“All I can say is that it was used in the Spanish Inquisition, it was used in Pol Pot’s genocide in Cambodia, and there are reports that it is being used against Buddhist monks today."
Of presidential candidates like Mr. Giuliani, who say that they are unsure whether waterboarding is torture, Mr. McCain said: “They should know what it is. It is not a complicated procedure. It is torture.”
Posted by: jim | Feb 15, 2008 12:07:42 PM
>>it would repeal the entire enhanced interrogation program
Stripped of Orwellian double-speak, she means the entire torture program.
>>"Do you trust the intelligence community
I thought the CIA was run by dirty hippies? Hmm. When the intelligence community puts out an NIE, we shouldn't trust them because the entire intelligence community and the State Department are run by pot-smoking dirty hippies (as everyone knows), but when Torture Czar Hayden says "torture saves lives!" then we should listen -- or we'll all die.
McCain just caved in the most transparent and dispicable way to placate the pro-torture base of the GOP. He is saying that waterboarding is torture and that he doesn't want the US military torturing people...but the CIA? No problem!
Posted by: jim | Feb 15, 2008 11:57:25 AM
McCain is definetly on the level about torture, he was at the Hanoi Hilton, tortured by the Vietnamese. He knows what it feels like for crying out loud! His position has not changed.
Posted by: steve | Feb 15, 2008 11:46:25 AM
pt | Feb 15, 2008 11:04:32 AM
"I know I would be embarrassed to be a republican right now"
Ya there's some work to do. But with an out of the Box guy like McC (or HOPEFULLY HUCK) we'll work it out.
Now just send us HRC, pls!
Posted by: The Commander Guy | Feb 15, 2008 11:10:13 AM
I know I would be embarrassed to be a republican right now. I would also be embarrassed to get Bush's endorsement like McCain just got. Why do you think they never mentioned his name during the republican debates. They wanted to stay as far away from him as they could. It is going to take a long time to clean up this mess with foreign relations, economy, etc... Lets not be wimps and submit to the fear-mongering that the republicans like to throw around. Obama 2008!!!
Posted by: pt | Feb 15, 2008 11:04:32 AM
cba please your not a republican, what a lie. because republicans want security, they do not want to have tea with these murdering pieces of @#$$% like the libs!
Posted by: spock | Feb 15, 2008 10:53:41 AM
McCain got my vote now!!
He did Flip-Flop ok people!!
He is against torture, ok we do not torture! OK get over it, waterboarding which our military personnel go thru is not torture!!
All you libs love protecting the enemoes of this country, but never ever do you protect this country!!
Posted by: spock | Feb 15, 2008 10:51:06 AM
Post a comment

