Political Punch

Power, pop, and probings from ABC News Senior White House Correspondent Jake Tapper

« Previous | Main | Next »

Should the U.S. Boycott the Beijing Olympics Opening Ceremony?

March 29, 2008 6:56 PM

Interesting debate on NPR between a human rights activist and an official of the International Olympic Committee about whether U.S. government officials, and perhaps even athletes, should boycott the opening ceremony of the Beijing Olympic games this August.

Listen to it HERE.

Human rights attorney David Kilgour, a former Canadian member of parliament, originally had supported a complete boycott because of China's abysmal record on human rights. But now he feels that the games are bringing greater scrutiny to that record -- in Tibet, Darfur, with the Falun Gong and more generally -- so he's instead calling for a boycott of the opening ceremony by government officials.

Now is the time to exert some pressure, he says.

Former U.S. rower and IOC member Anita DeFrantz — who missed the 1980 Moscow games after then-President Jimmy Carter pulled out the U.S. to protest the USSR invasion of Afghanistan — says such a boycott wouldn't work.

It got heated. The IOC "doesn't have a single scruple when it comes to totalitarian governments," Kilgour said.

What do you think?

- jpt

March 29, 2008 in Sports | Permalink | Share | User Comments (45)

User Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

The Athletes have a tough decision to make and the country needs to support them. The Athletes (coaches, trainers, etc) should go. I was moved by the comment from a past olympian - the IOC needs to be responsible for how the host country implements the 'contract' within that host country. Don't forget that Austrialia cleaned up Sidney by busing many aborginals out of the city. Don't go haywire on me - I know it is not the same as what is occuring in China. It is just another example of how the IOC needs to look past awarding the contract to the host city.

The US Government officals should just stay home. Going to the Olympics just to boycot the opening ceremonies does not make sense. The rest of the world should stay home!!

The worst that can happen if spectators and vendors from all over the world don't attend the games is media coverage. The coverage of the Athletes peacfully protesting and the slacking revenue numbers should speak for them selves. Try not buying products from China - especially during the games!!

Posted by: BCOlorado | Apr 12, 2008 7:48:32 PM

I have always looked forward to the opening ceremony of the Olympic games but this time I will not watch the games on TV.I feel that this is an appropriate time to voice our disapproval of China's thug tactics.I disagree with those who say nothing will help the plight of the Tibetans. China is watching everything that is going on and they realize the world will not tolerate their behavior.People,have some conviction and DO something even if it is just to turn the channel during the opening ceremony!You will have an impact. You can change things. Don't let the Chinese scare you. yes, we owe them money but they need us as a market for their products.If the free world doesn't buy their products they are left sitting on a pile of shoddy poisoned goods with a ruined economy.Think! Do you tell your children they must suffer the neighborhood bully because it would do no good to ask him to stop? Or do you say don't allow him play until he learns to play well with others? Folks, it is just a bigger sand box with the same rules,

Posted by: dahlimama | Apr 10, 2008 7:46:49 AM

It's pointless to boycott the chinese olympics. They still get tons of our cash from us buying everything from them. Sports is just a game, money is where the power is. If we really opposed china, we wouldn't trade with them....and that would ruin us.

Posted by: dave | Apr 7, 2008 12:55:53 PM

As a member of the Australian Olympic Swim team 1964 I expect the IOC to ensure China adheres to its promises of 2001 (prior to being awarded the Olympics) to improve Human Rights. The IOC has a responsibility to ensure the Olympic Charter and the Code of Ethics are respected by the host nation, to enable the true Spitit of the Olympics to be upheld, for the athletes and for all humanity. This responsibility is not political, it is their duty of care towards the Olympic Charter.
A recent comment by the Vice President of the IOC says it all "they, (the IOC) will investigate the Tibet incident and maybe, they should not have given the games to a communist dictatorship."
Everyone needs to be aware of the attrocities the CCP has carried out on its citizens, 330,000 people evicted from their homes,mostly without compensation to make way for a few weeks of elete sport.
When I read the words the "Sanctity of life and respect for Human Dignity over rides any sporting event, I knew in my heart this included the Olympics.

Posted by: Jan Becker | Apr 2, 2008 9:07:14 PM

The 1980 boycott of Moscow Olympics was a first step towards the end of Soviet Union. In fact the Soviet Union ceased to exist only 9 years later - in 1989.

Let's hope the Beijing Olympics are as successful as Moscow Olympics were. Chinese will be much better off without human rights violations and One Party State.

Posted by: Sev | Apr 2, 2008 12:41:02 AM

After the news tonight I was sick to see all of the people who china kicked out of there homes and made homeless just for the
games to be played there. Just to build places to house the visitors and the athletes. This is wrong and should not go unpunished. We the US should boycott the games and not compete or even watch the games and I think all of the news media should not even film or show or report the games. Furthermore I think the President should stop trade with this country and or state publicly that they will not support the games. Also if the people who chose this country new about this they should be publicly flogged and kicked out of the group that chooses who is to host the games. If they did not know than they need to change the way they pick them and do more investigation on the country and the locations they plan to use so this dosen't happen again.
Join me and do not support the games and write to whoever you need to write to include the papers and the media and try to stop the reporting of the games.
And do not buy any products from china.

Posted by: Joe | Mar 31, 2008 7:54:51 PM

Just keep talking folks. The more we ask questions about the Chinese Communists the more their bloody history is revealed.

Posted by: kathy gillis | Mar 31, 2008 5:55:52 PM

No we can't. They'll ask for all the money we've borrowed, which we can't pay ASAP. If they do that, more homes and jobs would be lost. Our currency would be worthless and the war in Iraq would end due to lack of funds.

Posted by: Chan | Mar 31, 2008 11:30:40 AM

Some Chinese actually hope that the West boycott the game and open the second cold war between the east and the west as Russian has stated that it support China on Tibet. If the west announce the boycott, immediately, all of collaboration on Unclear weapon control, Islam terrorist, Global Climate Change will collapse. China will announce that they will divide Tibet to several small provinces and openly encourage and organize immigration of non-Tibetan Chinese into Tibet with economic package and military support. So please boycott, China has plenty of coal to burn to let the earth cover with 3% CO2.

Posted by: Grove | Mar 30, 2008 5:59:04 PM

I agree that denying athletes the chance to compete would be cruel. I certainly wouldn't advocate that our country impose an official boycott. But I believe that a consumer boycott is entirely appropriate. Many people will not be attending the games or even watching them on television. Why give the Chinese government the opportunity to showcase the country when it has failed to honor its promise to improve its human rights record? In fact, the abuses have increased in the run-up to the games. On August 25, it will be business as usual in China. This tiny window of opportunity is our only chance to speak out and be heard.

Posted by: Tilly Lavenas | Mar 30, 2008 4:02:40 PM

The Olypics are sports,not politics.Did the US go to Germany when Hitler was in power? yes;
Why change policy now? It does no good.

Posted by: Richard D N | Mar 30, 2008 3:43:53 PM

All non violent means to bring a dramatic and much awaited change should be Welcome. 90% of the actual people of the world would not care if the Olympics were not held but if there is any long history of injustice to some, it is injustice to all. As we mark Martin Luther King's 40th death anniversary, let that be the guiding principle and let freedom ring.

Posted by: gjkotw01 | Mar 30, 2008 11:37:21 AM

I think boycotting opening ceremony is not a bad idea.

Posted by: JS | Mar 30, 2008 11:35:23 AM

A boycott will be counter productive.
It will harden China' stance.

Beside Olympics is a sport event.

Posted by: Joe | Mar 30, 2008 11:27:42 AM

@ Bernd

Maybe she should get lobbyists like Obama and say she doesn't have any over and over until she has her supporters brainwashed (like he does) and we are convinced she doesn't have lobbyists.

Posted by: Bobby | Mar 30, 2008 10:45:32 AM

What does this tell us about anything really? This however, today's news, tells me a LOT about one of the cadidates left in this race:

"Hillary Rodham Clinton’s cash-strapped presidential campaign has been putting off paying hundreds of bills for months — freeing up cash for critical media buys, but also earning the campaign a reputation as something of a deadbeat in some small business circles.

A pair of Ohio companies owed more than $25,000 by Clinton for staging events for her campaign are warning others in the tight-knit event production community — and anyone else who will listen — to get their cash upfront when doing business with her. Her campaign, say representatives of the two companies, has stopped returning phone calls and e-mails seeking payment of outstanding invoices. One even got no response from a certified letter."

Posted by: Bernd | Mar 30, 2008 10:16:58 AM

The single big scandal is that it's the totally corrupt regime of China that is hosting these Olympics.

China is the biggest danger in this century, to ANY other country in the world. Look at the development of China's military spending.

They are so dangerous that the world allows them to organize the Olympic games; that I think is the bottom line here.

Posted by: Harvest | Mar 30, 2008 9:58:41 AM

TO Rose, I disagree with your point. If China is going to take that extreme action for Olympics boycott then it just proves that China is a rogue nation.

We need ask some fundamental question:Why did riots happened on the First place? Why Dalai Lama cannot stay in Tibet? Why is big country like China is so adamant on small country like Tibet? Today, riots symbolize the way China handles and supress the issue.

America uses China's product in their day to day life. China has more to loose than America. China can no longer stay isolated. This is a integrated global economy. China should stop their imperial expansion and should start working with their global partners.

As a responsible growing nation China should show that they have good policy towards Tibet. I think no one is asking anything more.

Posted by: Humm | Mar 30, 2008 9:57:02 AM

HI, ALL,

So called Boycott will only hurt US, not China. TO Boycott is to oppose all Chinese people as Rice said. China's nationaism will drive all American (or any country)'s businesses out of China, not buy US products and services, if US (any contry)will boycott... Chinese poeple are standing firmly in CHinese government side.

HUman Right is not equal to RIOT !!!
Oppose media bias !!!

Posted by: Rose | Mar 30, 2008 9:31:42 AM

America should boycott the Beijing Olympics Opening Ceremony and not the Olympics. This is an opportunity for America to create a positive image globally. America did not tolerate Saddam Hussien's Human right violation and now they should they tolerate in China. It is matter for principle.

Posted by: Humm | Mar 30, 2008 9:17:58 AM

Post a comment





 

POLITICAL VIDEOS