Political Punch
Power, pop, and probings from ABC News Senior White House Correspondent Jake Tapper
RECENT POSTS
- Today's Q's For O's White House
- Afghanistan Offensive and Iraq Withdrawal: Obama's National Security Advisor Discusses Both with ABC News
- Who Makes the Big Bucks at the White House?
- Obama Quizzed at Health Care Town Hall: On Taxing Benefits, Single Payer System, and Costs
- Today's Q's for O's White House
- Spotlight on Non-Profit Work, Obama Calls on “Deep Pockets”
- Obama says Iraqi People Right to Celebrate
- Today's Q's for O's White House
- POTUS to LGBT: "Welcome to Your White House"
- Obama Gives Biden Iraq Assignment
MONTHLY ARCHIVES
« Previous | Main | Next »
From the Fact Check Desk: What Did Obama's Half-Brother Say About Obama's Background?
June 18, 2008 12:39 PM
It was a sloppy paraphrase that emerged as false evidence.
Malik Obama, the older half brother of Sen. Barack Obama, D-Illinois, gave a brief interview to Israeli Army Radio.
The Jerusalem Post listened to the interview, apparently, and produced a story saying "Malik Obama says his brother will be good president for the Jews. Barack Obama's half brother Malik said Thursday that if elected his brother will be a good president for the Jewish people, despite his Muslim background."
Nowhere is Malik quoted.
The Jerusalem Post has since taken the story down of its website, but you can see a cached version HERE.
Conservatives jumped on the Jerusalem Post's paraphrase that Malik said Obama "will be a good president for the Jewish people, despite his Muslim background" as some sort of evidence that Malik was saying Obama was raised a Muslim, which the campaign says he was not.
This suspicion reared its head in Israeli blogs and the blogs of supporters of Sen. Hillary Clinton, D-NY, and Sean Hannity fan sites and Free Republic and conservative blogs.
It ended up on Fox News, with anchor Brut Hume saying on June 16 that: "Barack Obama is a practicing Christian, married in a Christian church, whose children were also baptized in that church. His campaign has emphasized his faith in part to dispel what the campaign calls an online smear campaign which contends among other things that Obama was raised a Muslim. There is even a statement on his official campaign website reading, quote, 'Obama has never been a Muslim, and is a committed Christian.' But Obama's half brother is not so sure. Malik Obama tells The Jerusalem Post that, 'if elected his brother will be a good president for the Jewish people, despite his Muslim background.'"
So is it true?
No.
**
ABC News got a hold of the audio of Malik's interview with Israel Army Radio, and Malik said nothing of the kind.
You can't hear the questions -- only Malik's answers (listen HERE) -- but whatever the interviewer asked about Obama's father's Muslim heritage, or the Muslim minority in Kenya, Malik said, “I don’t think that’s in any way going to be something to worry about. I myself am not speaking for him. But we are here, we love people in general. People love us. I myself love people who love me. You know, so, and I think it’s mutual. I can’t go in terms of Israel and Kenya and America, and so forth, you know, but based on what else I’ve heard him say and what I know of him as an individual, I don’t think Israel should worry too much, you know, about the connection. Because, I am a Muslim myself, and I don’t think that my being a Muslim has got anything to do with my brother being the President of the United States.”
It may be that the Israeli Army Radio interviewer asked about Obama having a "Muslim background." But even if the interviewer did, Malik did not say that or come close to saying that.
It could be that the interviewer used the phrase, and Malik interpreted that in a way that squares with the Obama campaign's story -- that Obama's father was a largely secular man born Muslim. We don't know.
But nowhere in there does Malik expressly say anything about Obama having a Muslim background.
And nowhere does he "confirm" anything about Obama having a Muslim background.
Malik refers to Obama having a "connection" to something, perhaps Islam, which could clearly be a reference to Obama's father.
This interpretation spreading throughout the blogosphere and cable news is just not supported by the facts. The paraphrase was sloppy, for such a sensitive subject, and Malik's quotes don't even come close to supporting any assertion that Obama himself has a Muslim background.
**
In Obama's book Dreams of My Father, interestingly enough, he writes about meeting Malik as an adult: “I checked into the cheapest room I could find and waited. At nine, I heard a knock. When I opened the door, I found a big man standing there with his hands in his pockets, an even-toothed grin breaking across his ebony face. ‘Hey, brother,’ he said. ‘How’s life?’ In the pictures I had of Roy, he was slender, dressed in African print, with an Afro, a goatee, a mustache. The man who embraced me now was much heavier, over two hundred pounds, I guessed, the flesh on his cheeks pressing out beneath a thick pair of glasses. The goatee was gone; the African shirt had been replaced by a gray sports coat, white shirt, and tie. Auma had been right, though; his resemblance to the Old Man was unnerving. Looking at my brother, I felt as if I were ten years old again.”
It was later that Malik converted to Islam, Obama wrote in Dreams: “The person who made me proudest of all, though, was Roy. Actually, now we call him Abongo, his Luo name, for two years ago he decided to reassert his African heritage. He converted to Islam, and has sworn off pork and tobacco and alcohol. He still works at his accounting firm, but talks about moving back to Kenya once he has enough money.”
In the Israeli Army Radio interview Malik said that Obama was the "best man at my wedding and I was best man at his wedding."
And in my favorite part of the interview, Malik said, "I think he'll be a good president as long as all of this, you know, doesn't go to his head."
Mark Twain is said to have quipped, "A lie can travel half way around the world while the truth is putting on its shoes."
And that was before the internet. And cable.
-- jpt
June 18, 2008 | Permalink | Share | User Comments (96)
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.
It doesn't matter how you people try to spin it. The guy is no good. The only thing he has going for him the ability to deliver a speech. It scares me how many people out there that will just believe anything there told with out doing a little research. Your right it shouldn't matter what his faith is
except for the fact that a certain group of muslim have declared war against us!!!!!
HELLO!!!!! And to all those people out there that think one person controls the rise and fall of the American economy your just as crazy as Obama
Posted by: brandon | Jul 5, 2008 1:15:53 PM
I am getting sick and tire of candidates having to pass the Israel protection quiz in order to be the president of "OUR" country, or agree to join the republicans in their policies in order to please them.
Bush and everyone of our elected official has bankrupt our citizens and country in order to give Israel our tax money , military equipment and fight wars to please them.
I don't see any of these candidates coming in front of the democratic groups to see what policies they wish in order to receive our votes. But in fact kisses the republican's a...es by passing legislation which censored democratic groups.
Matter of fact they take our vote for granted and arrogantly believe we will vote for them no matter how they s... on us.
I believe this government is intentionally destroying our jobs , manufacturing plants , constitution , freedom , rights , democracy , social programs and military by replacing it with their private army in order to take complete control of our citizens and our country.
Posted by: What to Say | Jun 23, 2008 7:12:52 AM
Not only did Malik NOT say Obama had a Muslim background--but they were not raised together and did not even MEET until both were well into adulthood. It's not as if Malik were an authority on Barack's upbringing even if he had said such a thing, which, of course, he didn't. But the absurdity of the whole flap is stunning.
Posted by: CeeCee | Jun 20, 2008 10:43:00 PM
Odd how critics explain how Obama says whatever it takes to get elected when he is a lot more straight forward than the Flip-Flop Express. Odd how they claim not enough is known about Obama, but claim he's identical in politics with Jimmy Carter. And has a website that tells you exactly where he stands on IMPORTANT issues.
All Republicans can do to avoid the inevitable landslide is smear Obama, and his wife. They CANNOT win on the issues. Good riddance to McSame.
Posted by: Clear Vision | Jun 20, 2008 2:37:23 PM
He running for President...he will be or not be whatever, to whomever he is addressing!
IMO...he can't be trusted to tell the truth,and has no experience.
He's another Jimmy Carter...and if you are old enough to remember the Carter years..you do not want to go through that again.
Posted by: Justin | Jun 20, 2008 8:50:23 AM
I don't know why so many people are freakin' out about whether or not Obama is Muslim or not. There is supposed to be NO RELIGIOUS TEST for office.
We are doing an end run around the Constitution. It sucks that we embrace some sections and ignore others.
It is one thing to disregard it because you don't like what protections the campaign affords, but the biggest hypocritical thing the right and the left does is ignore certain sections and then claim the moral high ground.
Posted by: Genna | Jun 19, 2008 7:28:03 PM
He is a Muslim, he is not a Muslim, he is a Catholic, he is a Marxist he is not Marxist. He is more black no he is more white, What does it matter!
We elected Shrub, a Fool, who can't even construct a simple sentence, who almost single handled consigned the once great US to the dark ages. The Economy has tanked, House prices fallen, Sub prime, Petrol prices, Iraq war, possible Iran war etc.
We are treated with scorn and derision by the rest of the World. Even Mickey Mouse would made a better President. Obama is no Mickey Mouse he is strong, articulate, educated and his background allows him a first row seat to what ails the US and its people.
Obama offers a chance to hope again dream again, purge the stench of Bush from our consciousness and to hold our heads up once with pride.
Posted by: lydia | Jun 19, 2008 6:37:35 PM
Slag, I take offense when the possible future President of the USA sits in a church that subscribes to black liberation theology. BLT teaches that white people are the cause of all the misery on the planet. James Cone, the founder of BLT, says that white people need to be eliminated. Now, if Mr. Obama is so lazy that he did not know what his own church is founded upon, this is incredible. If he did know, then he should not have stayed in that church. It is not true Christianity.
Posted by: Patricia | Jun 19, 2008 5:25:01 PM
Why would anyone characterize questioning and doubts with hatred? If Obama would quit lying about everything, then people would not be so concerned. The guy just can't quit lying. He has to assuage his way, way left base and now he is trying to gather some middle ground. He's a charlatan, a scammer.
Posted by: Patricia | Jun 19, 2008 5:14:55 PM
So many horrible comments in this thread. What has become of this country ? So much hatred. So many people believing lies.
Barack is a Cristian. He has never been a Muslim. If he had been a Muslim he would have said so, there is no shame in that. He is an honest person. He has never been shown to lie about anything. He is smart and eloquent and I agree with most of his politics. He is not a "elitist" - that is a word label that makes no sense, a word that has dropped out of the sky. If you don't want to vote for him, fine, that is your right. But treat him with the same respect you would treat any other person including McCain.
Posted by: Rick | Jun 19, 2008 1:46:33 PM
It doesn't matter if Obama is Muslim or not. This country has not moved that far ahead from Jim Crowe and slavery. The majority of the American public is still racist, sexist, and homophobic. I think the worst fact about the American public is that they are dumb, which more than anything else will be their downfall
Posted by: bob | Jun 19, 2008 1:05:15 PM
ABC offering good information for a change. I think that's great!
Obama 08!
Posted by: Hope For Change | Jun 19, 2008 6:14:02 AM
i don't have anything productive to add to this discussion, since clearly most of the people commenting here are incredibly paranoid. i think most people will find that the level of ignorance on this board is incredible. the internet has provided a wealth of information for people to check claims, but as many of these comments suggest it's also provided a lot of convenient misinformation.
Posted by: PP | Jun 19, 2008 3:24:16 AM
You can look at his face (Obama) when he lies. Sure enough, he's lying to all American. I'm democrat but I'll not go vote this time.
Posted by: Peter T. | Jun 18, 2008 11:52:19 PM
I'm tired of this whole thing.
He said " Never" people said" ever"
Shouldn't the DNC check on him first before they select him?
Should he take a LIE DETECTOR?
Posted by: catleya | Jun 18, 2008 9:44:27 PM
I can hardly wait for the smirking non-apology from Brit Hume, followed by Sean Hannity's substitution of a different smear for this one.
Posted by: Endlessly Amused | Jun 18, 2008 7:31:59 PM
The damage was already done by Obama's shifting degrees of stern disapproval at his own church and spiritual guides. He has indicated his embarrassment with his connection to Wright, Pfleger, Muslims, black liberation theology, earlier foreign policy declarations, and much else besides. If anyone thinks Obama is not damaged by all that, I encourage you to go right along with that sentiment.
Posted by: Adrien | Jun 18, 2008 7:31:17 PM
Thanks for links Jake, tho people who want to smear Obama don't care about the truth, others with more open minds do and it's great to have the source directly online.
Since Obama was never Muslim, only had a Muslim step-dad, the point is moot, people need to grow up now. What I find fascinating is that Hillary-supporting blogs should spread this garbage, when Hillary's funders are demanding that Barack pay her debts before they'll donate to him. Obama had to stop campaigning when he'd already won and she kept going, just to not waste money by encouraging her to spend more. Winners always help losers pay their debts. How much they run it up after they lose reflects on them.
Bad, bad sportsmanship, and how any Clinton-supporter can undermine Hillary's efforts to reunite the party by promoting the lies about Michelle and Barack is beyond me. I'm glad the vast majority of her supporters are cool, and these are just fringe elements, getting way too much attention.
Posted by: Earthbound | Jun 18, 2008 6:58:32 PM
These constant and absurd smear tactics against Obama are backfiring on the Republicans now. No one can believe anything the Republicans say now and they have lost all credibility. We've already endurred 7 years of lies and deception with Bush in the White House. America won't tolerate more of the same.
Posted by: AnnFurthermore | Jun 18, 2008 6:54:01 PM
For all the people judging Obama based on short snippets of inflammatory statements made by others, you are doing yourselves and your country a huge disservice. American democracy deserves better than citizens who make decisions out of ignorance and fear.
This election is about our economy, our national security, our health care system, our environment, our energy independence, our Constitution, and our educational system. It's not about your personal prejudices. Get over it.
Posted by: slag | Jun 18, 2008 6:31:11 PM
Post a comment

