Political Punch

Power, pop, and probings from ABC News Senior White House Correspondent Jake Tapper

« Previous | Main | Next »

McCain Doesn't Want Ellen DeGeneres to Adopt Kids…Or Does He?

July 16, 2008 10:13 AM

Thought it's been getting a lot of ink this week, Sen. John McCain's opposition to "gay adoption" -- the ability of same sex couples to adopt children -- is not a new thing. Though he didn't bring it up when he went on "Ellen" a few weeks ago.

On CBS's Face the Nation on November 22, 1999, McCain said that unlike then-Gov. George W. Bush, he had already met with the gay GOP group, the Log Cabin Republicans, but then he quickly pivoted to say, "I am opposed to legalization of gay marriages, gay adoption. I strongly support the 'don't ask, don't tell policy,' but I believe strongly in the party of Abraham Lincoln, and the Log Cabin Republicans are a part of our party. I will be more than happy to meet and have a dialogue with anyone in the Republican Party. I believe that I can have my point of view prevail in an honest and open debate and dialogue, whether it be with the Log Cabin Republicans or whether it be the Christian right, or whoever it be."

In an interview with the New York Times published Sunday McCain was described as saying "flatly that he opposed allowing gay couples to adopt."

The full transcript shows that the exchange with the reporters went like this:

Q: President Bush believes that gay couples should not be permitted to adopt children. Do you agree with that?

McCain: I think that we’ve proven that both parents are important in the success of a family so, no I don’t believe in gay adoption.

Q: Even if the alternative is the kid staying in an orphanage, or not having parents.

McCain: I encourage adoption and I encourage the opportunities for people to adopt children I encourage the process being less complicated so they can adopt as quickly as possible. And Cindy and I are proud of being adoptive parents.

Q: But your concern would be that the couple should a traditional couple

McCain: Yes.

And yet the McCain campaign shortly thereafter issued a statement saying: “John McCain could have been clearer in the interview in stating that his position on gay adoption is that it is a state issue, just as he made it clear in the interview that marriage is a state issue. He was not endorsing any federal legislation. Senator McCain expressed his personal preference for children to be raised by a mother and a father wherever possible. However, as an adoptive father himself, McCain believes children deserve loving and caring home environments, and he recognizes that there are many abandoned children who have yet to find homes. John McCain believes that in those situations that caring parental figures are better for the child than the alternative.”

Which seems to be saying he doesn't like gay adoptions unless there are kids who can't find homes otherwise, in which case he thinks gay adoption is OK.

Over at CBN, David Brody writes "I can’t imagine comments like that will play well with the social conservative base at all. I mean if you’re going to say that you’re against gay adoption then why not just stick with that view rather than trying to massage it? The qualifier after the interview does some damage. Why? Because McCain had an opportunity to add the gay adoption issue to his Evangelical checklist and now it’s muddy. As for this being a state issue? Why do so many politicians use the federalist approach to get out of a sticky situation? McCain’s not the first and he won’t be the last. Social conservatives are saddened by children in foster care or orphanages too. So that’s not the issue. The debate over gay adoption is another matter entirely. The focus here is on John McCain. Evangelicals are already feeling fidgety about McCain and have concerns about him on a number of issues. Why add to the list?"

And Brody gets an email from Tony Perkins, president of the conservative Family Research Council saying: "There is nothing 'straight talking' about the McCain campaign's response to the Senator's statements on homosexual adoption. I hope he's able to get everyone on his staff on the right side of the road."

A 2007 CNN poll indicated that 57 percent of the American people feel same sex couples should have adoption rights. Florida is the only state that explicitly bans gays and lesbians from adopting children.

- jpt

July 16, 2008 | Permalink | Share | User Comments (16)

User Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I think McCain has voiced an honest opinion... one which defines HIS personal views.

If you had asked this same questions of Barack, you would have received a response which might have been politically correct.... but probably not his gut feeling on the topic.


I like Mccain's taking a stand in this regard. and sticking with it .... whether or not it pleases every one.

He will be a trustworthy, dependable President.

Posted by: eyes extremely wide open | Jul 16, 2008 9:59:15 PM

"Florida is the only state that explicitly bans gays and lesbians from adopting children." And we all know what a WONDERFUL job they do with children in the care of the State! lol (but crying, too - at this point...)

Posted by: tiredgirlie | Jul 16, 2008 8:55:51 PM

Mr. McCain isn't making any new friends with this position, but it is consistent with conservative values. It seems he is winning over some of the Republican base. In a year when the GOP should not have a chance, he is holding his own. Not bad given the poor performance of the GOP overall.

Posted by: Independent | Jul 16, 2008 7:22:05 PM

LOL, with McBush one can never tell. One day he says one thing then the next says the complete opposite! LOL

JT

Posted by: Justin Write | Jul 16, 2008 2:07:06 PM

allie, you're right, and it echoes my earlier sentiment that America has MUCH more serious problems than gay rights.

The only thing amusing about all this is that the two candidates seem to be trying to outdo each other in "waffling". At least we now understand what Obama meant when he kept chanting "Change!" He and McCain BOTH know the meaning of this word all too well.

Posted by: Rhys | Jul 16, 2008 12:11:59 PM

This is laughable - really. It is a lame attempt to give the Christian Right some sort of "issue" to latch onto when their candidate is faltering. Does McCain truly think that the majority of Americans are sitting around debating gay adoption when we are paying over $4 for gas, entire neighborhoods can't sell homes, and there is talk of expaning the war on terrorism? If the man stands a chance he needs to talk about what we really want resolved.

Posted by: allie | Jul 16, 2008 11:59:17 AM

I have a friend trying to adopt from VN. The US is claiming a lot of bull about corruption, but they aren't telling the whole story.

This friend and several families wrote to Senator McCain for help. They were thinking that since he has a daughter from an international adoption and because his website touts what an adoption proponent his is, that he would help them. They were wrong.

He told them that he was sorry he couldn't help them, that he is a senator from AZ and they aren't from AZ.

I thought he was running for president of the United States and not just of AZ.

Any claims he makes about how much he values and cares about adoption are just laughable to me, now.

Posted by: lisa | Jul 16, 2008 11:55:15 AM

Wasn't McCain's campaign "shake-up" supposed to clarify his stance on such things? I seems in the last week that his positions are fuzzier than ever.

Posted by: Jane Hussein | Jul 16, 2008 11:48:53 AM

Dear American Citizens and the Press

As a concerned citizen, I consider it is my duty to bring following message to you all.

"We the citizens of the United States of America have the ultimate responsibility to elect the " Right Candidate" to lead our nation, out of our huge present and future internal and external challenges as well as opportunities. This is to prevent depression and isolation in-spite of being the only superpower in the world morally, democratically, economically, and militarily.

We need to consider the "critical qualities and characteristics" of our presumptive presidential nominees at the time we vote.

In my personal and professional opinion the critical considerations are as under:


1. Calm, cool, and collected " temper " [ Presidential Temperament ].
2. Sound and sustained "Judgment and Caliber".
3. "Thought-fullness and togetherness" of purpose and positions.
4. Minimum "ex-poser and exploitation" around "Washington and Washington insiders".
5. Renewed " Vigor and Vision " for our Greatgrand Nation.
6. Foreign policy based on " American Values, Virtuous, Vastness".

Stay informed, stay involved, and stay engaged. Do not allow some partisan media, pundits, pollsters, and perpetual political opinion makers effect your vote in the wrong direction.

Don't be effected and duped by "Psychological Terrorism" that is afflicted upon you all the time.

Long live U.S.A and its diverse but democratic people.

Col. A.M. Khajawall [Ret] MD., ABFM., ABDA.

Posted by: COL.[retd]A.M.Khajawall | Jul 16, 2008 11:34:04 AM

So McCain believes that all children should have two parents of different genders. Does this mean widowed, gay or an unmarried parent should give up their children? That it's better for children to languish in orphanages or foster care system rather than be in a home with a loving and supportive parent(s) to be kicked to the street when they reach 18 yrs. without a support system? If that's a plank in the Republican platform, count me out. I'm an independent and I was leaning Republican for this election, but I can't see supporting anyone who would rather see a child sit in foster care or an orphanage without caring parents than with a caring parent that happens to prefer their own gender. Sexual preference does NOT define the entire person.

Posted by: Catherine | Jul 16, 2008 11:30:32 AM

Who is the real John Mcain? and would he please stand up, the man flip flops and changes his mind sooooo much I dont know who he is or what he stands for.

Posted by: angie | Jul 16, 2008 11:03:56 AM

McFish strikes again

Posted by: Last Call | Jul 16, 2008 11:00:03 AM

I don't have a problem with gays adopting kids. But I don't know if Ellen DeGeneres should be allowed to do so!

Posted by: Mickey | Jul 16, 2008 10:57:38 AM

'Cause I'm John McCain-y, yes I'm the real McCain-y
All you other John McCain-ys are just imitating
So won't the real John McCain-y please stand up,
please stand up, please stand up?

Posted by: Deep Release | Jul 16, 2008 10:48:45 AM

This should NOT be a political issue, especially at a time when we must decide which war is "correct" (Afghanistan or Iraq), and while our financial and housing markets are in serious trouble. Sexual orientation should be the LEAST of our concerns!

Posted by: Rhys | Jul 16, 2008 10:44:38 AM

Obama really needs to hit McCain hard on the "don't ask, don't tell" BS. It is about time we allow our service memebers to serve their country with dignity.

Posted by: Jane Hussein | Jul 16, 2008 10:24:44 AM

Post a comment





 

POLITICAL VIDEOS