Political Punch
Power, pop, and probings from ABC News Senior White House Correspondent Jake Tapper

« Previous | Main | Next »

The POW "Card"

August 25, 2008 8:55 AM

Can a person who showed unfathomable heroism in a dark period of war invoke that heroism too often?

It's a complicated thing, writing about Sen. John McCain's years as a Vietnam POW, and how he's cited those years in the campaign.

A meme has developed among some bloggers and commentators that McCain is citing those grisly five and a half years too often.

Among them one-time McCain admirer Andrew Sullivan, who sees it cropping up in McCain comments so often it's becoming even mockable, despite how horrific it was, in the same way Sen. Joe Biden, D-Del., felt able to mock former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani's invocation of September 11.

Sullivan refers to it as "noun, verb, POW." And Maureen Dowd in yesterday's New York Times wrote: "It's hard to believe that John McCain is now in danger of exceeding his credit limit on the equivalent of an American Express black card. His campaign is cheapening his greatest strength - and making a mockery of his already dubious claim that he's reticent to talk about his P.O.W. experience - by flashing the P.O.W. card to rebut any criticism, no matter how unrelated. The captivity is already amply displayed in posters and TV advertisements."

And that was before the latest example.

Over the weekend, Biden went after McCain in his Veep announcement speech, saying, "Ladies and gentlemen, your kitchen table is like mine. You sit there at night...after you put the kids to bed and you talk, you talk about what you need. You talk about how much you are worried about being able to pay the bills. Well, ladies and gentlemen, that's not a worry John McCain has to worry about. It's a pretty hard experience. He'll have to figure out which of the seven kitchen tables to sit at!"

In response, McCain told CBS News in an interview that aired Sunday, "I spent some years without a kitchen table, without a chair, and I know what it is like to be blessed with the opportunities of this great nation."

**

It's not a new thing.

Running for Congress from Arizona in 1982, John McCain was repeatedly assailed as a carpetbagger, which he pretty much was.

At a candidates forum when the matter was brought up yet again, McCain responded abruptly, telling his rival, "Listen, pal. I spent 22 years in the Navy. My grandfather was in the Navy. We in the military service tend to move a lot. We have to live in all parts of the country, all parts of the world. I wish I could have had the luxury, like you, of growing up and living and spending my entire life in a nice place like the first district of Arizona, but I was doing other things. As a matter of fact, when I think about it now, the place I lived longest in my life was Hanoi."

It was a devastating rejoinder.

In Worth the Fighting For, McCain (and Mark Salter) wrote: "Looking back, I think the race was effectively over right then. I had stunned the audience and finally put to rest the one nagging vulnerability that was still clouding my prospects. But I didn't know that then. I was just mad and had taken a swing."

But it wasn't until this election season that I've seen McCain and his campaign discuss his POW years so often when rebutting or refuting charges.

In June this blog noted that you could see the stark differences between the McCain of 2008 and the McCain of 2000 on this issue by looking at McCain's cross-in-the-dirt story, which McCain told in the third person to a crowd in Virginia Beach on February 28, 2000, as if it had happened to a different person, but used in the first person in a TV ad in December 2007.

After McCain jokingly offered his wife Cindy as a contestant at a biker beauty pageant, and was criticized for it, McCain spox Brian Rogers said Americans "know that John McCain's faith and character were tested and forged in ways few can fathom."

After some questioned whether McCain had violated the rules and listened to Rick Warren's questions for Sen. Barack Obama at the Saddleback Forum (McCain was to get the same questions, but was supposed to be in a "cone of silence," McCain spox Nicole Wallace said, "The insinuation from the Obama campaign that John McCain, a former prisoner of war, cheated is outrageous."

During a back and forth on health care, Elizabeth Edwards wrote in the Wall Street Journal that McCain has had government health care his whole life.

"It's a cheap shot," McCain said to George Stephanopoulos on This Week, "but I did have a period of time where I didn't have very good government health care. I had it from another government."

And of course, during a GOP debate last Fall, McCain mocked a $1 million Woodstock museum and noted that he hadn't attended the music fest since he was "tied up at the time."

It's a tricky business to criticize -- I don't know many people who would be able to withstand what McCain went through, and it's entirely within the realm of possibility that most Americans are not paying enough attention to think he's "overplaying" anything. And even those who are paying close attention might think he's earned the right to mention those dark five and a half years.

Surely many Americans believe McCain has earned the right to tell the story of his uncommon valor however often he wants, in whatever venue he wants.

The question for him and his campaign is whether he's diminishing his heroism at all with its increasingly frequent mention within the context of campaign controversies that have absolutely nothing to do with that heroism.

- jpt

August 25, 2008 | Permalink | Share | User Comments (119)

User Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I'm sorry, don't vote for McCain if you don't want to. But I'm never going to tell a guy who spent 5.5 years in the Hanoi Hilton (ironic, Hilton :-) that he's mentioning it too much. Frankly, he's luckly to be alive. He's done something that 99.99% of us can't even fathom, and all for our country. If you don't think it's a qualification for POTUS, God bless you, don't vote for him. But he can bring it up all he wants IMO.

Posted by: D'Obama | Aug 25, 2008 2:04:00 PM

A noun
A verb
and POW McCaint. lol

I can't recall the last vet who constantly and UN-HEROICALLY repeats the events of his service?

McCaint is suffering from the pangs of old age, when the aged begins to believe that they are being forgotten.
In this way, McCaint is overusing his POW status to keep his memory alive.

Either the above, or McCaint is pandering politically and being UN-HEROIC!

Posted by: Patriot | Aug 25, 2008 1:39:01 PM

spock, what was all the Repub hoopla about Michelle Obama, if they aren't going after wives? You're being a just tad bit, a little hypocritical aren't ya? And it's just silly to think that McCcain doesn't share in his wife's wealth; but, you're missing the point. That's not really even the issue. The issue is that earlier in the election, he said that the economy was "fundamentally sound," that his economic policies want to continue the Bush tax cuts for the wealthy (which would benefit him and NOT the majority of the middle class), that he hs reversed himself from his former 2000 moderate maverick brand to embrace Bush' policies (which would only continue our current economic situation), and that his own mocking definition of who's wealthy is those making $5 million a year (which would exclude Obama by his own definition, as he made $4 million on his book sales, and who, btw, answered the question at the Saddleback Forum, to include those in the $200k bracket, as being part of the upper 5%, considering the relativity of geography of course). It goes beyond the pale that he wants to help those who could afford seven homes as he has, when so many are struggling to hold onto one. That's what makes him out of touch - not that he CAN afford that many, but that he seems utterly unwilling to help any but those who can also afford that many. He even has the man responsible for the housing/mortgage crisis and banking failures through deregulation, in his trusted circle of advisors, Phil Gramm.

Posted by: sheribaby | Aug 25, 2008 1:32:13 PM

John McCain wouldn't give up those five years in prison if it also meant giving up the excuse to leave his first wife, pick up an heiress half his age, and live the pampered life of a senator with 12 houses the rest of his life.

Posted by: Seamus | Aug 25, 2008 1:20:25 PM

Pink Elephant, you have got to be one of the most reasonable posters I've read in a long time.

Posted by: sheribaby | Aug 25, 2008 1:20:14 PM

It will be a great day in America when Barack Obama and his hate filled supporters get defeated in Novmeber.

Posted by: geevill | Aug 25, 2008 1:16:41 PM

Biden is one to talk, lets see how many homes does Obama's hero the Drunk Ted Kennedy own, or Pelosi, or Gore or Kerry. It is not a sin in this country to own more then one home, hey Obama wants to bail out those people who foreclosed on there 2nd or 3rd or more house. And as pointed out John McCain does not own those houses, hi wife does. So now the Obama camp is going after wives huh?

As far as the POW, only the libs think he is saying it too much, because hey they do not know what a real hero is.

Jake - you should do a blog on the Biden who was instrumental on Clinton getting us involved in a civil war in Kosovo, which is why Russia is mad at us now and in Georgia!

Anyone But Obama in 08'

Posted by: spock | Aug 25, 2008 1:16:14 PM

geevill, since when were campaign slogans and platitudes such as "hope," "change" and "yes, we can" cards? And Obama didn't play the race card; the McCain camp tried to invoke it from him, by injecting race into the campaign with their disparaging ads, using code words and images. we're not stupid. Ask David Gergen who's from the south. Are McCain's "reform,"
"prosperity," and "peace" cards also? LMAO.

Posted by: sheribaby | Aug 25, 2008 1:02:08 PM

Paige said: "As a 'resident from Illinois' I would expect you to know that Obama gave up a very lucrative career to come back to Chicago as a community organizer to help re-build the south side from closed down plants."

You mean Barack came to Illinois to make political connections, living in a luxury condo nearly the entire time, all the while never had worked one day at a real job at any point in his entire life.

Obama and Reverend Wright...play off disadvantaged minorities while they live in luxury in white neighborhoods.

Posted by: ynot4tony2 | Aug 25, 2008 1:01:55 PM

The experience McCain went through as a POW does not entitle him to be President or to use that tragic experience as an excuse for all his mistakes and other issues he must confront.

He and his campaign are using it in away that does a disservice to all of our Veteran's some of whom may have suffered far worse experiences, and permanent damage both physical and mental.

Posted by: JIm Martin | Aug 25, 2008 12:59:58 PM

McCain is a fraud.

Posted by: Hoo-Ahh! | Aug 25, 2008 12:55:38 PM

Given the fact that McCain is a decorated former POW makes his abandonment of veterans and current troops even worse. The Disabled American Veterans gave him a 20% voting record on vet's issues. The Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America gave him a letter grade of D.

Posted by: Hoo-Ahh! | Aug 25, 2008 12:54:27 PM

McCain is a hypocrite. He voted against every bill that has come forward in the last two years to increase veterans health services. He spoke against the new GI Bill, then did not bother to show up to even vote on it. He voted against a mandatory rest period for troops between deployments. He voted against armored vehicles and flak vests for Nat'l. Guard and Reservists. I am one disgusted vet who is not buying the BS that he supports the troops and veterans.

Posted by: Hoo-Ahh! | Aug 25, 2008 12:51:47 PM

geevill, I didn't say anything about what Biden was promoting about himself or not - that was squintz. And you still haven't addressed the Repub double standard when it comes to military service. Nuf said.

Posted by: sheribaby | Aug 25, 2008 12:50:40 PM

Geevil, you are obviously a Republican through-and-through. You're no Democrat. Go ahead and vote for McSame.

Posted by: Hoo-Ahh! | Aug 25, 2008 12:48:03 PM

JA, you are misinformed. Barack Obama has not run on being black, nor has he repeatedly reminded voters that he is (why would he have to or want to, which would be stupid and counterproductive with racist whites?) He has run on bringing people of different races, cultures and socieconomic backgrounds together to solve problems, united. He mentioned on SOME - some campaign speeches that the McCain camp would try to scare voters about him being different, question his patriotism, and make fun of his name, all of which they've already done. Also McCain has an internet ad in which he features Obama on dollar bills and changing everything in America, including the Statue of Liberty and Mount Rushmore, if he were elected, which is ridiculous, and is clearly a scare tactic to incite fear in white racist voters wary that blacks want to "take over.") Then when he called them on it, they said that HE injected race into the campaign. They got their desired result: they got to inject race into the campaign but make it LOOK like Obama did, and was playing the "race card."

Posted by: sheribaby | Aug 25, 2008 12:43:10 PM

The problem is that McCain has said he doesn't like to talk about his POW experience.

Yet he has used video footage and images from that experience since the beginning of his campaign. And now his campaign is using it to avoid criticism of his gaffes.

It may help him in an election but not so much if he becomes President.

Posted by: cincyr | Aug 25, 2008 12:39:05 PM

sheribaby,
I am a Democrat. voted for Clinton in the primary. will vote for McCain in November.

and Biden is free to exploit his tragic hair loss and transplant surgery anytime.

Posted by: geevill | Aug 25, 2008 12:31:18 PM

Well, that's all he has. That's how he defines himself - POW. Can he get away from it? I don't think so. My own husband served under horrible conditions and he still suffers from PTSD, so I am pretty sure McSame has his spells. What meds does he take? Invoking his POW experiences for even a hangnail serves only to diminish his service. What about his judgement...should have been more observant, maybe he wouldn't have got shot down.

POW: Prisoner of W.

Posted by: mariaWr | Aug 25, 2008 12:28:53 PM

Biden "never exploits" his own tragic personal history?! Obama just mentioned it in his introduction of Biden two days ago! What are you Biden apologists smoking, and where can I get some?

Posted by: CFB | Aug 25, 2008 12:28:40 PM

Post a comment





 

POLITICAL VIDEOS