Political Punch

Power, pop, and probings from ABC News Senior National Correspondent Jake Tapper

« Stumbles | Main | The Trouble with Lobbyists Running Your Campaign »

The Wit and Wisdom of Toby Keith

August 08, 2008 10:53 AM

The country star tells Glen Beck that "black people would say" of Sen. Barack Obama, D-Illinois, that "he don’t talk, act, or carry himself as a black person."

"What does that even mean?" Asks Beck.

"Well, I don’t know what that means, I'm saying that's what I think that they would say," Keith responds. "Even though black society would pull for him I still think that they think in the back of their mind that the only reason he is in is because he talks, acts, and carries himself as a Caucasian."

Listen HERE.

In the back of the black community's "mind"?

Wow.

- jpt

August 8, 2008 | Permalink | User Comments (347)

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/433071/32167710

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The Wit and Wisdom of Toby Keith:

User Comments

Race is not even a consideration in this or any other election or matter. Let's assume their both green. McCain has been in public service for decades. Yeah, he's a conservative republican. I don't like everything he says. On the other hand, Obama has been in public service for less than one year. I don't like everything he says either. But some of the issues he and his party favor are not in the best interests of this country. IF he can be successful in his stated objective to emaciate the 2nd amendment and, for all practical purposes, disarm this country, and if he can successfully 'equalize' the playing field between the rich and the poor, so that there are no 'rich or poor', but all the same, not only in this country but the world over, then he will give you a tax bill you won't believe, and put this country on the course for socialism in it's most basic form. Check the records. This country has out lasted any other democratic republic because we have the ability to revolt. Take away that ability and we'll become just another country that gets taken over by a group who has more power than we do. Even though I am a volunteer war veteran, I don't like war. Anyone who has ever been in one will tell you the same thing. However, those same people will also tell you that sometimes you have to do things you don't like, including taking up arms and defending yourself. I don't have enough room here to continue.

Posted by: old conservative | Aug 20, 2008 8:15:50 PM

I am wondering what black people perspective is Toby Keith providing? As far as Barack Obama's ability to invoke various vernacular, I am okay with it...I do it myself. "when in Rome" as the olding saying goes. At least when Barack does it he is speaking from and about his own point of view not trying to inaccurately describe someone else's.

Posted by: Times2 | Aug 14, 2008 3:12:14 PM

Obama is going to win & he's what we all need. So stop hating.

Posted by: Christy | Aug 11, 2008 4:51:33 PM

The funniest thing about this is that.. it is true testament of why America is not yet ready for a minority president. because the majority of Americans do not understand minorities. They choose to listen to stereotypes and treat those stereotypes as facts instead of seeking out the true meaning of where minorites are coming from.The fact that Mr. Obama is articulate makes him"Not Black Enough" for black people, this a sad truth about the Black community and it makes those Black Americans with an education feel ostracized because they don't speak in Ebonics. the fact that when he speaks he adapts to his environment does not make him a phony... it makes him a good public speaker. Why would he speak to a group of southern high school graduates with words that only Harvard Grads would understand..I think Mr. Keith's comment is a tell-tell sign of how people really view educated minorities.. and we should educate people with this point of view. Unfortunately most Americans have only been exposed to one type of black person and this is the one that the media likes to exploit .. The uneducated, irresponsible ignorant ones.. not the Barack Obamas of the world!

Posted by: Randall J | Aug 11, 2008 10:27:20 AM

Thanks for another perspective from the Prep School Press. In other unannounced/uncovered actual news - here's a piece of interesting commentary from the WSJ:

"The underreported economic news of the week is that Barack Obama favors a stronger dollar. Even better, he thinks a stronger greenback would help to reduce oil prices."

Let's see, what would a real reporter cover? The economy? The petroleum crisis? No. The deep opinions of a country western star. Thanks for another piece of in-depth, relevant journalism.

Posted by: mara | Aug 11, 2008 1:28:16 AM

[QUOTE] The sad truth is that Barack "talks black" [and Southern] whenever he addresses a predominately black audience. He even makes references to racial stereotypes like "Popeye's Fried Chicken" to his black supporters and they totally eat it up [no pun intended]. Then, whenever Barack addresses a predominately white audience his Harvard education speak starts up again. WHO IS THIS MAN?! Who wants such a phoney baloney as our next President? Not this Democrat, thats for darn sure. [QUOTE]

To be able to relate to and appeal to the likes and dislikes of different groups of people simply makes Barack worldly and smart. If you're intimidated by that, then I don't want YOU for president.

Posted by: Beth | Aug 10, 2008 11:01:32 PM

The sad truth is that Barack "talks black" [and Southern] whenever he addresses a predominately black audience. He even makes references to racial stereotypes like "Popeye's Fried Chicken" to his black supporters and they totally eat it up [no pun intended]. Then, whenever Barack addresses a predominately white audience his Harvard education speak starts up again. WHO IS THIS MAN?! Who wants such a phoney baloney as our next President? Not this Democrat, thats for darn sure.

Posted by: PhillyPaul | Aug 10, 2008 9:03:38 PM

Toby, shhhhhhhhhhhh.............

Posted by: 100% Agree | Aug 10, 2008 8:15:30 PM

Unfortunately, Mr. Keith's comments suggest a real issue in this country. "Artists" like Jay-Z, Diddy, and Lil Kim sell their music, ideology, and behavior to mainstream America. As a result, there is a one-dimensional image of Black Americans that dominates. Don't believe me? Watch BET. I rarely watched because the programming is BEYOND offensive and ignorant, and I'm black.(Tavis Smiley was the exception) As a result of all the sterotypes that many Black entertainers sell to make money, any black person who speaks English properly, gets good grades, or thinks outside the box is "acting white." Do I act white because I abhor the welfare system? Does my husband act white because he wears his pants around his waist with a belt?

Obama isn't "acting white." He is behaving in a manner befitting his education and upbringing.

Posted by: Leslie | Aug 10, 2008 2:03:38 PM

Is there any truth to the rumor that Toby Keith will soon appear on the Suday morning news shows, offering his in-depth analyses and other startling jingoistic political insights on the current status of race relations in the US?

Posted by: chuck | Aug 10, 2008 1:31:23 PM

Is this still news? Wow.
If Sen Obama wins will this be the nation's focus?
He grew up in Hawaii.But he doesn't sound like it.

Posted by: mhm | Aug 10, 2008 12:46:17 PM

Obama is where he is because he is a educated, intelligent and well-spoken man. He acts in a professional manner, not like a Caucasian! There are many successful black CEO's and business owners and the like and they are doing good in their careers because of their intelligence and the will to succeed. Why does so many white americans attribute many black successes to those blacks acting or trying to be white?

Posted by: sickandtired | Aug 10, 2008 11:12:00 AM

I can't help but laugh at all the people who claim they aren't familiar with what 'acting black' is really all about. I live in the deep south and just like anywhere else, we have good and bad black and white people. Thanks to our constitution any group can portray themselves culturally through speech, clothing, music, whatever. I don't think Obama 'acts white', he act like a mature adult. No, I don't plan on voting for him, but just like many mature adults, he can be a very engaging speaker.

Posted by: Nic | Aug 10, 2008 8:33:30 AM

tim {{3 of my best friends are black, and they say they will not vote for Obama because he is "not black enough". I asked what they meant by that and they told me it would not make sense to me.}} -- You lie through your teeth because if your friends where so call “Black enough” then they wouldn't be your friends.

Posted by: JD | Aug 10, 2008 6:20:48 AM

The author ends his article with "wow" as if Toby Keith is 'controversial'. Well I would bet if the author put a little thought into Toby's words, he would probably believe them. However, the only reason Obama has been ahead in polls is because of his adoring media worshipers. They abuse their responsibility by using their jobs as reporters to influence an election with their slanted coverage towards Obama's favor and so that they can crown their man the winner.

Posted by: s | Aug 10, 2008 1:46:24 AM

Toby Keith is so fine, I don't care what he says.
Besides, you all are just trying to be politically correct. Every one of you believe the same thing if you'd just tell the truth.

Posted by: JustDuckie | Aug 9, 2008 11:15:52 PM

To start with, I like TK and his alter egos music.
As far as all the racial comments, I will vote for the person that I believe supports the most of my views, not by the color of their skin.
To everyone of voting age- check where each candidate stands on the views that are most important to you.

Posted by: Sailoron | Aug 9, 2008 9:41:14 PM

3 of my best friends are black, and they say they will not vote for Obama because he is "not black enough". I asked what they meant by that and they told me it would not make sense to me.

Posted by: tim | Aug 9, 2008 8:35:22 PM

Somebody should burn his cds like he pushed people to do when The Dixie Chicks said their little spill about Bush!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by: Tina | Aug 9, 2008 8:06:25 PM

Toby Keith and George Bush are what's wrong with America today. Both are shining examples why Americas image has taken a big hit worldwide. One a elitist Neocon,the other a ignorant redneck.

Posted by: AJ | Aug 9, 2008 7:33:48 PM

if you put a person behind a wall and let me hear them talk i can tell you if they are white or black .. unless its obama of coarse

Posted by: j rola | Aug 8, 2008


Bulllony you could!!

Toby Keith is just bringing to light ignorant and false ideas that permeate our society. We DO need to bring these things up to expose them for the falsehoods they are. Way to go Toby! Thanks for being so "ignernt". (thats how we say it in PA) Dialects are regional and have nothing to do with skin color. Period.

Posted by: Pam C | Aug 9, 2008 5:46:57 PM

You make a good points Natacha. Words to definately consider. Thanks...

Posted by: TonyM | Aug 9, 2008 5:18:12 PM

Who cares what TK thinks. We don't base our opinions on what he thinks. I'm sick of people saying they stand for "family values" and "freedom" but vote for canidates who endorse the killing of the unborn. Everyone knows that race does play an issue in an election anyway. Most whites vote for whites and most blacks do the same. What is Obama anyway? He is biracial! So why does everyone call him black? Give me a break. Quit whining about race and stereotypes. Personally, I'm sick of hearing about race and how racial groups are victims, etc. Get over it and move on.

Posted by: Jewels | Aug 9, 2008 4:35:55 PM

I'm amazed that someone can introduce his comments and use words like "wit" or "wisdom." His statement, "carries himself as a Caucasian" was rude and overwhelming racist. How do you carry yourself like a Caucasian? Culturally, how do you describe a Caucasian? I guess, the better question is how does he perceive "black society?"

Posted by: Natacha | Aug 9, 2008 4:28:21 PM

I have it hard enough being a 29year old African American Republican, who is strong supporter of GW. But when I have stupid comments coming from folks who; "aren't racist, that's just a stereotype. Republicans stand for family values and freedom." - Words I have to repeat over and over to friends who can't understand my political allegiance. I would hate to think after all these years, that I was one who was mistaken..

TonyM:

I have to admit a am a bi racial black & white man I too supported President Bush both terms I also thought that Republicans stood for family values and freedom." - Words I used to repeat over and over to friends who didn't understand my political allegiance.

Well I've learned in the last eight years that President Bush did nothing for values and nothing for freedom and McCain will follow right along with Bush. I also learned being a Republican or a Democrat has nothing to do with what you believe.

The party line politics myth is over and we can thank Hillary Clinton for opening our eyes on that one. Wake up people no longer can you believe that one party or the other is gonna represent you because you are a Democrat or a Republican.

Don't vote red or blue, vote the issues at hand, such as jobs, housing and bringing our troops home.
By the way TonyM I am proud to say I am a Independent now. Obama08/12

Posted by: Orlando B. Fremont Ohio | Aug 9, 2008 4:19:10 PM

Jeff in Kansas: This gentlemen you speak about sounds like a true success story and very intelligent. That being said, you state that his daughter told him that she knew nothing about Sen. Obama but the only thing that mattered was that he was black. Correct!

The guy you just described to everyone sounds very smart but being black & white myself and have came from the same kind of tough background, it seems that your mentor of 20 yrs would have educated his daughter at a very young age that politics would play a very big role in her life.

It would also seem to me that knowing where her father came from and how far he has came that she would be a very intelligent young lady and would honer him by being well informed about every decision she would make in her life.

The fact is black people in the United States are very well informed about Sen Barack Obama. I work with young kids that have come from back grounds just like the one you describe your black friend has went through and worse and all of these kids that aren't even old enough to vote are very much engaged in this years Election and know the policy differences.

Some of them even have family members in IRAQ and Afghanistan and would like them to come home alive and not in a box. I myself have family their and would like them to get out of the illegal war that Bush put us in and the war that John McCain wants to continue for the next 100 years.

My own kids who are 6 and 13 know the policy differences between Obama and McCain because we discuss them in our home.

So it strikes me as very odd that a grown woman who is old enough to vote in the biggest Election in her lifetime knows nothing about Sen Barack Obama.
I'm not calling you a liar but that is a mighty tall tail.

You did a nice job invoking Martin Luther Kings name to drive your very suspect message but why don't you give us a list of all the shady characters San. Obama has had around him and the shady characters Sen McCain has around him. Are you sure you want to compare the two?

Please explain to us in detail your understanding of the policy differences between Sen. Obama and McCain.

Posted by: Orlando B. Fremont Ohio | Aug 9, 2008 3:55:00 PM

Freedom of Speech....leave the guy alone for expressing his views and alot of others, I'm sure. Too bad this election has to be so full of racial distractions, as an Obama presidency will be too.

Posted by: Debra | Aug 9, 2008 3:47:00 PM

I have it hard enough being a 29year old African American Republican, who is strong supporter of GW. But when I have stupid comments coming from folks who; "aren't racist, that's just a stereotype. Republicans stand for family values and freedom." - Words I have to repeat over and over to friends who can't understand my political allegiance. I would hate to think after all these years, that I was one who was mistaken..

Posted by: TonyM | Aug 9, 2008 3:29:35 PM

As an educator, I hear the phrase “not acting Black” far too often. When I access the students who are characterized this way, they tend to be the students who are flourishing
academically and have the potential to be successful in their adult life WITHOUT stealing and selling drugs. On the other hand, students who deem it important to wear their pants so that their underwear shows and speak Ebonics tend to be underachievers that don’t live up to their potential. A person’s dialect does not make him a man or woman. An individual’s ability to thrive legally and moralistically in our society should be the true measure of a person.

Up to this point, Obama has shown that he is making every attempt to project himself as a prominent AMERICAN we can be proud of, and one who we can use as a positive role model to all children. Hopefully,African-American children will see what can happen if they work hard and stay focused on school and work.

Obama is bashed for many things, but I don’t think “being black” should be one of them. In my opinion, this is just another maneuver by the republicans to divide the black vote. DON”T BE FOOLED!

Posted by: Yvonne | Aug 9, 2008 3:28:11 PM

I have always been a fan of Toby Keith. While I am not a supporter of George Bush, I liked the fact that Toby Keith stood up for him when the Dixie Chicks said what they did. I don't believe that you should talk badly about the leader of your country no matter how much you dislike him. But I have to say that I am very disappointed in him for saying what he did. I am a 31 year old white woman and to me that is one of the most racist things to say. What is acting/ talking/ or carrying yourself as a black person? What is acting/ talking/ or carrying yourself as a white person? I have always voted Republican, but every since I first heard and saw Obama speak he has had my vote and it has nothing to do with him carrying himself as any race. He is an intelligent man. And it's time to finally have one of those as the leader of this great nation.

Posted by: katie | Aug 9, 2008 2:11:59 PM

I'm not a fan of Obama (nor McCain for that matter), but I've got to say that I've been reading these posts and can't tell who is black and who is white. I think that proves nobody has to "talk" a certain way. I think we do need more dialogue about race in the country no matter who wins the election. But right now, I would prefer both candidates make sure that all of us AMERICANS have jobs and security. Both candidates have ideas on how to achieve this. I just wish everyone would quit making up their minds about who to vote for without looking deeper than an article that's just trying to get a rise out of everyone to sell subscriptions or get viewers. Look at both candidates with an open mind. Hear what both sides have to say. Choose according to the policies you agree with. From my perspective, the half white/half black issue is deviding us along the wrong lines. Looking at the issues, my ideal candidate is half Obama/half McCain.

Posted by: Duh-wain | Aug 9, 2008 1:24:14 PM

Oonogil:

Obama’s people shouldn't’t shout “racism” every time someone says something against their hero either? What! Who exactly are his people? Are you talking about all the black, white, woman, man, gay, straight people that voted for Barack?

Are you talking about just black people? The fact is Obama is loved by all walks of life but it's people like yourself that want to hide behind the politics of the candidate so that you don't have to admit you may have some issues with race. HIS PEOPLE! That's funny!

Posted by: Orlando B. Fremont Ohio | Aug 9, 2008 12:55:40 PM

Obama is his own person. There are plenty of whites behaving in a manner that Mr. Keith would call "black". Toby would be wise to keep the trap shut.

Posted by: Ben Straub | Aug 9, 2008 12:03:54 PM

What is a Toby Keith? Is this some uneducated racist moron from the South?
Looks like he needs a bath.

Posted by: imacrank | Aug 9, 2008 12:03:06 PM

Wow! People are always making something huge out of nothing. The fact is the majority of people who are black do talk a certain way, just like white people do, asians do and many other races do as well. So what! What's so bad about that? We are different, get over it people! It's not a bad thing! How boring would the world be if we were all the same! The drama llama strikes again!

Posted by: stacy | Aug 9, 2008 11:55:45 AM

There are some deep underlying concerns about Mr. Keith’s statement, which really has transcended through the years. We attend school to be educated. Education encompasses a variety of forms of skill development, including speaking, articulation as well as the basics: math, reading, social studies, science, etc. When a person attains and masters these skills (in particular, the skill of oratory and “acceptable” presence) some contribute their persona as acting “Caucasian”. This stems to expectations that some individuals have for various groups of people and unfortunately it goes back to slavery. Mr. Obama is a well-educated “man” and he exemplifies the education and knowledge that he has received. Nothing else and never less should be expected of him or any other person. Black or White should not be the conversations here. EDUCATION has been the key to his success, as it is for any other person. We are expressing our own judgmental values and expectations when we contribute specific characteristics to a particular group. Also,Mr. Keith might want to take some time for self-reflection about what "his" perceptions of people are. His public statement is a societal issue.

Posted by: Shirley | Aug 9, 2008 11:11:37 AM

Barrack Obama wasn’t raised in an African American community by African American parents. You wouldn’t expect someone from the Bronx to sound like someone from San Antonio.

Still, it was a dumb thing for Keith to say. Race should have nothing to do with the election. Obama’s people shouldn’t shout “racism” every time someone says something against their hero either.

I don’t care what color he is, I just don’t like his political views.

Posted by: Oonogil | Aug 9, 2008 11:03:28 AM

noexit:
You have to remember this, all Democrats that have ran for President have received over 90% of the black vote. As far as Jessie Jackson and Al. Sharpton they lost the respect of the black community a long time go. I hate to say it but those two are no different then Rev. Wright who have made a living keeping people divided. That being said they have still done a lot of positive things for the black community and are well respected for that. No one is perfect but I think that we are at the tipping point where people have had enough of the divisions and want to move past it but people have t want to have serious dialog and instead of talking at each other we should be talking to each other. Sen Obama should not only be seen as a leader for blacks but for whites also because the fact is he is the face of America.

Posted by: Orlando B. Fremont Ohio | Aug 9, 2008 10:46:19 AM

Keith said essentially the same thing of Obama that Al Shapton said.

Posted by: Vote None of the Above | Aug 9, 2008 10:38:07 AM

Marlene said "Stop assuming that all blacks will vote for Obama. Black people, not unlike any other race on the face of the planet, are capable of forming their own thoughts and opinions on the many serious topics and issues impacting all of America".

I appreciate your sentiments Marlene. However, I promise you that when the election is over the numbers will show 90+% of black people voted for Obama.

Posted by: noexit | Aug 9, 2008 10:35:27 AM

It's great we are talking about race, even though it's so painful but now that were talking about it does anyone have any solutions on how to fix the race problem we have? This know a good time to have honest adult conversation with each other about race. Why don't people start by giving a little background about themselves and start ask each other serious questions. Isn't that what we want?

Posted by: Orlando B. Fremont Ohio | Aug 9, 2008 10:34:00 AM

First of all most of you commenting must not be from the south. There is a distinct difference in the Black and White cultures. Here in the South there would be a very notable difference in how BHO presented himself and the average black person. There would be a no notable difference in George Bush's mannerisms and speech in relation to the average Texan. It may have not been delivered in an very inteligent manner but the point that was made was valid none the less. Tiger Woods has been greatly dismissed by the black community for his mannerisms.

Posted by: Kevin | Aug 9, 2008 10:24:07 AM

If the polls are right, a public tired of Republicans is beginning to think an increasingly bothersome Obama would be no better -- and maybe a lot worse. It is one thing to suggest to voters that they should shed their prejudices, eat less and be more cosmopolitan. But it is quite another when the sermonizer himself too easily evokes race, weekly changes his mind and often sounds like he doesn't have a clue what he's talking about.

Posted by: hillary1st | Aug 9, 2008 10:21:29 AM

I think success has gone to toby keith's head. I don't think he is so hot.

I like Obama. He will show everyone that is racist. That Obama will be an excellent president. Obama has class, patience and kindness. And I respect him.
Obama 2008

Posted by: mary | Aug 9, 2008 9:48:05 AM


When I lived in the north, I assumed that all black people had their own way of speaking. But when I move to the south, I learned that what I assumed was a "black
person way of talking" was just a southern way of talking." For the first year every
time I answered the phone, I would say to myself, "I think the caller is black." And then I was surprised when I met them that they were white. So since must blacks do have roots that go to the south, so what we now attribute as a black way of talking is simply roots that go back to Mr. Keith country singing roots. Put Mr Keith in Nashville, his country capitol and blind fold him. Then bring out 20 well educated blacks and 20 well educated whites. Have them read the same sentences. He won't be able to tell you the difference. Do the same test with 20 uneducated blacks and 20 uneducated white and the results will be the same.
I listen to Mr Keith type of talk day in and day out since I moved here. I listen closely and smile. Racism has deep roots in America. The difference is that it is now disguised as "Concern for America or "Speaking plainly" by
the Likes of fear mongering news "reporter" Beck, O Reilly,Dobbs and the copy cats. I wish I had a magic wand to undo this sadness. Many thought education was the key. I dare say that these men have educated minds. But who has educated their hearts? That is my question.

Posted by: Sonia | Aug 9, 2008 9:34:35 AM

Toby Keith is entitled to his opinion- and to attempt to speak the truth. He may or may not be right but I am sick to the gills of throwing celebrities to the lions because they said something offensive to someone [meanwhile Hip-Hop blares every offensive anti-establishment bit of claptrap it wants and people play it to show how cool they are]. We're all brain-washed, confused and cowardly.

Posted by: rob bingham | Aug 9, 2008 9:26:17 AM

I can't read Toby Keith's mind but when
was the last time did any one hear Obama
say he was proud of his "white" heritage
vice numerous remarks praising his "black" heritage?

Posted by: dornooc | Aug 9, 2008 9:12:39 AM

President Obama -- Get used to it!

Posted by: JD | Aug 9, 2008 8:59:10 AM

Don´t you wish Rev. Wright was around to comment on this?

Posted by: Sally J. | Aug 9, 2008 8:52:35 AM

Obama is as white as he is black. Therefore, he's..."Blaucasian" or, perhaps "Whack". And, yes, this is all tongue in cheek. But in all fairness, you can't call him "black" without being inaccurate or even, dare I say it, RACIST (against WHICH race, though, is the question).

Posted by: Walter | Aug 9, 2008 7:02:09 AM

Obama's family background has virtually nothing in common with the average Black American who's descendents were brought here as slaves. However, the color of his skin is still an issue or we wouldn't be talking about it.

Posted by: Peter Ramsey | Aug 9, 2008 3:34:44 AM

I know a lot of professional, well educated, black people that will still say, "I axed yuzz'a questions"

I've also heard MANY black people say of other successful black people, "They are not black, they have forgotten their roots." For example, I’ve heard several black people say that about Col. Powell and I heard it on TV when they were getting interviewed.

So I do not think Toby is that far off by saying what he said. I think there are far more blacks out there thinking exactly that! Lets not forget, Obama is only half black and he was raised by a white family. He's no more black than I am! Skin color is just an illusion.

Posted by: Adelyn | Aug 9, 2008 2:18:07 AM

Tobey Keith wasn't insulting blacks. what he was saying is, most blacks speak a slightly different style of English, i.e., "what's dat?" or, "dialouge baby," or, using plurals in English when a singular should be used, i.e., "HIMS" instead of "HIS." Senator Obama speaks correct English. I've never heard Senator Obama use English plurals incorrectly.

Posted by: Pointman | Aug 9, 2008 1:59:16 AM

What the hell does acting black mean. It is a damn shame that in 2008 some ignorant people still don't think that a black person can be smart, educated, and well spoken. And if they are they are acting white or their not black enough. That is the dumbest piece of crap I've ever heard. Hey stupid, we are educated, we are smart, and we are well spoken and being so doen't make us less black you moron. How does Tobey Keith even know the black perspective, don't you have to be black to know the black perspective. We are all different, but we are all equal. Tobey Keith is a very ignorant person I feel sad for him being so dumb.

Posted by: Helena B. | Aug 8, 2008 10:53:16 PM

What the heck is acting Black or White enough. What happened to being HUMAN......??????

Posted by: tired of the crap | Aug 8, 2008 9:50:37 PM

Toby Keith didn't say anything that Obama hasn't said about white people...The "Typical" Black person...So get over it...If Blacks can say it and you think nothing of it whites can say it to...This is America...Not Africa America...

Posted by: PCC | Aug 8, 2008 9:39:44 PM

It's looks like the beginning of the END for ol' Johnny Boy. TPM reports in the article "Group To Ask Justice Department To Probe McCain's Bundlers"...."A good government group is set to ask the Justice Department to open a criminal investigation into the two big McCain stories of recent days -- the bundled contributions from Hess executives, and the bundling by Harry Sargeant, the guy who raised cash for McCain from a host of unlikely donors." More bad news for McCain as conservative magazines are bailing on the Republican nominee...."Things really have deteriorated between John McCain and the press: even the Wall Street Journal editorial board is turning on him. The famously conservative group publishes a column praising the economic policy of none other than Barack Obama". OBAMA 08'

Posted by: peoples_prez | Aug 8, 2008 9:23:40 PM

Pathetic.

Posted by: candice | Aug 8, 2008 8:58:08 PM

America believes that Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton speak for all black americans because thats what the racist media wants us all to believe. Most blacks do not subscribe to what they have to say. The media does not seek out the educated black men and women the speak because then uninformed white america will see that we are just as diverse as any other people and thats what the racist media has tried to suppress and hide for many years. Mr. Keith along with many other americans (white & black) have brought into this crap. Obama and many other educated black americans scare and worry a lot of white america (not all)because they fear they will lose power. Knowledge is power!

Posted by: Believe | Aug 8, 2008 8:54:45 PM

Remember what your divine one said - there is no blue America, there is no red America, there is only one America. I think he should have included that there is no black America, there is no white America in that mantra. Get with the program, folks!

Posted by: Beckie | Aug 8, 2008 8:46:07 PM

Toby Keith doesn't talk like other white people do.

And McCain couldn't keep it in his pants either.

Posted by: Tofu Keefe | Aug 8, 2008 8:39:13 PM

I'm curious to know who and what black people Toby Keith really knows. I'm willing to bet that its not many. I'm white myself and I would like to encourage more of us to really make the effort to get to meet and know black people and vice virsa. The media has givin us all false images and only the negative images for years because most of the media has been inherently racist. Its been my experience that most people that make the type of comments that Mr. Keith made, usually don't even know any black people or have even made the effort to really know black people.

Posted by: Just Curious | Aug 8, 2008 8:30:51 PM

On a related topic, to those whites who don't know any better, please stop assuming that Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton and their like speak for all black people. They don't!!! They just happen to have loud mouths, access to microphones and the press. Stop assuming that all blacks will vote for Obama. Black people, not unlike any other race on the face of the planet, are capable of forming their own thoughts and opinions on the many serious topics and issues impacting all of America.

Posted by: Marlene | Aug 8, 2008 8:28:22 PM

Big news here... a guy that grew up in the suburbs and becomes a fake cowboy is making judgements on the authenticity of anyone? This is a joke... right?

Posted by: Rick_VT | Aug 8, 2008 8:17:59 PM

Mr. Keith belives this because the only black people he knows or knows of, are the black people that the media of this country puts before us. They are either rappers, criminals, uneducated dumb #####. The media has done this for as long as there has been newspapers and tv and it is not by accident. The end result is that we have like Mr. Toby who actually believe that these are the only black people in America. The fact is that Obama is more like a lot of black people than most white Americans realize. Obama talks like an educated black man or better yet, an educated man...period. If Mr. Keith wants to make these type statements about what black people in america and what they think, he should at least get out and meet more black people. Then maybe he won't come off as such a #######when he speaks.

Posted by: MGreen | Aug 8, 2008 8:13:23 PM

As I recall TK slammed the Dixie Chicks for speaking up about something other than singing about Earl. Now it's time for him to shut his yap and sing.

I do think that part of the magic of Obama is his multicultural experiences. Raised in "white" America but no doubt hearing snide remarks about his race from some. Then there's the whole Indonesia thing including his sister and step father and living there. And Hawaii, quite "asian". Add to Michelle who has a more traditional "black" American experience. Plus Obama has lived and worked on the south side of Chicago.

He is white. He is black. He is neither. Yet he is all. So is America. So is the world. Perhaps it's the liberal in me, the international humanism of my convictions, or the big rainbow flag I fly, but I look forward to his inauguration: whites, blacks, asians, and international connections. Diversity takes a big step forward.

Posted by: Mike Guilford | Aug 8, 2008 8:11:38 PM

Why do we have to say someone "acts black"? So if any person on this planet speaks well, and carries themselves with dignity they are automatically "caucasion"? If a black man lives a honorable life and speaks well than he's missing something and is not really black? That is the dumbest thing I've ever heard. At this late date & time in history you would think by now we humans would have stepped above racial ignorance & immaturity...but we still have a long way to go.

Posted by: Everett | Aug 8, 2008 7:40:02 PM

I am so tired of people talking like he's not White. He is black and white people. His white mother and grandparents raised him. There's no such thing as talking white or black or anything else. This is really ridiculous and shows how educated some people are in this country. Funny that most of this is coming from white people who do not speak english very well. Plus, I want my president to be able to adapt to any crowd. If he goes overseas, respect that country and try to learn something in their native language. You have to be able to relate to people or at least show some interest in getting to know them. I wish everyone would get that.

Posted by: Marcus | Aug 8, 2008 7:35:45 PM

I am an educated and professional black woman who speaks proper english. In fact, my entire family speaks proper english. It never ceases to amaze me that some whites think all black people speak ebonics and think and act alike. It also never ceases to amaze me when, at times, I encounter other black people who comment that I "sound different" and when pressed to explain what that means they reply that I sound white. Just goes to show there are ignorant and small minded people in every race.

I am always amused whenever I have a phone conversation with someone and then when I meet them, they are shocked to discover that I am black. The shock registers on their face. Priceless!

Posted by: Marlene | Aug 8, 2008 7:29:37 PM

The reason Obama talks "white" is very simple, to get the white vote. If he spoke "black" this would ruin any chance of his nomination in late August, at the convention. It has been noted, that Obama has spoke "black" on occasion with black friends and mostly black crowds. This is proof, he will do anything for a vote. This proves Mr. Keith is correct.

Posted by: sally in jacksonville | Aug 8, 2008 7:29:05 PM

Toby Keith is a jerk -- He proved that with the Dixie Chicks. (Watch "Shut up and Sing". He's a Republic puppet.

Posted by: Brenda Starr | Aug 8, 2008 7:26:09 PM

But something was said about Ludacris, Pastor Wright, etc. So there has been criticism both ways. You all downplay what has been said about Obama, but get outraged when there's retaliation. It happens. Plus, to be honest Ludacris didn't say anything about white people as a whole. He even talked about Jesse Jackson in the video. It was only 2 minutes long, the least you could do was watch the whole thing to have a good basis for argument.

Posted by: Marcus | Aug 8, 2008 7:22:11 PM

Actually the polls did turn towards McCain last week. This week Obama has regained himself to a 5-point lead again. Stay updated people.

Posted by: Marcus | Aug 8, 2008 7:18:07 PM

I would just like to know why Toby Kieth believes he can categorize an entire group of people by being so arrogant enough to say "Obama doesn't act black". The fact the statement was even made shows us that racism, prejudice, discrimination, and stereotyping does not have a peaceful future.

Posted by: Enlightened | Aug 8, 2008 7:16:43 PM

"the polls are turning in favor of John McCain" It's about time! McCain has been running from behind since the beginning of this campaign! I know his legs must be tired from chasing people for all these months.

Posted by: Marathon Runner | Aug 8, 2008 7:15:58 PM

to 90210: "Obama proves his "change" motto. He got the "change" from Bush in 2000 campaign'....Just a politician..."

Of course, he is a politician. They all are. Bush, McCain, Obama, etc...
They all flip-flop and change.. Big deal..
This is a political circus. Enjoy ;(((

Posted by: ghost | Aug 8, 2008 7:14:39 PM

The media still has a "celeb" status for Obama. Toby can express his opinion, as this is his right as a citizen, but anything against "The One" is racist and wrong. However, the Obama followers can talk negative about McCain and Hillary and nothing is said. Obama hides behind his aides and blind followers, like a coward. This is why the polls are turning in favor of John McCain.

Posted by: Art in Dayton | Aug 8, 2008 7:12:00 PM

Sounds like you need an Obama presidency. Just what the doctor ordered.