Political Punch
Power, pop, and probings from ABC News Senior White House Correspondent Jake Tapper

« Previous | Main | Next »

McCain Again Flubs Highlighted Attack Lines

October 21, 2008 8:44 PM

No one ever said campaigning for president was easy, particularly in these last grueling few weeks.

Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., this week has been flubbing not just parts of his speeches, but the pivotal attack lines his campaign prepares reporters to film and record.

In Belton, Mo., Monday, McCain was supposed to say, "Just last night, Senator Biden guaranteed that if Senator Obama is elected, we will have an international crisis to test America's new president. We don't want a president who invites testing from the world at a time when our economy is in crisis and Americans are already fighting in two wars."

What he actually said, per ABC News' Bret Hovell: "Just last night, Senator Obama (sic) guaranteed that if Senator Obama is elected, Senator Biden said, we will have an international crisis to test America's new president," etc. etc.

He flubbed it again in the extended version of the attack.

"What's more troubling is that Senator Obama (sic) told their campaign donors that when that crisis hits, they would have to stand with them because it wouldn't be apparent Senator Obama would have the right response."

And this is from a teleprompter!

Today in Western Pennsylvania, per ABC News' Jan Simmonds, McCain attempted to repudiate remarks about the area made by Rep. Jack Murtha, D-Pa., last week.

"There is no question that western Pennsylvania is a racist area," Murtha said. He later apologized, but yesterday he told WTAE-TV in Pittsburgh that "this whole area, years ago, was really redneck."

So McCain, sensing an opportunity, said the following.

Which probably couldn't have gone worse:

"I think you may have noticed that Senator Obama's supporters have been saying some pretty nasty things about western Pennsylvania lately," McCain said, as folks booed.

"You know," he continued, "I couldn't agree with them more."

(Sound of crickets chirping.)

"I couldn't disagree with you, I couldn't agree with you more than the fact that western Pennsylvania is the most patriotic, most God loving, most patriotic part of America," McCain said. "And this is a great part of the country. My friends, I couldn't agr--  I could not disagree with those critics more, this is a great part of America."

Yikes.

- jpt

October 21, 2008 | Permalink | Share | User Comments (170)

User Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I had some respect for McCain because of his courage to reject war and injustices in a very humble way. Now he is even sounding and acting racist and xenophobic.

Not to mention he is getting too close with the extreme-right bunch that he was well known for disagreeing with in a fair and impartial way, always on the side of justice and common sense.

I really miss the old McCain. Too bad he sold his soul to the extreme right.

Posted by: Juan | Oct 22, 2008 11:05:01 PM

Sir,

I am a Vietnam Veteran, who spent two and a half years in the friggin jungles of Vietnam in a Marine Recon unit. I learned a great lesson in war...that war is not about who is right...only who is left. Apparently you do not know McCain as well as those who were in the POW camp with him. Do your homework. Once you know the truth...perhaps you will comprehend more. We will never promote 'democracy' thru firepower. We cannot nuke away the ideals of others. We cannot swap steel with those who have a differing idea of the world and be the 'winners.' There are no winners in war. There are only mothers who have lost their sons or daughters and only wives or hsubands who sleep alone and tell their children what a great person their father was. John McCain supports the EXACT same ideas if George Bush. 'If we don't agree I will not even talk to you. And if you press your opinions on me, I will bomb you into non-existence.' I, sir, have a pretty box on the wall with a lot more medals and ribbons than John McCain has...and it don't mean a darn thing to anybody but me, and to all those friends who I left behind in Vietnam. Do some homework and study the words of those who spent time in the same POW camp with Mr. McCain. It may open your eyes.

Posted by: Larry W | Oct 22, 2008 9:41:16 PM

To 'A Simple Voter'

'...though things have improved somewhat I believe.'

Fascinating what having a few of them doing time in prison does for keeping the rest of them on their toes, eh? :)

Posted by: Larry W | Oct 22, 2008 7:35:34 PM

This may not be taken very well by the person who suggested outlawing lobbying. However, as I understand it lobbying itself falls under constitutional protection as "the right to petition the government for redress and grievances". I am not certain that is the exact wording, but to petition the government does fall under the title of "lobbying" as well. What we need is reform on how it is conducted, though things have improved somewhat I believe.

Posted by: A Simple Voter | Oct 22, 2008 5:54:27 PM

The problem with the Senate and congress is they are littered with "money-for-votes" lobbyists. Are elected officials are constantly faced with a delemna... do I press this button (because it's the right one to press) or do I press this one (and get that nice chunky check deposited into my foundation's account? decisions, decisions...)

We need to CLEAN HOUSE, beginning with those corporate lobbyists. Make lobbying illegal and punishible by jail and loss of any professional/business liscensing. That should shift some power back to "We The People".

How bout that?

Posted by: Davibaby | Oct 22, 2008 4:56:02 PM

Well gosh, those pesky teleprompters can be as tough to handle as a fighter plane! Opps.

Posted by: Larry W | Oct 22, 2008 4:43:43 PM

Dear "moderate"

There is a fundimental difference between truth and fact. Facts are indisputable, truth is relevant.

Here are the facts:

1. He really isn't as smart as Obama,

2. He can't pick a running mate worth a damn.

3. He is ill-tempered ,compulsive and hot headed.

4. He doesn't have a clue about the economy."

5. Being a "Maverick" is costing him the campaign. If elected, it will cost us our country, freedoms, liberties, incomes, health, environment, etc....

These are not opinions, they are facts based on what we've all seen and heard, except for folks like you who hear only what pleases you about your candidates, which should be very little. All McCain & Palin do in interviews, speeches & debates is attack, attack, attack. Well what about some good old-fashioned problem solving? How about some remedies? CONCRETE solutions? There is a reason why McCain's crowds are on average 3,000 to Obama's 20,000 (AND GROWING). Instead of thinking all these people for Obama are wrong, maybe it's time you consider that maybe you are. Another fact is: just because he's your party's candidate doesn't mean he's the right choice. If you don't accept this from me then ask Colin Powell. He'll clear it up for you.

I say all this with love and all due respect because that's how we DEMS roll. We take the high road, until you give us a reason to take the gloves off.

Posted by: Davibaby | Oct 22, 2008 4:43:05 PM

Okay,a few comments.

1. Presidential campaigns are grueling, especially this one, which has been going on forever. Not surprising that McCain is losing his bearings; he's an old guy.

2. The presidency is even more gruelling. Clinton and Bush Jr both came out with a lot more gray in their hair then when they went in. It requires youth and vigour.

3. McCain talks about having been tested during the Cuban Missile Crisis. That was 46 years ago and he wasn't calling the shots himself. Good thing too; He was 26 at the time.

Posted by: ThePhotogsBlog | Oct 22, 2008 3:20:17 PM

I think the real reason John McCain 2008 is flubbing these lines is that somewhere deep down inside John McCain 2000 is trying to throttle him.

Posted by: genek1953 | Oct 22, 2008 3:06:21 PM

McCain's advisors try to explain the talking points (all negative, it seems), but it seems McCain must not understand the nuances. If he completely understood *how* the talking points turned into benefits for his own campaign, he wouldn't blunder; he would at least get through the (negative) talking points.

McCain's problem since the Palin pick was foisted upon him is that he has become only a puppet of the RNC and his advisors. He has become something *other* than his true self, and he is having a hard time embracing the dark underworld of the *dirtiest* politics.

While McCain might have lost if he had followed his own true wishes; if he had picked Joe Lieberman for a running mate, he would have remained true to his own self, and he would not be flubbing his handlers' talking points. That would have been a "respectable" campaign whether he would have won or lost, and in that sense EVERYONE has lost.

The "wise men" political advisors (and we have seen enough of their antics over the last eight years to last a lifetime) should be tarred, feathered, and run out of the political scene forever.

Posted by: EGBB | Oct 22, 2008 2:50:59 PM

I don't think one needs to look any further than Gov. Palins' apparent vacuousness to find the most unsettling reason for her fall in approval polls.

Yesterday, she was asked again (for maybe the forth time publicly) what the VPs' reponsibilites include, from a 3rd grader. She repeated the gibberish she's been mistakenly expousing about the VP presiding over the Senate. I bet at least half of the 3rd graders know better.

Is this the type of intellectual we want with the launch codes?

Posted by: Bob Whiteman | Oct 22, 2008 1:51:52 PM

PA Dem,

I'll bite. But I notice that after admonishing us to talk positively about our own candidate rather than run down the other, you turn around and run down John McCain. Double standard, much?

You wrote-- in all caps to get our attention:
"THE ONLY THING McCAINS CAMPAIGN HAS ATTEMPTED TO DO TO DATE IS TELL US WHY (MAYBE) WE SHOULDN'T VOTE FOR HIS OPPONENT - WHAT HAS JOHN McCAIN DONE TO GARNER OUR VOTE ?"

Actually, that is not the only thing McCain talks about, its just the only thing you and the media focus on. He talks about his economic plans (mortgage buyback plan, capital gains cut, IRA/401K rules temporary rules suspensions, business tax rate cuts, need I go on?), his energy plans (strong emphasis on nuclear, offshore drilling, all-of-the-above support, a competition for an improved electric car battery), his foreign policy (modified surge in Afghanistan, etc.), his trade policy (remember how Obama was completely wrong in his statements on COlumbian free trade agreement?), his tax plans (increased child credit, make bush tax cuts permanent, business tax reductions), and on and on. Those well-reasoned, pragmatic proposals are the reason I am voting for him.

Got to respond to this little rant of yours as well:

"He's isn't as smart (fact) as Obama
He can't pick a running mate worth a damn. He is ill-tempered ,compulsive and hot headed. He doesn't have a clue about the economy."

None of these are facts-- they are opinions, and I do not agree with any of them. So, having answered your questions, do I win a prize?

And he can't fly planes too well either.

Posted by: moderate | Oct 22, 2008 1:51:42 PM

Why don't people stop blaming the Presidency? Notice I did not say any President's name. It's not the office of the Presidency that spends countless hours and countless taxpayer dollars in the Senate and in the House making the laws and regulations. It's the Senators and the Congressmen/women. What we need is a complete cleansing of the entire House and Senate. They haven't gotten anything done, and now they want us to believe it's all the fault of the Office of the President? Come on! Get Real! What legislation has the Office of the President vetoed that caused the collapse of the Financial System? What legislations has the Office of the President written and forced Congress and the Senate to accept? Yes, the incumbent President hasn't been effective in his leadership. But, why not hold our Senators and Congressmen/women accountable? Why do they get a free pass? Focus!!!!

Posted by: JR | Oct 22, 2008 1:39:06 PM

DDayDawg,

I am voting for Obama. That being said, I think deep down McCain is a good man. I truly believe that part of the reason he is having so many problems is because he is saying, and doing, things he doesn't truly believe in.

Pandering to the religious right is not John McCain. Inciting racism and dissent is not the John McCain we have seen over all these years. Deep down he is a good man. But, he has picked horrible advisers, made horrible decisions, made a disastrous VP pick, and that makes him unqualified to be President. So sad to see the down fall of a good and decent man.
___________________________________

I agree with you one hundred percent. I think McCain is an honorable man who is just having a difficult time expressing his true self amidst the "hate" spewing from his party.

Posted by: Beckie | Oct 22, 2008 1:33:48 PM

I have two points. (1) How it is that anyone can keep supporting the McCain campaign and/or the Bush presidency. What does it take to actually point out that this stuff is not working? The collapse of the stock market and financial system, incompetent and corrupt management of the government on all levels - why do honest people still support the Republicans? It is beyond me. (2) in a similar vein, with such incompetence in the Republican party, why is the election so close? (I think that it is closer than the polls would have us think). How incompetent and corrupt would the Republicans have to be for their base to really turn away from them? It is amazing to me, but definitely a learning experience about the American public.

Posted by: Bill Kudrle | Oct 22, 2008 1:13:52 PM

So delivery is paramount...and the issue of a VP candidate casting doubt on his choice of commander in chief is secondary to "thoughtful" media pundits. YIKES indeed.

Posted by: robert b | Oct 22, 2008 1:01:05 PM

Getting cocky? "Who will count the votes" said the little red hen.

Posted by: J. Flagg | Oct 22, 2008 12:03:06 PM

Tracey, excellent workup of the tax diffs. Too bad 0% of us can even understand the tax code.

McCain is all Sound and Fury (signifying nothing)

Posted by: MDark | Oct 22, 2008 12:02:25 PM

Todd Palin, this man would be in the White house if McCain wins, we need to know more about this man. He has played a large role in his wife's governership in Alaska--attending meeting, influencing hireing and fireing decisions. The American people still have not been introduced to Todd Palin. We have not even heard the sound of his voice.

Posted by: Sims | Oct 22, 2008 11:58:33 AM

McCain won't last the final days--the man is too old. His mistake will get worst as the days go on. I am over 50 and know how hard it can be to try to keep up with the pace of a much younger person. If you notice his wife, daughter or Palin has to always stand by his side, while Obama is often campaigning without his wife or other people, he does not need someone to hold him up and keep him from making a mistake.

Posted by: Sims | Oct 22, 2008 11:52:31 AM

Post a comment





 

POLITICAL VIDEOS