RECENT POSTS
- Oprah, Health Care Lobbyists, Among Recent Visitors to White House
- An Obama Thanksgiving Menu, with an Extra Serving of Pie
- White House Thanksgiving Traditions: Broken and Observed
- Obama, GOP Air Differences Over Jobs, Economy In Thanksgiving Addresses
- White House State Dinner Party Crashers
- Obama to Lay Out Emissions Goals in Copenhagen
- Free Bird
- The "Good" War
- The Presidential Planner
- Under the Stars, Obama Toasts India’s Prime Minister
MONTHLY ARCHIVES
« Previous | Main | Next »
Will Obama's Team of Rivals Fare Better Than Lincoln's?
November 23, 2008 10:50 AM
If President-elect Obama indeed appoints Bill Richardson Secretary of Commerce and Hillary Clinton Secretary of State, combined with Vice President-elect Joe Biden, that will be three former primary rivals in his Cabinet.
And as pending White House senior adviser David Axelrod told George Stephanopoulos this morning on This Week, the President-elect "is someone who invites a strong opinions. He enjoys that he thinks that’s an important element of leadership. They are not going to be potted plants in their departments, they are going to be partners and I’m sure that is the message he has given them in their discussions."
It's not just a question of putting some fellow Democratic colleagues on his team.
Try to think of it this way: Obama is putting in his Cabinet three people who not only (at least at one point) have thought they would be better Presidents than he will be, but they put those thoughts to action by running against him.
Abraham Lincoln's "Team of Rivals" model that Obama heralds is an interesting one, but it didn't work out in every case.
Rice University professor Douglas Brinkley says, "it's based on a false historical analogy."
And writing in the Los Angeles Times, Dickinson University historian Matthew Pinsker writes that some of those appointments caused problems. As when Secretary of State William Seward (a former New York Senator and primary rival) "tried to seize political command from Lincoln during the Fort Sumter crisis...the effect of repeated disloyalty and unnecessary backroom drama from him and several other Cabinet officers was a significant factor in the early failures of the Union war effort. By December 1862, there was a full-blown Cabinet crisis.
"'We are now on the brink of destruction,' Lincoln confided to a close friend after being deluged with congressional criticism and confronted by resignations from both Seward and Treasury Secretary Salmon P. Chase...Out of the four leading vote-getters for the 1860 Republican presidential nomination whom Lincoln placed on his original team, three left during his first term —one in disgrace, one in defiance and one in disgust.
"Simon Cameron was the disgraced rival, Lincoln's failed first secretary of war. ["Team of Rivals" author Doris Kearns] Goodwin essentially erased him from her group biography, not mentioning him in the book's first 200 pages, even though he placed third, after Seward and Lincoln, on the first Republican presidential ballot. Cameron proved so corrupt and inept that the Republican-controlled House of Representatives censured him after he was removed from office in 1862.
"Chase was the defiant rival. As Goodwin acknowledges, the Treasury chief never reconciled himself to Lincoln's victory, continuously angling to replace him. Lincoln put up with this aggravation until he secured renomination and then dumped his brilliant but arrogant subordinate because, in his words, their "mutual embarrassment" was no longer sustainable.
"Attorney General Edward Bates was the disgusted rival. The elder statesman — 67 when he was appointed —never felt at home in the Lincoln Cabinet and played only a marginal role in shaping policy. He resigned late in the first term...
"Lincoln was a political genius, but his model for Cabinet-building should stand more as a cautionary tale than as a leadership manual."
-- jpt
November 23, 2008 | Permalink | Share | User Comments (61)
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.
I'm personally disappointed with Obama's choices for his cabinet. He promised change, but now he's appointing career politicians like Hillary Clinton. (Did he forget her sleazy campaign tactics? She makes Lee Atwater look like Mother Theresa.)
Posted by: Jim B | Nov 23, 2008 6:25:14 PM
Barack Obama(bright, intelligent..loves his country)..Hillary Clinton(bright, intelligent..loves her country..Good start president elect..we are supporting you and your picks one hundred percent and more importantly..we are praying for you and your cabinet...God bless these United States of America!
Posted by: Stanley | Nov 23, 2008 6:23:25 PM
Good grief. Obama is as Machiavellian as they get.
Posted by: WestCoastMessenger | Nov 23, 2008 6:23:12 PM
Isn't it refreshing to have a president who is bright,articulate,intelligent and one who does not hold grudges but is more interested in investing in America! Isn't it refreshing to have a president who when he speaks you can feel proud to say "that is my president speaking"..you don't have to worry about green verbs and sentences that do not make any sense! God bless Barack Obama and his cabinet and God bless America for making the right choice!
Posted by: Stanley | Nov 23, 2008 6:17:59 PM
Quite frankly, I think Republicans should be kept away from management at the federal level..they have been a failure and always leaves us with a deficit..Bill Clinton left us with a surplus..Ronald Reagan, Papa Bush left us with big deficits and now Baby Bush is leaving us with the biggest deficit ever in the history of this country. The democrats always have to clean up the mess. Thank God that we now have a smart,level headed thinker who will surround himself with bright people to deal with the current situation that affects our beloved country. God bless Barack Obama and his cabinet and God bles America!
Posted by: Stanley | Nov 23, 2008 6:07:35 PM
The Clintons are capable people without all of the manipulation by media, surragates, and old timers.
I think the Clinton appointment was a bargning chip to get the support that the Obama campaign was convienced it needed to win. To really be "CHANG", if the Clinton's chose not to be involved they should have been left alone and the Obama campaign should have taken the risk. I think they would have been suprised.
If the truth was faced, Obama started to move up with women and the working man's voters before the Clinton drama.
Yhis has the over tones of "calling in favors".
With the push of the media and the oldtimers there was no trust that the new guy was capable of doing the job.
This is the unspoken evidence of the insidius racism in our country. AND THIS IS NOT THE RACE CARD.
Posted by: Jean2 | Nov 23, 2008 6:00:47 PM
Relax folks. It's been so long, you just don't remember how a real "uniter" operates. The last person who ran for president and claimed to be a "uniter" wasn't. Not hardly. So sure it's gonna look a little foreign to ya.
Posted by: foxisms | Nov 23, 2008 5:41:07 PM
Kennedy, you must be a Republican and Republicans are not too bright! You Republicans believe in voodoo economics(trickle down theory)and that you can grow the economy by fighting wars and messing in the internal affairs of other countries. I am an independent voter but democrats always make more sense than Republicans..I normally do not respond to Republicans because they don't have a clue and the average Republican would look you in the eye and try to justify why its more important to spend 10 billion dollars a month to support a baseless,unjust war in Iraq than to invest that same money in Education, healthcare and in growing the economy..God bless Barack Obama and his cabinet and God bless America! The Republicans are about to go! What a sigh of relief! Thank you Lord!
Posted by: Stanley | Nov 23, 2008 5:36:30 PM
Stanley and you are exactly what all politician's, rep and democrat, dream about. A sheep that can be slaughtered.
Posted by: kennedy | Nov 23, 2008 5:27:49 PM
Obama said that he will include a Republican in his cabinet..I am waiting to see who that could be! beside chuck hagel..he will be hard pressed to find a smart Republican..Republicans are rich but not too bright and Obama needs bright people..Haven't you seen what the Republicans have done to our country? They believed that you grow the economy by fighting wars..even my 13 year old daughter know that does not make sense! Thank God the democrats are in to fix this economic problem(I am not even a democrat..Am an Independent voter) but experience has taught me that the democrats are the better of the two evils on the question of domestic policy and focusing on America rather than the outside world..I am an American not an Iraqi or Afghan..America ought to come first. Obama and him bright team will do a great job of turning this country around if they are not blocked by the Republic who are good at playing politics and who put party before country. God bless Barack Obama and his cabinet and God bless America!
Posted by: Stanley | Nov 23, 2008 5:27:42 PM
Jan: You mean like Obama's choice for Treasury secretary? A man that represents the worse curse to the American government. The Federal Reserve. A group of super rich private banks that print us money from nothing and collect interest.
Obama is the twin brother of Bush...seperated at birth. Chosing Timmy for TS is just following the family traditon.
Start buying food....it's more of the same old, same old.
Posted by: kennedy | Nov 23, 2008 5:23:29 PM
Obama is the smartest, most intelligent, most articulate president that we will ever have..sit back and watch! He will do a great job of turning this country around, because he will surround himself with smart people..he will seek their advice and he would make decision based on commonsense..quite unlike George W..God bless Barack Obama and his cabinet and God bless America!
Posted by: Stanley | Nov 23, 2008 5:19:26 PM
What is the most impressive and rewarding experience of Obama is that he sees the situation we are in and is doing his best to surround himself with the best and brightest minds he can, regardless of petty opinions. In fact, his continual standing on higher ground, with noble thinking is exactly what the American people want and need.
The world is faced with several significant challenges, do we have time to bicker, gossip, lie, play games, be ego-centric? I think not. The wake-up call has been given. Action must be based on sound judgement and be swift. My prayer will always be for Obama to have wisdom and understanding and this is what I am pursuing within myself so as to be of service to him and America.
Posted by: srarch | Nov 23, 2008 5:17:36 PM
Jock...what Obama are you seeing? I've heard it from his own words
Posted by: Andrew | Nov 23, 2008 5:16:50 PM
Josehama-
Senator Kennedy stopped drinking some time ago with help from his friend, Senator Hatch. He now has a brain tumor which will probably be fatal but that's no reason to stop kicking him, right?
Posted by: Brooklyn Democrat | Nov 23, 2008 5:06:47 PM
So far, I've been extremely impressed. The Dems have a deep bench and he's calling in all the best talent and assigning them to the roles they are uniquely fitted to succeed at. He will be in charge of a great team, a real Dream Team, that is truly dedicated to fixing America and restoring it to its former glory. Big, positive change is coming!
Posted by: hopesprings52 | Nov 23, 2008 5:02:32 PM
The only thing Bill Richardson should be in charge of is putting wheels of miscarriages. He's a self important, egomaniacal ass who will cause nothing but grief to Obama and his cabinet. I give him about a year before Obama hands him his hat.
Posted by: mrbubbleintrouble | Nov 23, 2008 4:52:39 PM
Let's just hold judgment until his cabinet is seated and he actually begins to govern. At this point, it seems, he can't blink without raising eyebrows.
Posted by: plantain11 | Nov 23, 2008 4:23:21 PM
It's a baited question. Don't answer it. Big brother will come knocking. The SS Agents will pay you a visit.
Posted by: Maxify55 | Nov 23, 2008 4:17:00 PM
Forget whether the team of rivals fairs better than Lincoln's! With Obama fare better than Lincoln?
Posted by: Uranis | Nov 23, 2008 3:53:29 PM
Post a comment


