RECENT POSTS
- Ten Times the Rate of Inflation
- WH: Some Critics 'Serving the Goals of al Qaeda'*
- The Presidential Planner
- Will There Be a Bipartisan Health Care Reform Summit? We Shall See
- A Tale Both Positive and a Cautionary: President Obama's Phantom $15 Billion Program for Small Businesses
- Obama Administration to California Insurance Company: Justify Your 39% Premium Hike
- HAMP Champ: What Ever Happened to That Obama Mortgage Modification Plan?
- Democrats on the Defensive, Republicans Resurgent
- White House: Republicans Were Briefed Abdulmutallab Was In FBI Custody -- Did They Think That Didn't Mean He Was Mirandized?
- The Presidential Planner
MONTHLY ARCHIVES
« Previous | Main | Next »
Gibbs on Capitol Hill Protest: “I'm Sure There's a Jon Voight Joke in Here Somewhere”
November 05, 2009 2:34 PM
Asked about the several thousand protestors who gathered on Capitol Hill today to protest Democratic health care reform legislation, White House press secretary Robert Gibbs joked about one of the actors who was a featured speaker at the rally, saying, “I'm sure there's a Jon Voight joke in here somewhere, given he was one of the featured speakers, but…my father always told me my mouth would get me in trouble, and I have a feeling if I acted on the line that I'd like to give you, I'm almost positive that it would.”
Voight spoke at the rally, decrying the White House’s "radical Chicago tactics,” as did John Ratzenberger, better known as Cliff Clavin from the TV show Cheers.
Many members of Congress, including Rep. Michelle Bachmann, R-Minn., were featured as well, as was conservative talk radio host Mark Levin.
Pressed further for a response to the rally, Gibbs said that “anybody that watches (the rally) is struck by the fact that there's a rally going on without a solution on their side.”
Referring to the House Republican health care reform bill introduced this week, Gibbs said, “they've rolled out a piece of legislation -- and I use those -- I hesitate to even say that. It's -- it's a series of old ideas that -- that wouldn't cut the amount of money government spends on health care nearly to the degree that other bills would. It fails to provide the necessary insurance protections that families and businesses need to assure them that, if they get sick, their coverage isn't going to be dropped or they -- they and their family won't be discriminated against because of pre-existing condition. And it fails to cover virtually anybody in the country that already doesn't have insurance.”
Gibbs said “many in the Republican Party have wanted to be active in this debate, and the piece of legislation they've come up with, I think, is disappointing as a process in this debate and disappointing for millions of Americans that wanted help in finding affordable health care.”
A reporter asked Gibbs if it’s legitimate for protestors just to demonstrate even without a solution to say they don't like the approach the administration and the Democrats are pursuing.
“Absolutely,” Gibbs said. “But this is a representative democracy. I assume they came to Washington to try to solve problems like small businesses that are dropping health care coverage because it's not affordable. So demonstrating is fine. It's well within your constitutionally protected rights in this representative democracy. I would also mention that, if you were a representative in that democracy, it might also be good to have a solution that addresses some of those problems.”
Gibbs later clarified for a reporter that he was not referring to Voight’s performance in Deliverance.
-jpt
November 5, 2009 in congress, Current Affairs, health care, Obama, Barack, Today's Qs for Obama's WH, White House, White House Press Briefing | Permalink | Share | User Comments (138)
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.
I read Gibbs's remarks and immediately conjured up the image of Rush Limbaugh squealing like a pig.
Posted by: TheOldSchool***************************
and if it sounds like one, it must be one....
Posted by: Spacerook1 | Nov 22, 2009 12:36:59 PM
1. Go ahead, Mr. Gibbs, ridicule half the nation by ridiculing one of the speakers that represented them yesterday. That last-century-Alinsky tactic is getting really old, kind of like continuing to blame our nation's first 21st Century president for all the ills of the 21st Century.
2. Gibbs dismissal of one Republican bill is the only public explanation I know of on record discussing any alternatives. (Wyden's? Why not? Mackey's ideas? Why not? What would Mayo Clinic suggest? Why not?) My point is this: A methodical, public deliberation by Congress is a vital primary step for substantive change. The Worst.Congress.Ever arrogantly slid right past a transparent review of our health care system and the best ways to improve it, and instead patched together this Frankenstein in their backrooms.
The nation deserves a full, documented review of all the issues and alternatives and for Congress to be on record on why they won't work.
That's why I stood at my Congressman's office yesterday with another 100 folks -- in solidarity with others across the country and those on the Capitol steps -- to say "Kill the Bill". Start ALL over and do it right.
Posted by: Carol | Nov 6, 2009 8:43:55 PM
Doesnt Gibbs ever get dizzy from all of the spinning? He probably was born dizzy, so that is normal for him.
Posted by: NTexas | Nov 6, 2009 4:28:12 PM
Whine, complain. Loved the prior 8 years. Found no reason to demonstrate then as we moved into depression territory. Yes I have been to the brainwash right wing stations. I hope I covered it mostly.
Posted by: J. Richter | Nov 6, 2009 4:00:57 PM
Gibbs needs to understand that many of us do not find him amusing or trustworthy. He had best watch his backside.
Posted by: Leadrunner | Nov 6, 2009 4:00:39 PM
What spin! “anybody that watches (the rally) is struck by the fact that there's a rally going on without a solution on their side.” Is it OK to ridicule the voices of warning when it's obvious that the government is on a course to disaster? This is ridiculing just because there is no rational way to do what the administration's is hell-bent on doing. An analogy would be this: The government is trucking down the road and ignores posted signs that the bridge ahead is not structurally sound enough to support the load being hauled. The trucker ignores the signs because there are no alternate routes posted and is hell-bent on delivering the load in one trip. So he blows past the signs. The bridge in this analogy is the economy. The economy is supported by the privately employed work force that is dwindling. The load is the growing government workforce, entitlements, health care for the uninsured,... basically everything that the government relies upon the private sector to pay for through taxes. Since the bridge is loosing it's private sector strength it is doomed to fail under the approaching load. So just because the alternate plans are not so grandiose by themselves does not mean there are no alternatives. The load on the truck needs to broken down into smaller loads to succeed in the delivery. These protester understand the need for reform and the ultimate objective of quality health care for all. We can never achieve that by being irrational and putting on blinders.
Posted by: TX_MBell | Nov 6, 2009 2:29:28 PM
Not to worry - Gibbs won't even warrant a footnote in history. I have to agree that his fourth-grade smarmy comments are grating - evidence of weak parentage.
Posted by: ElDiaOctavo | Nov 6, 2009 2:14:00 PM
I can't wait until 2010/2012... Deliverance
Posted by: CB | Nov 6, 2009 2:12:01 PM
Clown Giggs never has a coherent answer...Such an idiot!
Posted by: Linda C in Cal | Nov 6, 2009 1:43:21 PM
OBWAN222 - so let me get this strait, if the Bush administration did it, it is OK for the Obama administration, right? 2 wrongs make a right? Unbelievable. But that is the logic you liberals use all the time.
Thought you voted for change. LOL
Posted by: saintknowitall | Nov 6, 2009 1:40:28 PM
Obwan222 - You have no moral authority anymore. Give it up.
Posted by: saintknowitall | Nov 6, 2009 1:38:30 PM
I read Gibbs's remarks and immediately conjured up the image of Rush Limbaugh squealing like a pig.
Posted by: TheOldSchool | Nov 6, 2009 1:16:10 PM
"Deliverance" was funny.
Posted by: Brian | Nov 6, 2009 1:05:38 PM
If any of the health care reform naysayers find themselves without health insurance coverage one day, they can call Jon Voight or Jon Ratzengerger to help pay their medical bills and keep them from going into bankruptcy because of medical bills.
Posted by: Ron | Nov 6, 2009 12:40:38 PM
Gibbs is a disgrace to this country, and Obama for selecting him as press sec't
Posted by: Barberqueen | Nov 6, 2009 12:34:37 PM
I see that Obama, Pelosi & Reid continue to miss the point of the 2008 election. They misread this election at their peril. The emperor's glow is not transferable . What the MSM has not discussed are the many local elections for town and county offices that took place on Tuesday. Many democratic incumbents have been turned out of office. The Democratic Weschester county executive was defeated by a large margin. The Nassau county legislature went Republican after eight years of Democratic majority. A Popular Nassau county executive is in a virtual tie for reelection necessitating the impounding of the voting machines and a recount. These local election results were repeated in statewide and local races in Pennsylvania and throughout the United States. If you were an incumbent Democrat this year, your reelection was much more difficult. The electorate is frustrated and angry; they are tired of being lied to and lied about. Ignore the electorate at your peril. They will have the last word in 2010. election.
Posted by: Al | Nov 6, 2009 12:12:17 PM
"Since when does the press secretary give talking points about the bills being presented in Congress?"
OH, like since, forever.
If you don't believe me maybe you'll believe Bush's Press Secretary:
Q: Define your job for me. I know Scott in the book says that his job -- he believed his job was to advance the agenda of the President of the United States.
MS. PERINO: Sure it is.
Posted by: OB-Wan222 | Nov 6, 2009 12:10:35 PM
Small clarification with large distinction; we live in a Representative Republic, or maybe even a Democratic Republic. Not a Democracy. We are represented by people who are hemmed in by law (the Constitution).
Posted by: Rich | Nov 6, 2009 11:59:54 AM
Since when does the press secretary give talking points about the bills being presented in Congress?
If the press secretary is now part of the propaganda machine, can we believe anything coming from the Whitehouse?
Posted by: NC77 | Nov 6, 2009 11:59:43 AM
"After the use of that term..."
Oh get YOUR mind out of the gutter. It's a simple word like bang or backdoor or melons or any other word that can sound dirty to people with dirty minds.
Posted by: OB-Wan222 | Nov 6, 2009 11:45:18 AM
Post a comment


