« Previous | Main | Next »

Edwards On O’Reilly: 'He Has No Idea What He’s Talking About'

Share

January 16, 2008 10:42 PM

ABC News' Raelyn Johnson reports: In a campaign stop in Las Vegas, Nev., Democratic hopeful John Edwards defended himself against Bill O’Reilly’s slamming a regular part of his stump speech that thousands of homeless vets are sleeping under bridges.

“In a country with as much wealth as America has, for us to have as many as 200,000 veterans who go to bed under bridges, go to sleep under bridges, or on grates, and who are homeless... This is immoral, and it’s wrong. And we, America, we have a responsibility to do something about it,” Edwards repeated tonight, speaking at US Veterans, a non profit organization that reintegrates homeless vets back into society.

Last night, on Fox's "The O’Reilly Factor," guest Ed Schultz, a syndicated radio talk show host, suggested that Edwards needs to expand on his two Americas theme.  O’Reilly jumped in:

O'REILLY: Well, we're still looking for all the veterans sleeping under the bridges, Ed. So, if you find anybody, let us know. Because that's all the guy said for the last...
SCHULTZ: Well, they're out there, Bill, don't kid yourself.
O'REILLY: They may be out there, but there are not many of them out there, OK. So, if you know where there is a veteran sleeping under a bridge, you call me immediately, and we will make sure that man does not do it.

Tonight, speaking in front of a roomful of homeless vets, Edwards responded, “I heard that, last night, Bill O'Reilly, who's a talk show host, who's heard that I have said this about hundreds of thousands of veterans who don't have a place to live, and were homeless. And he challenged me about whether that's true or not, whether, in fact, we have that many veterans who don't have a place to live, and some of them are sleeping under bridges. Well, he ought to start by coming to Las Vegas, if he wants to know what's going on.

“America has the responsibility to do something about this. We do. And the fact that this talk show host, Bill O’Reilly, is willing to speak out that blatantly, when he has no idea what he’s talking about, is an example of how America doesn’t understand the problem, doesn’t understand how serious this issue is.”

January 16, 2008 | Permalink | User Comments (86)

User Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

It is a shame that there are so many homeless much less veterans. Our country is going downhill fast. We need a government that will put our country back on the right track. That definitely means helping our homeless.

Posted by: Vicki | Jan 16, 2008 11:17:20 PM

Edwards, Clinton and Obama are interchangeable parts. They all spout the same issues. From Lebananon, it seems that the Republican candidates are more diverse when it comes to stances on issues. Us Arab women fear that the Democrats will abandon us to the savage men who have destroyed so many livs.

Posted by: Asma Bint Marwan | Jan 16, 2008 11:19:18 PM

Bill O'Reilly is a typical of Republicans who live in a make believe world where military power brings democracy and walls keep out immigrants. His ilk came into power squandered our budget surplus in the name of fiscal responsibility and worked every day to make the rich richer. It is time we see the persons in power for what they are and it is good that we are begining with their mouthpieces and puppets like Bill-O.

Posted by: Merle Savage | Jan 16, 2008 11:23:17 PM

Sorry John, nice try, but O'Reilly makes your head spin like in the movie The Exocist. Do your homework!

Posted by: Margaret | Jan 16, 2008 11:28:49 PM

Bill O'Reilly doesn't know what is he talking about. He is a radical spin master and a lier.

Posted by: Paul | Jan 16, 2008 11:31:27 PM

O'Reilly is an example of the WORST the USA has to offer. He is a fat-head with an ego... and worse yet, he is actually PAID for it by the SHAMELESS Fox news network.

Posted by: RW | Jan 16, 2008 11:32:28 PM

Asma the republicans have made things worse. If you want to stick with that side of things, go ahead.

If you have a stock broker who's continually gambling with your money and is continuously failing at his job, I guess you'd keep trusting the same guy til you have nothing left.

Good luck with that.

Posted by: Josh | Jan 16, 2008 11:32:52 PM

oh sluggo, when the republicans have you living under a bridge, remember that you helped to convince people to vote you under that bridge. Here's an extra cardboard box |____| for you.

Posted by: Frustrated With The Fairy Tale | Jan 16, 2008 11:50:55 PM

it is time some people have an idea of what is going on in this country. people like bill oriley dont have a clue of what is going on here. remember when the war started they were saying lets get them bush our oil price is too high what are they saying now we can barley buy a drop now

Posted by: plaintruth | Jan 16, 2008 11:53:26 PM

O'Reilly was Right to call Edwards on the comment! Where's the Proof,
John Edwards? Please provide the
American people with proof that there are 200,000 American veterans sleeping
under bridges!
The person that doesn't know what he's talking about is John Edwards!

Posted by: reaganfan | Jan 16, 2008 11:54:47 PM

I work at a VA hospital and I know of at least 3 vets who were discharged to shelters because they were homeless. One was attacked and returned to the hospital with a broken jaw. It is a problem but don't expect Bill O'Reilly to care much less do anything. With all the money he makes he could provide hundreds of vets with decnt housing.

Posted by: April Campbell | Jan 16, 2008 11:55:11 PM

jbond posted a link here that I don't see anymore. It was nv??.org whatever, it showed state by state, with the total number being almost 196K. So for people worshiping B Film stars who committed perjury themselves 47 times under oath, or treason for not stepping down once they learned they had a disease that would impair them from being president, or for folks idolizing a president who allowed an attack on his own country so he could make a buck and shred the constitution, there are ways to google and find some answers.

Posted by: Frustrated With The Fairy Tale | Jan 17, 2008 12:21:50 AM

If they are not sleeping under some bridge someplace, they are stuck in some homeless shelter. Of course the shelters don't want them hanging around during the day, so they go to the park. Some never leave the park and that's where they sleep at night.

O'Reilly is a joke. Anyone who doesn't know this isn't much better. Anyone who doesn't know this should just pick up the phone book and look for shelters in his/her area call them an make plans to go and visit. While there, ask them to give you info. regarding other places, so you can visit those and see how over crowded they are as well.

You may even be able to tag along on a wellness ride with some community advocates or case workers. That's if one is prepared to accept the truth.

If that's to risky for you, just turn on the tv or pick up the newspaper and see/read for yourself how veterans are treated in this country; more specifically how they are treated after they have served this country.

O'Reilly should be ashamed of himself, for even trying to call Edwards out on this.

Posted by: macy w | Jan 17, 2008 12:22:36 AM

All O'Reilly cares about is keeping the fantasy going. That anytime America starts a war, it is entitled to win. That no matter how troops are treated, they always return (if at all) endowed and joyous like that Life magazine photo from 1945 taken by Alfred Eisenstaedt.

As for a common sense check: a credible professional does not lack the skill of identifying problems needing solutions to spite those who supposedly "blame America first." Like alcoholism, the first step to improvement is admitting there is a problem. And you certainly don't start out assuming any existing problems must not be substantial.

I can't imagine anyone believing what Bill O'Reilley says. All you need is a daily work commute to encounter a homeless veteran at any random place. Edwards does not even need to dignify such an absurd falsehood with a counter-attack.

People who really care about the army usually take an interest in contributing. Yes, a lot of leftists have never served the military, but they don't expect anybody else to. You lead by example if credibility matters at all.

It really is time to stop listening to the hollow opinions of people who have always had better things to do than serve America.

Posted by: Andre | Jan 17, 2008 12:23:11 AM

Is it 200,000? I don't know. Maybe 100,000? Whatever. I know there are many. But let's say their 50,000.... Oh ok... Now O'Rilley's closer to correct. Is that still acceptable. Or is it more important to ignore it and spend our energies disagreeing on the number? That is the Republican way. O'Rilley likes to be the news rather than report it.

Posted by: roy | Jan 17, 2008 12:24:43 AM

andre - You said that leftist don't serve in the military. Well, maybe alot don't because they see the hypocracy before they serve. But a lot of conservatives who serve end up being Liberal when they get discharged after experiencing it.

Posted by: roy | Jan 17, 2008 12:28:47 AM

i know a few homeless vets and i live in a small town... in fact, most of the homeless here are vets... bill oreilly is going to be a has-been very soon

Posted by: earthisnotflat | Jan 17, 2008 12:40:52 AM

Roy, that is also a very good point. Bush has not done a lot to make signing up for the military especially attractive.

Posted by: Andre | Jan 17, 2008 12:44:39 AM

Bill O'Reilly vs. John Edwards... far right against far left. A theocrat vs. a Socialist. THAT is what's wrong with America's politics; we need some MODERATES!

Posted by: rmberryman | Jan 17, 2008 1:08:34 AM

As I understand the facts, Bill O'Reilly spent the bloodiest days of combat in Vietnam as a student in England. To my knowledge, Mr. O'Reilly, as many of his right-wing colleagues at Fox, never served in the United States military. For those of us who did serve in the military, it comes as an insult that this habitual distorter of the truth can deny that countless numbers of our comrades (veterans) are homeless and "live" on the streets of America. Whether under bridges, on the sidewalks, gutters, etc., those who served America and allow Mr. Reilly the "right" to spread his venom are at this very moment scorned and discarded by our own government as if they did not exist. America one day will be held accountable not only for the manner in which it mistreated its veterans but for its squandering of billions that could have been utilized to better the lives of its citizens. President Bush, oblivious to reality, would rather spend his time dancing with the Saudi royalty and attending horse shows.

Posted by: mongo100 | Jan 17, 2008 1:10:29 AM

Post a comment