« Previous | Main | Next »

Obama Campaign On Defensive, Points Plagiarism to Clinton

Share

February 18, 2008 12:41 PM

ABC News' Sunlen Miller and Teddy Davis Reports: Senator Barack Obama said during a press conference in Niles, Ohio that he probably should have given credit to Massachusetts Gov. Deval Patrick when he used his words at a speech on Saturday night in Wisconsin, as first reported by ABC News' Jake Tapper.

Obama pushed back against questions about whether he has ever plagiarized before. Obama said he usually gives credit when quoting people or using ideas, but he insisted that he is friends with Patrick.

"I've written two books, wrote most of my speeches, so I'm putting aside the question that you just raised whether my words are my own, I think that would be carrying it too far," Obama said. "Deval and I do trade ideas all the time, and he's occasionally used lines of mine and I at a Jefferson Jackson dinner in Wisconsin used some words of his.”

When asked if he should have credited Patrick, Obama admitted he should have: “I was on the stump. He suggested we use these lines. I thought they were good lines. I’m sure I should have. Didn’t this time.”

But the Illinois senator then turned his focus on Sen. Hillary Clinton, suggesting the New York senator uses his words without his approval. "Senator Clinton has used mine as well," Obama said, citing "fired up and ready to go," as examples.

The Clinton campaign today held a conference call with reporters to highlight charges that Obama's  speech this weekend had a striking similarity to a speech given by Gov. Deval Patrick, D-MA in 2006.

"The power of his rhetoric has been much discussed," Clinton spokesman Howard Wolfson said today, referring to Obama. "So when we learned that he has taken an important section of a speech from another elected official, it raises questions about the premise of his candidacy."

"It makes those words much less inspiring; less authentic and more political," he added.

The Clinton campaign circulated a video of the similar Patrick and Obama speeches Monday.

Patrick, who supports Obama for president, has defended the Illinois Democrat for using his refrain without attribution. But Clinton's spokesman argued that regardless of how Patrick feels, harm was done to Obama's audience, and he compared it to an author who plagiarizes the work of another.

"I think it's fine that Deval Patrick said that," added Wolfson. "What I'm concerned about is that the public has an expectation that the words are his own unless he credited them to someone else."

The Clinton camp believes that Obama' s lifting of rhetoric without attribution is especially damaging to the Illinois Democrat because his speeches have played an important role in his rise from state senator three years ago to Democratic presidential frontrunner.

"When you are running on your rhetoric and the power of your oratory," Wolfson said, "I think it undermines a central" element "of his candidacy."

Obama campaign manager David Plouffe held a conference call with reporters today that was meant to be dedicated to tomorrow’s primary in Wisconsin, but instead focused on the controversy and little else.

In Saturday’s speech at the Wisconsin Jefferson Jackson dinner Obama shot back at his critics’ charges that his campaign is about words, not action.

“Don't tell me words don't matter! ‘I have a dream’, just words?" he said. "‘We hold these truths to be self evident that all me are created equal’ - just words? ‘We have nothing to fear but fear itself?’ - just words? Just speeches?”

Plouffe tried to explain away the similarities in those remarks to the 2006 Deval Patrick speech by pointing out that the Governor and Obama are friends, and they often share thoughts and words in speeches.

Plouffe then tried to turn the argument to Obama’s opponent. He argued that Clinton is not in a position to be outraged about plagiarism. This is a “curious charge coming from Senator Clinton when she has actually repeatedly throughout the campaign used the language Senator Obama has used.”

Plouffe charged several instances when he says “Senator Obama’s language has been copied by the Clinton campaign.”

When reporters asked for specific examples, Plouffe said they would be provided. 

Obama campaign national press secretary Bill Burton soon sent reporters an email with Clinton quotes that he argued were copied from Obama.

Those phrases include: “Fired up and ready to Go”, “Bring our country together,” “Yes we can,”  “We’ve got to turn the page on George Bush and Dick Cheney,” and “Turn the Page.”

With reporting by ABC News' Jake Tapper.

February 18, 2008 in Bush, George W., Kucinich, Dennis, Tancredo, Tom | Permalink | User Comments (874)

User Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Now it starts for Obama, finally. Next he will charge Clinton with plagiarism for saying "Vote for me." Said the Tin Man to the Scarecrow, "I think it's going to get worse before it gets better."

Posted by: OldTT | Feb 18, 2008 12:58:45 PM

It's common to use phrases that you hear that are catchy. In fact I think we all can think of words or phrases that if you hear one more time you think you will puke. ie. Awesome,dude,like totally, snap, true that etc.

Posted by: deni | Feb 18, 2008 12:59:19 PM

Right from the beginning, Obama has been a man for "CHANGE". But now all candidates are for change, even including McCain. Do I need to say more?????

Posted by: Peace | Feb 18, 2008 1:06:56 PM

The problem with Obama's words, aside from the fact that htye arent his, it is that they just are words..His words dont call into action in stopping foreclosures, getting people healthcare, stopping oil dependency. So as awesome some of the words are - the words that he has borrowed had a bigger impact from other leaders becuase they were more than just vote for me..They actually provided solutions..

Posted by: linchristi | Feb 18, 2008 1:08:57 PM

Obama is starting to sound like a little boy in kindergarten who is crying because Hillary took his milk. There is no copyright on "catch" phrases. He plagiarized an entire speech, but he turns on Hillary for using his catch phrases. How juvenile. This man is not Presidential material.

Posted by: Jay | Feb 18, 2008 1:09:11 PM

Obama is using same technique as rappers. They get sampling of melody or tunes that stick and make it their own. Same old stuff only different artist. From the get go, I do not really see anything original about Obama. You could find lots of his phrases from self-help books or motivational speakers. People should just go to therapy if they want this kind of talk and elect someone more qualified.

Posted by: Felicia | Feb 18, 2008 1:09:24 PM

Is this man a baby geez, he was caught big time using Patrick's words rather than he leaves it alone and sit down and write something to show that he can do so he come off like a spoil kid pointing fingers 'look mommy she does it to", as the days go by I really wonder what exactly it is that some of you feel this man can bring to the office of President. Such petty and childish behavior coming from a grown man , Obama suck it up and move on, look at all the swipes Hillary has taken, I cant believe that you are letting a woman outshine you in the maturity departmenet, maybe Obama will go running home and cry to Michelle.

Posted by: SJ | Feb 18, 2008 1:12:56 PM

Obama has stolen an entire speech ,used words to his convenience and hads the audacity to attack Hillary on catch phrases.What a low act.He should apologize or quit the race...

Posted by: VIK | Feb 18, 2008 1:15:50 PM

It is true that Clinton has copied Obama's words many times in her campaign.such as yes, we will; fired up and ready to go; turn the age etc. These are OBAMA slogans. It is very shameful for the Clinton's supporters to bring these things out.

Posted by: I.A.T Smith | Feb 18, 2008 1:16:54 PM

I left Obama at REZCO. No more need for garbage on this empty suite.

Posted by: Charles | Feb 18, 2008 1:19:52 PM

OMG, can we find something better to discuss..something that means something to someone other than a bunch of talking heads

Posted by: Jerry | Feb 18, 2008 1:21:03 PM

Obama is not only words but they are other people's words. He cries change but has accepted more money from lobbyists than any presidential candidate in history. Wake up people you are falling for a dog and pony show!

Posted by: Firefighter | Feb 18, 2008 1:21:26 PM

Either you guys are the least educated people in the world or you have never heard FDR say that; or MLK; or JFK- Hillary stole her line about the statue of liberty from a poem at the same dinner. Educate yourself people, do not let others influence your perceptions at a whim.

Posted by: Chelsea | Feb 18, 2008 1:22:24 PM

Are some of you sleeping the issues is not coping a line from someone the man took the entire speech of Patrick and recited it word for word all he did was change around the order on the presentation. If Obama wants to come off as this great leader in the likes of MLK and that is what he is pretending to be, but MLK wrote his own stuff he did not need to copy or get pointers from others to make a speech. Now that you all are caught in this hoodwinking exercise some of you are making excuses to cover up his faults, he pretended to be something he is not, he used another man's words then claimed he makes great speeches, if he was this talented why did he need to do it that is the first question, and they other is how far is he willing to go to pretend that he is one way and not the other just to get the post of President.

Posted by: SJ | Feb 18, 2008 1:22:54 PM

The story about Obama are his speeches which inspire people. Now, we find out that those same words are the words of another politican who used them in another campain. Those words did not wholly come to his mind because he felt them but because he heard another politician use them (and win).

Posted by: Jim | Feb 18, 2008 1:24:08 PM

Was he not the one to say that Hillary will do and say anything to win looks as if he better rethink that position because that claim sure looks like its falling at his doorstep now

Posted by: SJ | Feb 18, 2008 1:26:10 PM

All you Obama university folks try and use someone else's entire speech or ideas in your written papers and then see what mark you get when the profs find out you stole someone else's ideas and words. Chances are you'd be kicked out of school.

Posted by: Will | Feb 18, 2008 1:27:18 PM

Barack Obama tried to compare himself to Ronald Reagan, Franklin D. Roosevelt, and Martin Luther King.

Barack Obama with his inexperience, is starting to remind us a Dan Quayle who tried to compare himself to John F. Kennedy in the 1988 debate. Senator Lloyd Bentsen responded to Dan Quayle with the famous quote:

"Senator, I served with Jack Kennedy, I knew Jack Kennedy. Jack Kennedy was a friend of mine. Senator, you're no Jack Kennedy."

Posted by: Angel | Feb 18, 2008 1:29:12 PM

Has anyone here bothered to listen to what he said. If he was stealing lines it was from King, Roosevelt, and Kennedy.

Both Patrick and Obama were responding to attacks on their ability to actually speak well...from desperate female candidates that were looking for an issues, any issue, to take them down a notch.

If you listened about 30 seconds of the speech were the same. Only Drudge seems to think this is a big deal.

Posted by: Keith | Feb 18, 2008 1:30:46 PM

Facts: Mr. Obama used an entire speech without mentioning to the public it was indeed someone else's speech. That is pure and simple plagiarism. He should apologize and drop out of the race now. "I give good speeches".. Yes, but they are someone else's words.
Doesn't matter if he and Deval are friends or not and even if he gave Obama permission to use his speech, he should have been given the proper credit.

Posted by: Jay | Feb 18, 2008 1:31:32 PM

Post a comment