« Previous | Main | Next »

Clinton Says Obama's 'Bitter' Remark Could Cost Party General Election

Share

April 13, 2008 3:12 PM

ABC News' Eloise Harper Reports: Sen. Hillary Clinton, D-N.Y., took the opportunity to capitalize on her rivals comments that people in small towns are "bitter" for the third day in a row.

Speaking to reporters outside some homes in Scranton, Pennsylvannia where she has family roots and today was greeted by many supporters holding signs and offering encouragement. She made the argument that Sen. Barack Obama's comments could cost the party the election and that the party has been seen as out of touch by male candidates in the past. Clinton also criticized Obama for not "owning up to his remarks."

Clinton was asked if this moment was her opening in the race – the one that she has been looking for. Clinton responded saying,"I think what’s important about this is that Senator Obama has not owned up to what he said, and taken accountability for it you. You know, first said he was right and attacked me for raising his remarks and referencing them. Then he admitted he may have said what he said in artfully. And now he he’s deeply apologized if he offended anyone. But what people are looking for is an explanation."

Clinton also threatened that these comments could really hurt the Democratic Party – making a veiled comparison to what happened to John Kerry and Al Gore.

"The Democratic party has been unfortunately viewed by many people over the last decades as being elitist and out of touch we have waged elections over that you don’t have to think too far to remember that good men running for president were viewed as being elitist and out of touch with the values and the lives of millions of Americans. So I think this is a very significant concern that people have expressed. You know the front page of the paper today in Scranton is very pointed and the mayor and mayors across Pennsylvanian and people across our country have all reacted," she said. 

Clinton repeated the argument she has been making these past days saying, "I do not believe, as Senator Obama apparently does, that Americans in small towns and small cities and rural areas cling to religion and gun ownership out of frustration they embrace them as a matter of faith and a way of life. We are at a point in America where need to be bringing people together."

Clinton also implied that Obama's comments reflect that he does not respect all Americans saying "I believe if you want to be president of all Americans you need to respect all Americans. You need to respect their values and their way of life and that’s exactly what I will do as president."

Clinton has been speaking about her hunting experience recently, but when asked when the last time she fired a gun or went to church – she objected saying "You know what that is not that is not a relevant question for this debate we can answer that another time this is about what people feel is being said about them and you know I went to church on Easter that is not what this is about. This is about how people look at the democratic party and the democratic party leadership."

Clinton also rejected any notion that she was out of touch – due to her not living in a middle class lifestyle and spending so much time living a more privileged life. Clinton said "Well Bill and I have worked very hard our entire lives and I am very grateful for the successes we’ve have had – and I think a lot of the way we live, even today you know my mother lives with us I've met a lot of mothers and aunts who living with people in these houses as we walk down the street. We are obviously very appreciative of the opportunities we have been given we don’t take anything for granted."

April 13, 2008 | Permalink | User Comments (256)

User Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

It's clear why the Hillary camp says that Obama is unelectable - because that's the only way for the superdelegates to justify ignoring the popular vote. The Clintons are just showing their elitist colors - trust them, they know that McCain is right for America. Because there's no way in hell that Hillary will win.

Posted by: Terris Linenbach | Apr 13, 2008 3:50:12 PM

Hillary is full of bologna and I hope Obama goes after her during the debate on Wednesday night, and show how she is exploiting this miss wording to something much much bigger then what it is.

Posted by: Stephen | Apr 13, 2008 3:51:28 PM

I think far too much is being made of his comments. Hillary is just upping her negativity ratings again. Keep it up, Hillary, we don't want you for president.

Obama '08

Posted by: barbara | Apr 13, 2008 3:51:58 PM

Maritza,
The people that are saying that are called Obama supporters.
***
Lawrence,
The people that are saying that Hillary still has a shot at becoming the nominee are called ignorant.

Posted by: lmao... | Apr 13, 2008 3:52:07 PM

Come on. Are you serious? This is the best Hillary can do to undermine Obama's campaign? Guess what, American's ARE bitter - they are bitter about the economic mess, the war in Iraq, the lack of meaningful opportunities, the housing crisis, the inability of the government to resolve the Katrina disaster, the climate. You name it, we're bitter about it. Does that makes us unAmerican? Does it mean we are sitting in some corner sulking and acting like petulent children? Of course not. It means we're trying our level best to help ourselves since the past eight years of so called leadership has shown that it is inadequate and unconcerned about helping anyone but themselves. And it means we'll be voting for Obama who frankly should not be apologizing to anyone for his remarks because his remarks are correct. We're being force fed the impression that he's somehow committed some huge error of judgement. He didn't. He spoke the truth.

Posted by: Artchers | Apr 13, 2008 3:52:24 PM

Being from a small town in Illinois, I certainly don't appreciate the picture he painted of me clinging to a gun and only going to church because I am frustrated. He's the one frustrated and bitter, because this nomination isn't the cake walk he thought it would be. His true self is just starting to peek through, and he is having trouble keeping it submerged lately. The only thing I am bitter about is having voted for him for Senator 2 years ago. The only response his supporters have is the usual "He's just speaking the truth." Well, if he thinks people from rural America only go to church because they are bitter and frustrated, I don't think he even knows the truth.

Posted by: dwc | Apr 13, 2008 3:53:15 PM

Her staying in will cost the General Election.

Posted by: A Non Name | Apr 13, 2008 3:54:43 PM

Hillary has lost all morals, and is out of contact with the frustration of the people, yes we are bitter, and sick of her desperate divisive tactics, it is sickening, like Bush, She doesn't care who gets hurt, as a democrat I am appalled, Gas Prices, energy cost,She is a millionaire we are suffering and bitter....

Posted by: Jeff Jackson | Apr 13, 2008 3:54:51 PM

Realtiy now strikes the political pundits. Contrast the politico article on the reaction of seasoned operatives to Obama's remarks with comments of the chattering class--seasoned operatives understand Obama likely loses any general election whereas Hillary likely wins. Even now, the pundits try to vidnciate previous judments favoring Obama by suggesting its still his to lose. Bill was right. This is a fairy tale, and voters are about to announce the news that Santa Claus does not exist. Obama is doomed.

Posted by: edfairness | Apr 13, 2008 3:54:55 PM

A fascinating analysis from Senator Clinton, but at what point exactly did Hillary start caring about the fate of the Democratic Party in November?

Senator Clinton sure hasn't ran her campaign like she cares about the party's chances for victory in 2008. Why start now?

Posted by: Richardson | Apr 13, 2008 3:55:43 PM

Does this woman have no conscience? As an elder female and feminist I am so sorry that this is what we are getting for a first-woman-candidate for president. Is this what it takes for a woman to hold so much power? Is this a commentary on woman in patriarchy, using the competitive dominating qualtiies of patriarchy to gain position? Yee goddess, it's dismaying.

Tonya Harding redux.

Posted by: Gaias Child | Apr 13, 2008 3:56:32 PM

"You know" (to use Hillary Clinton's favorite arrogant phrase), when I worked for 15 years as a hotel housekeeper at a Marriott in Buffalo, New York, I heard constantly from the management how upbeat we were, and how focused on getting on with our lives. Clinton said something similar in a speech she made while she was on the Board of Directors of Walmart. Walmart employees also hear this constantly. This is Corporate America's mind program for the working class.

Nothing could more specifically reflect the elite point of view. Not that I'm not upbeat, nor that I'm bitter all of the time, nor most people I know, but we're often very concerned, worried, and at times angry. With his background working in Chicago's ghettos, Barack Obama certainly is far more in touch with how working class people feel than is Hillary Clinton, who spent her pre-political life as a successful corporate attorney, a Walmart Board member, and a successful politician's wife. I'm completely fed up it with her extremely arrogant, girl scout leader style of talking to people.

I think that it was a mistake to make the country aware that the people of rural Pennsylvania are backward, and he threw in his own bias against guns. His list of ways people with serious economic problems they can't fix cope was not a list of ignorant ways to act; it included religion. Barack Obama is himself intensely religious. He did think, probably not entirely mistakenly, that he was describing people who care about their lives.

On the other hand, while Senator Obama's customary forethought is well recognized, Clinton rarely thinks before she speaks, and gets into trouble constantly, never by trying to do good. To quote her double on last night's Saturday Night Live, "Is sniper fire sometimes very quiet, so that people have trouble hearing it?" I think the superdelegates will take that into account.

Neither is this what the "firestorm" is about. This is just what occurred to Hillary Clinton to bounce at us today in the hope of convincing someone to vote for her. I'm sure she hopes that people in Pennsylvania are ignorant enough to see the matter as she wants them to. As for Senator McCain, when I grew up, how upbeat people are was the favorite topic of rural political speeches, and the man smells a bloodfest. I remind the media that this is real life and not a reality show.

Posted by: Dora Smith | Apr 13, 2008 3:56:32 PM

McCain-Clinton vs. Obama-Richardson! I can see it now.

Posted by: Brian Kolstad | Apr 13, 2008 3:56:59 PM

I had read about what he said, but I just actually HEARD him saying it. "Dem rednecks down there, dey's only gonna vote on dems guns and gay marriages and stuff dat's close to home fo' dems" Excellent candor and so eloquently put. Good way to ostracize 40% - 50% of all Americans. I'm from a very up-scale small town--one that is pre-dominantly pro-Obama--but even I and many of my friends took offense. He lost some votes with that comment...

Posted by: Chris Murphy | Apr 13, 2008 3:57:47 PM

This seals the deal for me. I will never vote for Obama. Ever. His wife hates America, he looks down on working-class white people, inlcuding his own grandmother, and his pastor hates Jews. Where on earth did the Democratic leadership get the idea this guy was mainstream and electable? His cult of personality is out of control.

Posted by: 10 | Apr 13, 2008 3:57:49 PM

This article is an example of what lengths both Obama and Hillary will go to to get elected. On one hand you have a man who often shows his lack of experience though smooth he may be; on the other hand you have a woman who will excuse herself from lying and claim it to be a mistake. How could anyone in their right mind vote for either of these characters?

Remember, if you are voting for anyone this election, the United States will get exactly what it has ask for! If you want change don't depend on the three that are running right now!

Posted by: Marv | Apr 13, 2008 3:57:54 PM

This is a sign of how desperate Clinton has become. But it is also the reason saying "I feel your pain" is more effective campaigning than attempting to describe it. There is an undeniable truth in what Obama said, at to any objective observer. But in the hands of Clinton it has somehow become a faux pas. The fact that we are even talking about it, rather than how to restore the faith in the political process and American government for the working class is indicative of the low state to which the campaign process has declined in this country. We should all be ashamed.

Posted by: Harry | Apr 13, 2008 4:02:38 PM

When you see your enemies eating each other, don't speak and pass the salt.

Posted by: tommyd | Apr 13, 2008 4:03:18 PM

The desperate nature of her relentless attack only reveals her recognition that she is finished as a canididate. In her heart she knows what Obama said is truth personified. Pathetic Hillary displays in the endgame her most salient fearure - shear hypocrisy.

Posted by: jefflz | Apr 13, 2008 4:03:33 PM

What did Hillary lie about today? About her middle class $100 million dollar background?? About being pinned down by sniper fire in PA? I heard Bill Clinton corrected her and said it was in Indiana. Sheesh... How can anyone fall for the Hillary snake oil salesman. She will say and do anything to get elected. She is a bigger liar and worse than even Bush. She is part of the Washington elite the status quo. She is a lying hypocritical opportunist. Shame on you Hillary.

Posted by: Larry Vandemeer | Apr 13, 2008 4:03:33 PM

Post a comment