« Previous | Main | Next »

McCain Touts Surge Success Before Obama's Overseas Trip

Share

July 17, 2008 7:22 PM

ABC News' Jennifer Duck reports: Touting the surge strategy, Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., declared today "we have succeeded in Iraq" and spoke of his confidence in winning the war in advance of Sen. Barack Obama's trip to the region.

"I'm happy to tell you we've succeeded in Iraq and we—unless we reverse the strategy that’s succeeding we will win this war. But it's fragile and it must be dictated—the strategy must be dictated by the situation on the ground. Not some artificially, politically schedule for withdraw as sen Obama wants to do," McCain told a crowd in Kansas City, MO.

Reporters questioned McCain on his rhetoric of success at a stop in Grand Haven, MI since in the past McCain has phrased the status in Iraq as "succeeding," as opposed to "succeeded."

McCain told reporters, "Military, economic, political, and all the benchmarks we said that the Iraqi government had to meet" have allowed for the word "succeeded" to be used.

However McCain admitted, "They haven’t met them all. Do they have a lot more to go-- distance to go? Yes and it’s very fragile. And can be reversed. But they’ve succeeded and if we will continue this, we will win this war."

He continued saying Obama's initial plan of withdraw would've "lost" the war. "I know how to win wars. And Sen Obama was wrong when he said that the surge would not succeed. And now he says he’s going to evaluate the situation. If we had done what Sen Obama wanted to do, there would be no situation to evaluate because we would’ve lost."

When asked when the war will be won, McCain responded, "I can say the war will be won when we will have the majority of Americans have returned and we have Gen Petraeus and his successor Gen Odierno tell us that the situation is secure. It’s still---we’ve succeed but it’s still fragile."

McCain’s communications director Jill Hazelbaker appeared on cable news channels calling Obama’s trip specifically to Iraq and Afghanistan "a campaign rally overseas" and "one giant photo opportunity."

"Well, Senator Obama is visiting Iraq and Afghanistan. I found it interesting that he released his plan for the way forward in Iraq and Afghanistan prior to visiting the region or talking with any of the commanders on the ground. Let's drop the pretense that this is a fact-finding trip and call it what it is: the first of its kind campaign rally overseas," Hazelbaker said on Fox News.

At first the presumptive Republican nominee seemed surprised with his staff's message telling reporters on his campaign bus he would talk to Hazelbaker about her message. "I can only give you my opinion, and I will talk to her. But the fact is, I’m glad that he’s going to Iraq and I think it’s – I’m glad that he’s going to Afghanistan. It’s long, long overdue, if you want to lead this nation and secure our national security."

However, after a flight from Missouri to Michigan, McCain was careful when telling reporters a few legs of Obama's trip to Europe and the Middle East appear to define it as a political trip. "If he has political rallies in other places, obviously it’s a political trip. But I was speaking specifically.

July 17, 2008 in Hunter, Duncan | Permalink | User Comments (28)

User Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

"I'm happy to tell you we've succeeded in Iraq and we—unless we reverse the strategy that’s succeeding we will win this war"

Double-Talk Express Way...

If we've succeeded and the Iraqis want us out then we should just LEAVE. Adopt Obama's plan and gradually withdraw.

Posted by: Vanessa | Jul 17, 2008 7:28:45 PM

McCain is just continuing Bush's bad politics. McCain is already saying we're winning - and the fact is - there's still a civil war going on in Iraq. People are continuing to die - and despite our soldiers' valiant efforts - there are still many problems. That's why we need a new approach to Iraq. That's why so many people are supporting Senator Obama. People don't want McCain to keep us there for another 10-15 years - the thing is - we want our soldiers to come home before another 4,100 soldiers die. It's time for change. We need new leadership in the White House, and Senator Obama is the best candidate for the job.

Posted by: Allen | Jul 17, 2008 7:56:32 PM

It's sad that these Obama bloggers apparently believe the the Surge has not worked. Even Obama KNOWS that the Surge is a HUGE SUCCESS. Probably reason why Obama has not wanted to visit Iraq - He would have to admit the obvious. Violence is way down, people are returning to homes and businesses. Airline starting back up. Iraqi Defense is taking over more and more responsibility. OBAMA PREDICTED THAT THE SURGE WOULD FAIL AND THAT MORE TERRORISTS WOULD SPRING UP AND CREATE MORE CHAOS. THIS HAS NOT HAPPENED - JUST THE OPPOSITE. JUST SHOWS OBAMA'S TOTAL INEXPERIENCE IN FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND NATIONAL DEFENSE.

Posted by: Manitu | Jul 17, 2008 8:14:51 PM

Senator Obama spoke out against the Iraq before it began and so did my cat. He did not vote against the beginning of the war in the Senate and neither did my cat. Senator Obama needs to "move on".

Posted by: Mai | Jul 17, 2008 8:21:22 PM

It is interesting that my posts are respectful with no use of bad words - but my posts get deleated because they show Obama for what he is. Makes sense now with three network anchors on the Obama's campaign plane to the middle -east NO DOUBT ABOUT MAJOR NEWS NETWORKS IN THE TANK FOR OBAMA NOW!! WAS FOX INVITED - DUH!!

Posted by: Manitu | Jul 17, 2008 8:22:46 PM

McCain is caught in a word trap. He says the Iraq war is a “success,” but then insists that we must stay and continue his surge strategy to “win the war.” This is twisted logic.

http://www.political-buzz.com/

Posted by: matt | Jul 17, 2008 8:25:46 PM


Manitu.

What was that about network news anchors on Obama's team to middle-east? I saw your post - but then disappeared.

Posted by: Temagami | Jul 17, 2008 8:28:21 PM

It doesn't matter what McCain says, due to financal reasons alone, we will be forced to leave Iraq. We can not afford to stay in Iraq ten years, let alone 100. And we don't have the personnel available to invade Iran. Simply put we will be forced, and very soon; To do what we did in Vietnam: Namely declare victory and leave. And even McCain has hinted at this on numberous occasions. We will NOT be in Iraq for 100 years. But if we choose to invade Iran we will have no choice but use nuclear weapons to make up for our manpower disadvantage. If anyone feels that it's reasonable to invade and detonate tactical nukes inside Iran, and feels that they won't declare war on us in Iraq and back here in the US, they may be dim enough to be a neocon, but they sure as hell aren't smart enough to lead. Wether they are a man or a woman, young or old, black or white. Negotiate with Iran, listen to what the Iraqis want, and act accordingly, otherwise no one is going to be truly safe. And that includes Israel, wether they want to believe it or not.

Posted by: jeez! | Jul 17, 2008 9:01:16 PM

mccain cannot remember what country he is talking about----john SUDAN SUDAN--YOU HAVE THE WRONG COUNTRY it is that simple.mccain is the guy you went to school with --that needed to go to summer school-------N-T-S

Posted by: rodney | Jul 17, 2008 9:29:41 PM

Question; When will this war be won? Do you mean we can lose this war? I guess it is when Obama pulls out.

Posted by: Waggdogg | Jul 17, 2008 9:54:36 PM

Obama is supposed to be going to Europe and the Middle East as a fact finding mission, to save the lives of American soldiers and to insure the security of Americans ... but, as usual, Obama is turning his responsibilities into a promotional photo op. Our country's problems are serious, and it's getting rather disgusting watching Obama the Opportunist, use America to further his personal ambition and aggrandizement. Also, the three network anchors, and the rest of the media, who are tripping over each other to accompany Obama overseas should be ashamed of themselves.

Posted by: Gina | Jul 17, 2008 10:17:37 PM

Obama blew his prediction of the Surge and its value. What MORE is there to discuss!! End of story. Nada!!

McCain 08

Posted by: Temagami | Jul 17, 2008 10:39:59 PM

I will vote for McCain even if he has to be carried into the oval office with an O2 cart and with paramedics and alzheimers specialists in tow. The alternative, Obama, is unthinkable. Unfortunately, as bad as some say the USA has it (which I really don't buy - consider the Amish) the world situation, particularly the middle-east has to take top priority. OTHER issues are important, but don't mean a damn thing if we cannot, nor will not protect ourselves. Obama just does not have the ability, nor experience to perform those functions. Obama's early prediction of the Surge failing and ensuing chaos in Iraq (just the opposite has occurred) clearly shows his complete lack of knowledge of foreign affairs and national defense.

Posted by: Temagami | Jul 17, 2008 11:12:08 PM

What is the point of making this trip now? Senator Obama has already stated his position on the Iraq War. Oh, yes, I forgot, he wants it as a taxpayer paid PR trip and photo session. He is not even the legal Democratic candidate yet.

Posted by: Mary | Jul 17, 2008 11:37:56 PM

Wow, I just read the headlines, McCain has won another war? When will the troops get to come home?

Posted by: Truth Matters | Jul 18, 2008 12:13:13 AM

McCain claims he "knows how to win wars"? Can anybody please explain to me what wars he has won?

Posted by: Truth Matters | Jul 18, 2008 12:17:12 AM

In this Era, as can be said of the past, Isn't it so true that mankind's one solution in an effort to resolve problems with his fellow brother, has continued to be War. "When will we understand that War is not the answer?" I am definitely not a softy, realizing that in some cases, we have to defend ourselves, but this is a situation we have brought on ourselves, by failing over and over to live in harmony with the Law of cause and effect, which is a natural Law of the Universe and our Being, believe it or not. We should also return to living in harmony with the Law which states, Thou Shalt not Kill. One of the ways to prevent War is non-stop negotiations.

Posted by: Rev Norbert Larcher | Jul 18, 2008 12:52:06 AM

Shiela.

Where is your "Total Bull" when all along McCain has said that the Surge would work and Obama - just the opposite? The Surge was a great success. And to respond to your concern about Afghanistan - it will work well there also. The Iraq question is almost past history - the concern now is Iran and Pakistan which will require at least leaving a token force in Iraq. There ARE plans to begin withdrawing troops beginning in Sept.

Posted by: Manitu | Jul 18, 2008 6:07:22 AM

The surge worked because Al-Sadir let it. For a time, he didn't and the surge did suffer set backs.
So now all the Iraqi factions have played kiss and make up, and we're patting ourselves on the back for it.

McCain is even touting, "we" as in we won. Like he held a rifle and got blood on his boots. How moronic!

Posted by: DAVID NH | Jul 18, 2008 7:32:00 AM

Mcain than why are you not willing to start slowly withdrawing like obama says our troops in afghan need help but all of our military is in iraq i say go with obamas plan pull some out of iraq not all and help the guys in afghan!!!

Posted by: angie | Jul 18, 2008 9:35:44 AM

Post a comment