BRIAN ROSS REPORTS
TOP BLOTTER CATEGORIES
- Abramoff Lobbying Scandal
- American Al Qaeda
- Avian Flu
- Beirut Hospital Out of Gas
- CIA
- CIA Secret Prisons
- D.C. Madam Affair
- FBI
- Federal Air Marshal Service
- Homeland Security
- Hurricane Katrina
- Mark Foley Internet Scandal
- Millionaire Sex Scandal
- Nigerian E-mail Scams
- Norman Hsu, Clinton Fundraiser
- NSA: Wiretapping
- Osama bin Laden
- Payola
- Pharmacy Investigation
- Speaker of the House Dennis Hastert
- Terror
- U.K. Airline Terror Plot
- U.K. Bombing Attempts
- Wen Ho Lee
- William Jefferson
- Zarqawi
The Quiz Top U.S. Officials Fail
February 15, 2007 10:40 AM
"Can you tell a Sunni from a Shiite?" is the famous question used by reporter Jeff Stein to expose the ignorance of some U.S. counterterrorism officials about basic issues related to the Middle East.
In a book to be published next summer, Stein, who is Congressional Quarterly's national security editor, will expand from columns he wrote after quizzing dumbfounded members of Congress and other officials about their knowledge of the Middle East.
"Americans are dying because of these differences...I was not asking them to be experts; I just wanted them to know who was on which side, and they couldn't answer some of the basic questions," Stein told ABC News.
It all started with an op-ed published in "The New York Times" last October that created a buzz in the media.
A few months later, Stein asked the incoming chairman of the House Intelligence Committee Sgt. Silvestre Reyes, D-Texas, whether al Qaeda was Sunni or Shiite. "Al Qaeda, they have both," Reyes said. "Predominantly -- probably Shiite," he added. Wrong answer, of course. Al Qaeda is strictly Sunni.
Click Here for Full Blotter Coverage.
"Members of the intelligence committee, mind you, are paid $165,200 a year to know more than basic facts about our foes in the Middle East," commented Stein in his column, which was published on Congressional Quarterly's Web site in December.
"If you are a manager of a baseball team...how can you manage the team if you didn't know the difference between the pitcher and the catcher?" remarks Stein.
The book's publisher, Hyperion editor Zareen Jaffery, noticed Stein's first articles and now considers the ignorance he exposed a key contributor to the ongoing problems in Iraq. "These issues go to the very basis of why our country is still there. If you don't put any effort into learning it, how do you expect us to get out?"
Although he is now well-known for his pop quizzes, Stein expects his second round of interviews to produce the same uninformed responses. "But now they're going to prepare for the interview?" we asked him. "If my showing up at the door will make them learn, it would be a huge capstone of my career," he answered.
Differences Between Sunnis and Shiites
The split between Islam's two main sects was created right after Prophet Mohammed died in the year 632 because of disagreements over succession. One group -- later known as the Sunnis -- believed the leader of Muslims should be anybody who is worthy of that position and particularly supported the Prophet's best friend Abu Bakr. The other group -- later known as the Shiites -- argued that the leader should be a descendant of the Prophet's family and supported his cousin and son-in-law Ali. The Shiites lost, and Abu Bakr became the first caliph.
The two sects believe in the same book, the Qur'an, and revere the same prophet. Both believe in the five pillars of Islam, which include the belief in one God, daily prayer, fasting during the month of Ramadan, alms giving and the pilgrimage to Mecca. While there are some religious differences, -- most importantly Shiite's veneration of the Imams -- the main conflict between Sunnis and Shiites is political rather than theological. The majority of Muslims in the world today are Sunnis.
Now Test Your Knowledge of Sunnis and Shiites.
February 15, 2007 | Permalink | User Comments (12)
There is a report by Congressinal Research Service for Congress in Feb 2004 on this topic. It's a shame that these policy makers aren't up to speed on this basic knowledge.
Posted by: Elaine | Feb 15, 2007 12:58:31 PM
What's the difference between the
Sunni and Shia dogma towards
non-muslims?
Not much. They both subscribe
to the exact same philosophy:
When you're not near the one you hate,
hate the one you're near.
Posted by: Jon Allman | Feb 15, 2007 1:41:14 PM
I still dont understand, are the Shia (Democrats) and the Sunn(Republican)? The article says its more political than ideological, kinda like the two organized crime families we have running the senet and house! Another fine example of when its time to separate politics from religion.
Posted by: jbinthe757otmail.com | Feb 15, 2007 1:45:26 PM
More than anything it just requires some basic curiosity about the world, and a belief that through understanding and learning we can improve ourselves and the world around us. You can seriously learn the basics about the differences between Shiites and Sunnis in about 10 minutes online. It's not hard--what an absurdity that top officials do not know, and, what's worse, do not appear inclined to learn.
Posted by: Dave J. | Feb 15, 2007 1:45:38 PM
This doesn't suprise me at all. I don't think any member of Congress could find their 'hole with a flashlight and a map. They'd probably need to set up some commission to see if there really was a 'hole, what purpose it served, and whether they could find any profit in it.
Posted by: skidog | Feb 15, 2007 3:01:24 PM
It is mind boggling that anyone in a position of authority in dealings with the war on terror would fail such an elementary quiz on basic radical Islam. Un-flippin-believable, they should be immediately canned, they are obviously making no effort at all to do their job right.
Posted by: Mike D | Feb 15, 2007 3:25:48 PM
Jon Allman; Your ignorance is showing. There's a difference between an Islamist & a Muslim, too. Start by learning that.
Posted by: Lana | Feb 15, 2007 4:15:28 PM
You know, I remember when they did an interview with, I think, the House of Representatives members and asked them if they knew the National Anthem - most of them didn't. And now, I find out they don't even know what they are fighting for or against -that's really pathetic.
Posted by: wowed | Feb 16, 2007 7:03:03 PM
Wow. Any of our soldiers in the military know the difference. Just ask any military in Iraq.
Now lets wait for the $165,200 pay raise. Ha.
Posted by: jw | Feb 18, 2007 1:11:32 PM
Well, It seems that you americans are finally learning that u have no respect for your own soldiers and idiologies, let alone religions and races other than the ones you have dealt with.
operation Iraqi freedom has now been replaced by OPERTAION LET's GET THE HELL OUT OF HERE, just because you had no idea what it would bring you or other people in the world.
after all, i guess i learned this simple but eye-opening lesson that : americans live in glass houses
Posted by: Mehdi | Feb 19, 2007 3:16:33 AM
Mehdi:
Why dont you get real, my friend? You say Americans have no respect for their military, other religions, or races. Can you name another nation with as many nationalities, ethnic groups, and religious diversity as the US? I suppose you believe Islam is such a tolerant religion, even though it was a religion some used as an excuse in their sick mind to behead people. You, my friend, need to swallow a dose of reality.
Posted by: Salameh | Feb 20, 2007 4:53:57 PM
If you want to know more about the history of Islam and its relationship with the West read some of the works of Bernard Lewis.
Posted by: Keith Sharwood | Feb 27, 2007 12:16:40 AM
Post a comment

Stray Guns in Baghdad
For McCain, Another Problem Fundraiser