« Previous | Main | Next »

FBI on the Lookout for Phony Heroes This Memorial Day Weekend

May 25, 2007 10:24 AM

Fbi_on_the_look_mn_2 FBI agents and veterans will be on the lookout this Memorial Day weekend for phony military heroes, a disquieting trend that officials say has grown substantially in the years of the war with Iraq.

"I probably get three to five calls a day about someone spotted with suspicious decorations," said Doug Sterner, who passes along the tips to veterans groups and the FBI.

Sterner operates the Web site Home of Heroes, which is dedicated to honoring true military heroes.

Photos: Phony Military Heroes: Medals of Dishonor

"I'll be damned if I sit idly by while some wannabe phony wears awards that real heroes gave their lives for," Sterner said.

Among the most recent examples is Louis Lowell McGuinn of New York City.

He claimed to be a lieutenant colonel in the United States Army, often appearing at military events wearing an impressive array of decorations, including a Purple Heart, Silver Star and the Distinguished Service Cross.

But law enforcement officials say it was a ruse and that McGuinn was discharged from the Army in 1968 as a private, with none of the decorations he claimed.

Last month, FBI agents arrested McGuinn and charged him with wearing unearned medals and badges in violation of federal law. They say he posed as a highly decorated military officer in order to get a job with an underwater marine security company.

McGuinn pleaded not guilty and was released on $5,000 bail with his travel restricted. When contacted by ABC News, he declined to comment on the case. 

The FBI and veterans groups say there are more and more decorated phonies turning up every day, and when they are caught, the punishment varies.

In one recent case in St. Louis, businessman Gerald Weilbacher received only two years probation and a $3,000 fine after pleading guilty to federal charges of wearing Marine Corps medals he did not earn, including the Navy Cross, the Corps' second highest medal.

The 400-pound Weilbacher never served in the Marines and was spotted at one Marine Corps veterans event as a phony because "he was too fat to be a Marine,"  according to one veteran.

In contrast, Michael Bramlett of Springfield, Mo., was sentenced to six months in federal prison without parole for claiming to be a Marine Captain and wearing unauthorized medals that included a Silver Star, Navy Cross and a Purple Heart for combat in Iraq.

At his sentencing on April 3, U.S. Attorney Bradley Schlozman said, "This impostor received the maximum penalty for his dishonorable conduct. Such disrespect for the brave men and women serving in our nation's forces won't be tolerated."

FBI Agent Michael Sandborn works to track down and expose phony military heroes. 

"In cemeteries overseas, there are 124,913 Americans who paid for their Purple Hearts with their lives, and these impostors purchase theirs over the Internet and at surplus stores," he told ABC News. 

Recent passage of the Stolen Valor Act now makes any misrepresentation of military decorations punishable by up to a year in jail.

Watchdogs like Doug Sterner think that even with the tougher law, military phonies will still be out there tarnishing the image of the true military heroes.

Sterner says, "It's so prevalent that you're never going to catch and prosecute all of them."

Do you have a tip for Brian Ross & the Investigative Team?

May 25, 2007 | Permalink | User Comments (138)

User Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Well, there are laws say that a person can't impersonate a police officer, so it should be the same regarding military personnel. It's one thing to dress up for Halloween, it's another to dress up and trick people to think you're an actual military person. So, I say they're doing the right thing to stop these phonies.

Posted by: Jupmod | May 25, 2007 12:28:01 PM

mark, I am fine, thanks for asking :)
just M.O. here, but laws are too leniant these days. crimes are rising, jails getting overfilled, more taxpayers money wasted on these scumbags. maybe the laws should be more intimidating and carry more fear. Like if you murder or rape, you lose your life; you steal you lose a hand. Could be deemed somewhat barbariac, but it could also make a person think twice before he/she commits a crime. to a criminal, there should be no such thing as cruel and unusual punishment. take that loser who beat up the 70 year old vet just because. let that POS get placed in a room with one of the family members of the vet with a hand axe. he already doesnt deserve to live anyways(offtopic)

Posted by: NJ | May 25, 2007 12:29:08 PM

Proposed: NEW PROGRAM FOR FAKE HERO/HERO WANNABEES
Each imposter should be arrested by the FBI. Then provide them with a current Battle Dress Uniform, give them a BB gun, a copy of ARABIC MADE EASY, a 1 year supply of MREs,a pair of Groucho glasses with nose, then fly them to Iraq and drop them off alone to guard a street corner ... a minimum of 25 miles from the nearest US Military operations area. If they survive a year on their own, great! If they do, then they might get a "I survived" medal to brag about. If not, oh well...

Posted by: Paul | May 25, 2007 12:37:44 PM

Paul, that made me LOL..good idea too. I'd vote for it :)

Posted by: NJ | May 25, 2007 12:41:20 PM

NJ: Wouldn't being more strict just make jails fill even faster? Maybe we should just do what you're suggesting. There are plenty of great models for your justice system in the Middle East. We could just copy Saudi Arabia, Iran, Pakistan, or Afphganistan before the Taliban fell. Those are all excellent models to choose from. I'm not saying these guys shouldn't go to jail, but to say someone should have their hand chopped off is outrageous. I hope you have never committed any sort of crime in your life or made a bad decision.

Posted by: Heath | May 25, 2007 12:55:18 PM

Heath:
An alternative as stated above a few times would be to ship criminals off overseas to do very hard labor, that way they aren't in jail sitting there.For example, send them to Africa or some place to help build homes and water, sewerage systems; work that is extremely hard labor but also has positive outcomes.

Posted by: NJ | May 25, 2007 12:59:07 PM

The wearing of Military honors by those not entitled to them is despicable and wrong, and should be punished to the highest degree available to law enforcement. This behavior is an affront to the men and women who served their country and EARNED those awards. I have dressed at halloween as an airmen, but have taken great pains to never display medals or ribbons, and have always made sure that while the costume was fairly authentic, I DID NOT, even on that day claim to really be a colonel or major, etc. Moreover, it was not done to defraud people and to gain jobs, benefits, or money from the recognition, but to honor the armed forces in special Halloween service persons events. Impersonating an officer is especially defrauding when the person is an ex-military individual and knows quite well the military code of conduct and regulations on insignia.

And for Eoghan, I am especially saddened to hear that you consider yourself 'irrelevant', since that is wholly untrue. This weekend, especially, your sacrifice and those of your comrades back to the Revolutionary War needs to be remembered vividly and clearly, since it is a reflection of the cost of freedom. Jefferson said "The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the Blood of Patriots and tyrants", we shall dismiss the tyrants and utterly forget them, but I will grieve the Patriots, and the cost exacted from each and every one and mourn the payments we have made.

Posted by: Shawn | May 25, 2007 1:01:01 PM

For those who take this too lightly: I guess I should lie about my military honors and ranking, just so I can get a better job, privileged benefits, and the like over 'non-military participated' folk. In addition, I guess it's ok for me to lie to the younger, gullible youth about what I did as a war hero, going against what true history states. I guess you boneheads would lie about your high GPA and making Magna Cum Lada, being CFO of some big-time bank industry, yada yada yada. There are just some people in this world who are as ignorant as those lousy wannabe singers on American Idol and yet, they buy into your pack of lies.

Posted by: The Real Ben | May 25, 2007 1:07:54 PM

I understand that this is wrong, but doesn't the FBI have better things to do than chase imposters? A waste of Taxpayers monies....

Posted by: quilts2love | May 25, 2007 1:12:54 PM

We earned the metals that we were AWARDED. Any one who want to wear them can certainly apply to the service of your choice and see if you can fullfill all the entrance requirements. Then if they have the cahones to be able to survive and take orders without question and serve and maybe even die for our Wonderful Country, they too can wear those ribbons awarded to them. Until then, the COWARDS should be tried convicted and allowed to meet the United States Marines that Control Levenworth! Then we will see what kind of metal they are made of.

Posted by: John Adams Ret USAF | May 25, 2007 1:16:34 PM

Question for you NJ, did you ever serve or are you making rants on stuff that doesn't concern you? If it's the latter then you are just as big of a posser as these guys.

Posted by: Maximus | May 25, 2007 1:27:39 PM

Don't let yourselves be fooled into calling these imposters "poor slobs" or think that they only have a "fixation" on receiving accolades for things they did not do. They do this for the perks.

Have you ever seen a stranger anonymously pick up a restaurant tab for a soldier in uniform? I have...it was heart-warming. I happened to be dining with that soldier. He returned from the restroom and became embarrassed when I told him what had happened. He said he didn't deserve that because he had not yet served in Iraq or any other battle field. I told him that he deserved it for being in uniform and willing to go when his time did come up. This is just one example of the kindness that some civilians offer to soldiers.

These imposters are in this game for the perks. That is called "gain by defrauding" and it is a felony offense. Since they are defrauding by using government materials, it becomes a federal offense. They deserve any jail-time or penalty that any other fraudulent criminal receives.

Posted by: ARSailorMom | May 25, 2007 1:28:25 PM

There are far too many Americans being criminalized by absurd laws which will ruin their lives forever, because now they are unemployable convicted felons, and have an arrest record. The silly USA military medals are not even made of precious metals such as silver and gold, and the USA need to stop giving out "Junk metal," medals to our brave USA soldiers. If somebody wants to pretend that they have been in the Army, "So what," it should be a compliment, considering how many young Americans have gotten killed in four un-declared wars, Korean War, Vietnam War, 1st Gulf War,(125,000) and now the barbaric current Iraqi war which has seen 4,000 USA soldiers killed, and at least 25 American soldiers have been tortured, casterated, burned, and then slowly beheaded with a dull, rusty knife. So the FBI should spend their time investigating Hallibruton's sinful practices, instead of arresting harmless American citizens who love the military. Hell let's stop having all the big Halloween parties if it's against the law to pretend to be somebody that you are not!

Posted by: RedMoons | May 25, 2007 1:29:33 PM

I am a civilian, working for the military, and believe it is a disgrace when an undeserved person wears the uniform or medals. However shameful it is, the only crime should be if they use it for personal or financial gain. If they are delusional they need mental help, not jail time.

Posted by: technopeasant | May 25, 2007 1:29:40 PM

SILLY USA MILITARY MEDALS!?!?

RedMoons....you are beyond words. At least beyond words permitted in this blog. You don't deserve the freedoms those "silly medals" have given you. You are a ....oh....I just can't say it because I'll get reported.

Posted by: ARSailorMom | May 25, 2007 1:31:39 PM


They say that imitation is the greatest form of flattery. I have a friend that always wishes he had become a Marine. I was a Marine for 8 years. He walks around and does the ooh-rah stuff and talks about "his beloved Marine Corps". Part of me is flattered because I know he admires me, but then another part of me is sad that he tries to grasp onto something he is not. He is not however a criminal.

I may be an only child, but I have millions of brothers and sisters. I live close to Arlington and amongst the rows of white stones, I see parent's, spouses and comrades mourning heroes who no longer have a voice. These people however have us to protect their legacy and honor their sacrifice.

Being an admiring, misguided and delusional soul is not a crime. Stealing an award and a hallowed honor is a crime.

Posted by: Marine1 | May 25, 2007 1:32:20 PM

technopeasant....please read my post that went up just prior to the idiot's that called them silly medals. Most of the people that do this are in it for gain and profit. I will agree with you that if they don't quite have a full basket, then they need help, not jail time.

Posted by: ARSailorMom | May 25, 2007 1:37:14 PM

These individuals who claim to be military heroes when they not apparently crave the attention and limelight to fill up their sad and pathetic lives. I feel this is a disgrace to those in our armed forces who gave their all in the defense of this great country including their very lives. To me the sentences they have received for this outrageous afront to the true military heroes has not been adequate enough. I am glad our FBI and any other law enfocement involved in these apprehensions of these individuals continue for as long as it takes.

GOD BLESS THE MEN AND WOMEN IN OUR ARMED FORCES EVERYWHERE!

Posted by: Rose of Texas | May 25, 2007 1:43:30 PM

I spent twelve years active duty and fourteen yeras in the reserves and I am humbled by the sacrifices these young men and women make every day.

These imposters don't need jail time. They need to be publicaly shamed in front of their families, parents, friends and co-workers.

I think anyone who has put on a military uniform... been scared, alone, hurt, captured... would never want to wish pain on a fellow American for dreaming about being "a hero". Didn't we serve so that others could enjoy these eccentricities? If not, what did we fight for in the first place?

Posted by: Turk | May 25, 2007 1:43:34 PM

One other comment. When you see any serviceman or woman, especially if they appear to be very young, please make sure they don't happen to be wearing an JROTC uniform. They are the same dress uniforms the servicemen/women wear and the medals and ribbons those kids earn are quite impressive.

My son just finished 4 years of NJROTC. He was on his way to a community-service project, in full dress blues. The 5 rows of ribbons and the medals he earned filled up most of his jacket breast. We had to make a stop at a store and he became quite embarrassed when a WWII vet commented that he didn't earn that many medals during the war. My son was very quick to tell him that they were ROTC medals and said they didn't hold near the importance that service medals hold. Although he was proud to wear his NJROTC uniform, he was bashful regarding the attention his ribbons drew.

So...just as a precaution, check to see if there is an ROTC patch on the sleeve.

Posted by: ARSailorMom | May 25, 2007 1:48:28 PM

Post a comment