BRIAN ROSS REPORTS
TOP BLOTTER CATEGORIES
- Abramoff Lobbying Scandal
- American Al Qaeda
- Avian Flu
- Beirut Hospital Out of Gas
- CIA
- CIA Secret Prisons
- D.C. Madam Affair
- FBI
- Federal Air Marshal Service
- Homeland Security
- Hurricane Katrina
- Mark Foley Internet Scandal
- Millionaire Sex Scandal
- Nigerian E-mail Scams
- Norman Hsu, Clinton Fundraiser
- NSA: Wiretapping
- Osama bin Laden
- Payola
- Pharmacy Investigation
- Speaker of the House Dennis Hastert
- Terror
- U.K. Airline Terror Plot
- U.K. Bombing Attempts
- Wen Ho Lee
- William Jefferson
- Zarqawi
Watchdogs: China Bullies Journalists, IOC Stands Mute
November 30, 2007 11:29 AM
In advance of hosting the next Summer Olympic Games, China continues to bully journalists, and a human rights group says the International Olympic Committee (IOC) has ignored its responsibility to do something about it.
In a letter to IOC president Jacques Rogges yesterday, Reporters Without Borders (or RSF, the acronym for its French name) blamed the abuses on his inaction.
"Mr. Rogge, it is your silence that has unfortunately made all these abuses possible," said RSF secretary-general Robert Ménard in the letter, referring to the roughly 100 journalists and human rights activists who are currently detained in China.
Since Beijing adopted new rules allowing foreign journalists to work more freely in China 11 months ago, Ménard said RSF has documented more than 50 cases of harassment of journalists, demonstrating the new rules have not taken effect. The relaxed rules expire in October 2008 following the close of the Olympic Games.
On Nov. 20, Barbara Lüthi, the Beijing correspondent of the Swiss TV channel Schweizer Fernsehen, and her Chinese camerawoman were detained for seven hours and beaten by authorities in a village near Beijing where unrest led to the deaths of several residents in 2005, according to RSF. RSF said local authorities have prevented at least five foreign journalists from working in the village.
Click Here for Full Blotter Coverage.
Also on Nov. 20, Mathias Brascheler and Monika Fisher, a Swiss husband-and-wife team of photographers, were detained for three hours in Hubei province while preparing a report on villagers who had been threatened and beaten in connection with a land dispute, according to RSF.
A spokesperson for the IOC said that a great deal of effort is being made by the Beijing Organizing Committee for the Games (BOCOG) and the Chinese authorities to uphold Beijing's assurances that there will be no restrictions on journalists reporting on the Olympic Games.
"There is work still to do, but the IOC believes in the good will of the Chinese to deliver the necessary environment for the 20,000 accredited media who will come for the Games. The IOC is working closely with BOCOG to encourage and guide their work so that the assurances can be delivered," a spokesperson said.
A Chinese Embassy spokesman said that China, like all countries, has some "off-limits" areas where journalists should not go, and that there has always been a gap between the requirements of journalists and the requirements of various governments of countries. He said that China has already set in place rules for reporting on the Beijing Olympic Games, and it will stick to its commitment and will try its best to provide service to create "favorable conditions for foreign and Chinese reporters."
Ménard also expressed concern that the Games' organizers said this week they were going to conduct ID checks on all accredited journalists covering the Games and that China's General Administration of Press and Publications (GAPP) announced it was going to compile files on the approximately 30,000 journalists coming to the Games.
RSF Asia director Vincent Brossel said that in light of China's human rights history, such close surveillance of journalists caused RSF to fear vast censorship of the Games.
The IOC office said all people that are accredited for the Olympic Games will receive a background check by the local security authorities.
"This is a standard security procedure [and] is not new to the Beijing Games," a spokesperson said. The spokesperson added that at the Games all accredited media's details will be held on a database in order to facilitate the accreditation process. "This is only natural and is the same as for previous editions of the Games. For non-accredited media, inquiries should be addressed to the Chinese Foreign Ministry for more information."
The Chinese Embassy spokesman said that no such files would be kept on foreign journalists and that the Chinese Foreign Ministry had clarified such misleading reporting two weeks ago.
"Journalists need to register with the Olympic organizational committee according to standard procedure, but there is no plan to establish a database on journalists," the spokesman said.
RSF is one of several groups outraged by China's continued crackdown on free press. In August, the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) published a report to illustrate the "yawning gap" between China's poor press freedom record and the promises made in 2001 when Beijing was awarded the Olympic Games.
"We're 10 months away, and there is still not a free flow of information," said CPJ Asia program coordinator Bob Dietz.
Dietz said China has fallen short thus far in its pledge to the international community.
"Chinese journalists are in jail. Vast censorship rules are in place. Harassment, attacks and threats occur with impunity," he said.
Do you have a tip for Brian Ross and the Investigative Team?
November 30, 2007 | Permalink | User Comments (8)
Freedoms in China continue to be limited. The Olympic Games are an opportunity to try to move the Beijing regime to improve freedom of the press. Keep shining light on this matter. The more that is written about, the greater the pressure for China to change.
Posted by: Gisela | Nov 30, 2007 1:05:38 PM
For a country that was so fully restricted under the recent communist regime they have definitely taken some positive steps in the right direction. The Olympics are sure to be only the beginning of the transition. It's a shame that the US standards of free speech have not yet been reached within China proper but they are becoming more open and fair one step at a time.
Their sheer population and cultural commitment to move slowly and in such a calculated manner assures me that they will eventually reach their free-speech goals, but it may not be in my lifetime and definitely not by 2008.
Posted by: Michael | Nov 30, 2007 3:21:00 PM
Freedom of the press? China? - all I have to say is.... Tienanmen Square. Despite the words and promises, China has and will continue to mold the media to her liking.
Pressure is good!!! Writing about these types of contradictions and violations increases public awareness.
Just as in the US, public opinion is the only "super-power" to combat against such atrocities Keep the pressure on!!!
Posted by: tattoo | Nov 30, 2007 3:44:01 PM
Having just dined with a prominent foreign media correspondent in Beijing a few weeks ago, and heard some mind-boggling stories about the harassment that he was consistently facing, I am dismayed, though not surprised, by the Chinese authorities' inability to stand behind their pledge for greater openness. It seems that one of the problems, though, is the disconnect between central policy and local enforcement of those policies, a challenge for the CCP across a variety of issues.
Posted by: Andrew | Nov 30, 2007 5:39:40 PM
By inviting the world for the Olympic Games, China has opened itself in an unprecedented way. For all of us who will not be there to see for ourselves, press reports are an invaluable window into this amazing country as it adapts to a more open society and a more integrated role in the world. Vigorous insistence on access and free reporting will stress their policies, but since they can't close off the process they have set in motion with the Olympics, it is likely to move them forward: beneficial to them and to the world. Meanwhile, this sort of scrutiny is the best leverage available to protect journalists from abuse.
Posted by: Julie | Nov 30, 2007 8:59:40 PM
Boycott Beijing! Climate apartheid!
Posted by: Ayeah | Dec 1, 2007 8:54:29 AM
Just remember the Munich Olympics and look at the place in world opinion today enjoyed by Germany and the Palestinian Movement.
Munich should have been the last Olympics
Posted by: electric | Dec 1, 2007 11:32:32 AM
Americans have built the largest and best equipped Military s in the World, unfortunately they are not in the Free World.
The military relationships between China, Russia, India and countries of the Middle East are downright scary.
Posted by: Guardian | Dec 1, 2007 1:10:17 PM
Post a comment

Stray Guns in Baghdad
For McCain, Another Problem Fundraiser