Rick Klein is ABC News' Senior Political Reporter and author of The Note's morning look at the upcoming day in politics. Throughout the day, ABC News' political team contributes to The Note with the very latest news and analysis from the nation's capital.
To email Rick Klein, click here.
RECENT POSTS
- AARP Endorses Cloture Vote, Not Yet Reid's Bill
- McCain Targets Ben Nelson on Health Care Vote
- 'Top Line' -- Ambassador Oprah? Senator Oprah?
- Sen. Brown: Health Care Bill Needs More Subsidies
- GOP Leaders: Obama Has ‘Emboldened Our Enemies' with Afghanistan Deliberations
- Burris Cleared of Legal Wrongdoing -- But With Swipe from Ethics Committee
- Friends, in Need: Obama Faces Backlash on Jobs, Economy
- Doug Hampton: Ensign Knowingly Broke Ethics Rules on Lobbying
- The Note's Must-Reads for Friday, November 20, 2009
- Did Illinois Guv Nod Off at Health Care Debate?
THE NOTE CATEGORIES
- 2010
- Afghanistan
- Bill Clinton
- CIA
- Congress
- Democratic party
- Environment
- Financial Reform
- GOP
- Gov. Mark Sanford
- Gov. Sarah Palin
- Guantanamo
- Health Care
- Hillary Clinton
- Immigration
- Iran
- Iraq
- John McCain
- Mitt Romney
- North Korea
- Obama Agenda
- Politics Live
- President Obama
- Republican Party
- Ronald Reagan
- Sen. John Ensign
- Senate
- Sonia Sotomayor
- Stimulus
- Sunday Shows
- Supreme Court
- Ted Kennedy
- The Note
- The Note Must-Reads
- Top Line
- Vice President Biden
- Virginia
MONTHLY ARCHIVES
« Previous | Main | Next »
Dem Defections Pile Up on Health Care
November 06, 2009 8:22 PM
ABC News’ Rick Klein reports: Could the health care bill be in real trouble in the House?
The Democratic defections are starting to pile up in advance of a vote scheduled for tomorrow on sweeping health reform efforts. (That schedule could slip to Sunday or beyond, if the votes aren’t there.)
According to the National Republican Congressional Committee -- which, of course, has an interest in watching this vote particularly closely -- 15 House Democrats and counting are saying publicly that they’ll oppose the measure when it reaches a vote.
Democrats can afford only 40 such defections to squeak the bill through. They’d prefer to win with room to spare.
The Democrats who’ve said -- either in interviews or press releases -- that they’re opposing the bill include: Rep. Travis Childers (Miss.); Rep. John Adler (N.J.); Rep. Walt Minnick (Idaho); Rep. Stephanie Herseth Sandlin (S.Dak.); Rep. Suzanne Kosmas (Fla.); Rep. Frank Kratovil (Md.); Rep. Larry Kissell (N.C.); Rep. Bart Gordon (Tenn.); Rep. Dan Boren (Okla.); Rep. Jim Matheson (Utah); Rep. Michael McMahon (N.Y.); Rep. John Tanner (Tenn.); Rep. Brian Baird (Wash.); Rep. Harry Teague (N.M.); and Rep. Collin Peterson (Minn.).
House Democratic aides say the list contains no surprises so far.
Some of the Democrats’ statements leave a bit of wiggle room. Plus -- as ABC’s George Stephanopoulos is reporting -- Democratic leaders are working behind the scenes to answer concerns among conservative Democrats about how the bill would handle funding for abortions.
But -- keeping in mind that many members of Congress prefer to announce their intentions with their votes, not press releases -- the defections suggest that reaching 218 remains a serious challenge for Democrats on the eve of the vote.
“If this bill is the political winner Nancy Pelosi claims it is, then why are Democrats fighting over who gets to vote against it?” NRCC spokesman Ken Spain said in a statement.
November 6, 2009 | Permalink | Share | User Comments (52)
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.
While questioning funding for abortion is certainly a worthy cause, why aren't these rational Dems questioning the funding for the whole darn bill? This bill is ludicrous. No one knows what's buried in it's absurd 2000 pages. Can't a Democrat stand up and say we can't afford another entitlement program. We can't borrow or print enough money to pay for this disaster of a bill.
Posted by: pam | Nov 6, 2009 8:48:47 PM
Let's all hope that there are enough sane and independent thinkers in the House of Representatives who will tell Nancy P. where she can stck her stinker of a bill and prevent its passage. The American people do not want this 2000 page mess!!!!
Posted by: Mohican | Nov 6, 2009 9:10:20 PM
Of course it's going to be tough to make it to 218 votes. The multi-trillion dollar health care industry has spent literally hundreds of millions of dollars to kill this bill and bought one entire party outright.
America can't afford the insane spiraling of health care costs. If we continue to spend twice as much as the average first world nation (and get on average _lower_ life expectancy for it) America simply won't be a first world nation in a decade's time. Our businesses are weighed down with massive health care costs that no other first world nation corporation is saddled with.
We can't afford the status quo anymore. A trillion dollars a year is sucked out of America's economy versus other first world nations and for what? I believe America is the best nation on Earth, but the cold hard facts show that our health care - at twice the cost - isn't even making average.
Posted by: jhw539 | Nov 6, 2009 9:11:06 PM
jhw539
Have no fear. Obama will take care of
his own.....with Soros money, if neces-
sary.
Posted by: grizzlybare | Nov 6, 2009 9:30:50 PM
Has Speaker Pelosi posted the bill online? She promised it would be online for public view for the 72 hours prior to the vote.
Posted by: spoutinghorn | Nov 6, 2009 9:32:58 PM
Have no fear. Obama will take care of
his own.....with Soros money, if neces-
sary.
grizzlybare | Nov 6, 2009 9:30:50 PM
What does that even mean? Is the right wing now just stringing together ominous words like some sort of malevolent sentence generating program?
Posted by: jhw539 | Nov 6, 2009 9:44:46 PM
Has Speaker Pelosi posted the bill online?
spoutinghorn | Nov 6, 2009 9:32:58 PM
The main bill has been posted for over three days. It speaks volumes about your false concern that you are unaware of this.
Posted by: jhw539 | Nov 6, 2009 9:46:44 PM
Pay your $15,000 per American family per year healthcare bill to your government, or be fined $250,000 and/or spend 5 years in jail. It's in the Bill! http://tinyurl.com/ykhk3k3
DJ | Nov 6, 2009 10:39:36 PM
More paranoid exageration from the right wing. Yeah, if you DON'T PAY YOUR TAXES, including the watered down penalty for not carrying health insurance (ie, freeloading off the ER system for catastrophic coverage), you can go to jail. Guess what - if you claim your dog as a dependent to not pay income tax, you could go to jail to.
BREAKING NEWS FROM REPUBLICANS: IF YOU REFUSE TO PAY YOUR TAXES YOU MAY GO TO JAIL - THIS IS THE DEMOCRATS FAULT!!11!
Posted by: jhw539 | Nov 6, 2009 10:56:35 PM
Hey Congress . . .remember you work for us. It is really quite simple. If you vote for this bill, we are going to vote YOU out of office.
Posted by: JoeCollins | Nov 6, 2009 11:11:11 PM
This is truly a great day for America. A day where no American should have to die from lack of health care. I for one am glad to see this historic day and am glad I gave Obama and the Democrats my vote.
It is a pleasure to see American's stand up to those who claim to be looking out for America. The constitution begins with "We the people..." and tomorrow the voices of the majority will finally be heard over the minority, corporations and special interest.
Posted by: Chuck | Nov 6, 2009 11:19:09 PM
I cannot believe the amount of clueless and ignorant people who post here. This is a great day? Over a trillion dollars about to be siphoned over is a great day? Get your head out of your asses, we are broke!! Completely and utterly broke and no amount of stimulus is going to save us.
Yes, we spend a lot on health care, but we are also the richest country in the world. There are plenty of proposals to reduce health costs - yet the Pelosi bill does NOT DO THAT.
Posted by: arkady | Nov 6, 2009 11:38:24 PM
The fine or jail clause is in the Pelosi bill, but not the Senate bill. jhw539 doesn't have all the information. As to special interests, the unions are getting big time payments out of this bill. I don't know where all this strong arming from the insurance companies is coming from. Obama's people threatened them into silence, like they do all dissenters. Health care will not be free. You will have to pay for it. The IRS will decide what you can afford. That's in the bill whether you want to believe it or not.
Posted by: pam | Nov 6, 2009 11:49:29 PM
You still-clueless HopeyChangey types had better get a clue REAL fast! If you think 10.2% unemployment, the highest in 26 years and the second highest since the Great Depression is bad, just wait until this $1.8 Trillion Bill is passed! The single largest government program in our nation's history. The second record government boondoggle since the immaculation of the great and wonderful messiah, T.O.T.U.S.
And to the moron who posted the brainless comments about "pay your taxes or go to jail now": you DO realize that this $15,000/yr per family is in ADDITION TO what you already pay in taxes! That's $1,250 month IN ADDITION to what you ALREADY PAY in taxes! So help yourselves to "FREE 0bummer Healthcare" or go to jail for 5 years. This from the candidate who lied repeatedly during the campaign that "95% of Americans will NOT see a tax increase" yada, yada. Good luck with that!
How's that Hopenchange crap workin' out for ya?
Posted by: DJ | Nov 6, 2009 11:54:50 PM
"The fine or jail clause is in the Pelosi bill, but not the Senate bill. jhw539 doesn't have all the information."
pam | Nov 6, 2009 11:49:29 PM
CITE THE PAGE AND LINE NUMBER. The bill is posted online and has been for a while now - we all have all the information. Jailing is not in the bill. The bill cites a fine be levied as a tax if you do not carry insurance. THAT'S IT. If you don't pay your taxes, yes you can go to jail, happened to almost 500 people last year. How shocking.
Again, if you are not grossly exaggerating and/or flat out lying, CITE THE PAGE AND LINE NUMBER MANDATING "JAILING".
Posted by: jhw539 | Nov 6, 2009 11:58:36 PM
.. and one more thing JHW: you stated "More paranoid exageration [sic] from the right wing.."
So 3 things: (1) either you can't read (you know .. I posted a link which gives the exact part of the Bill verbatim which describes the penalties), or (2) you are incapable of clicking link. Or maybe you're just going for that ignorance-thing that it takes to be a follower of 0bummer and are afraid to read the truth, and (3) you can't spell.
Posted by: DJ | Nov 6, 2009 11:59:15 PM
Yes, we spend a lot on health care, but we are also the richest country in the world.
arkady | Nov 6, 2009 11:38:24 PM
And for spending on average twice as much per person our life expectancy is LOWER than average - even though we smoke less and have literally seen acts of Congress to keep a brain dead woman 'alive'.
Posted by: jhw539 | Nov 7, 2009 12:00:01 AM
Sheez! You 0bama people are a clueless lot!
Posted by: DJ | Nov 7, 2009 12:02:25 AM
I'm going to make it even easier for you. Us intelligent people who DIDN'T fall under the spell of the messiah-of-Hopenchange always have to pick up the slack (and pay the bill).
"“Criminal penalties
Prosecution is authorized under the Code for a variety of offenses. Depending on the level of the noncompliance, the following penalties could apply to an individual:
• Section 7203 – misdemeanor willful failure to pay is punishable by a fine of up to $25,000 and/or imprisonment of up to one year.
• Section 7201 – felony willful evasion is punishable by a fine of up to $250,000 and/or imprisonment of up to five years.” [page 3]"
Posted by: DJ | Nov 7, 2009 12:06:30 AM
I'm also going to call you out on your "life expectancy is lower than average" statement. I want you to back that up with actual FACTS, with citations for reference. Because I have intimate knowledge in this discipline, and I KNOW you can't back that up!
Waiting ..
Posted by: DJ | Nov 7, 2009 12:13:03 AM
I'm also going to call you out on your "life expectancy is lower than average" statement. I want you to back that up with actual FACTS, with citations for reference. Because I have intimate knowledge in this discipline, and I KNOW you can't back that up!
Waiting ..
Posted by: DJ | Nov 7, 2009 12:13:03 AM
The current CIA world factbook, life expectency by country. United States is FIFTIETH in the world, just ahead of Albania. Google it up.
So does documented and cited reality have any impact on your opinions at all? And your intimate knowledge seems to be wrong - go ahead and pick out the first world countries from that list and you'll see how woeful the US life expectancy really is. Where is your cite?
Posted by: jhw539 | Nov 7, 2009 12:21:49 AM
Post a comment
POLITICAL VIDEOS
THE NOTE BLOG ROLL
- ABC News -- George Stephanopoulos
- ABC News -- Jake Tapper
- ABC News Politics
- ABC News -- The Numbers
- ABC News -- The Blotter
- The American Prospect -- TAPPED
- The Atlantic -- Politics Channel
- The Boston Globe -- Political Intelligence
- Center for American Progress -- Think Progress
- Center for Responsive Politics
- The Chicago Sun-Times -- Lynn Sweet
- The Chicago Tribune -- The Swamp
- Drudge Report
- FactCheck.org
- FiveThirtyEight
- Heritage Foundation -- The Foundry
- The Hill -- Briefing Room
- The Hotline
- The Huffington Post
- The Los Angeles Times -- Top of the Ticket
- NPR -- Political Junkie
- National Review -- The Corner
- The New Republic -- The Plank
- The New York Times -- The Caucus
- Newsweek -- The Gaggle
- Political Wire -- Taegan Goddard
- Politico -- Ben Smith
- Politico -- Mike Allen’s Playbook
- PolitiFact
- Real Clear Politics
- Talking Points Memo
- Time -- The Page
- USA Today -- On Politics
- Variety -- Wilshire & Washington
- The Wall Street Journal -- Capital Journal
- The Washington Post -- The Fix
- The Washington Post -- 44

